Can i make a co2 injected tank low maintenance?

idkausernamesoyeah

Well Known
Member
Messages
1,369

Advertisement
By keeping the lights dim, which is even more easy to do with CO2 gas injection, and temperature low.
 

Advertisement
So, I'm new and chiming in hoping to learn something.

What is considered low maintenance?

I don't do anything different before co2 than now with co2 aside from throwing away floaters.
 
  • Thread Starter
  • #4
So, I'm new and chiming in hoping to learn something.

What is considered low maintenance?

I don't do anything different before co2 than now with co2 aside from throwing away floaters.
low maintenance is just doing less for the tank less often. Like less water changes, less plant trimming, etc
 
low maintenance is just doing less for the tank less often. Like less water changes, less plant trimming, etc

Got it.

Figured water change intervals wouldn't be dictated at all by co2 injection. In fact, I would think it'd give you more time between intervals due to the nitrate intake from the increased growth of plants IE water changes less often?
 
Figured water change intervals wouldn't be dictated at all by co2 injection. In fact, I would think it'd give you more time between intervals due to the nitrate intake from the increased growth of plants IE water changes less often?
That would seem to make sense, but it hasn't panned out that way in my experience. Just the opposite. My high-energy, high-tech tanks demand far more water changes and other maintenance.

Essentially, the plants grow a lot faster in a high-tech tank (assuming the same lighting and temperature). To make sure the plants don't become deficient with this fast growth, fertilizers must be added. It's way too difficult to add the perfect amount of every fertilizer for a given high-tech tank, so the easy solution is to just add a lot of everything. But, to make sure those fertilizers don't build up to toxic levels, regular large water changes need to be done.

Furthermore, if lighting is bright (typical of most CO2 injected tanks), organic waste has a tendency to trigger algae. (Organic waste build up doesn't seem to cause the same problems in a low-energy, low-tech tank.) Plants create organic waste through the loss of old leaves (and possibly other secretions and such). If plants are growing super-fast, they grow a lot more leaves and create a lot more organic waste. Therefore, to keep organic waste build up from triggering algae growth in a high-tech tank, regular large water changes need to be done.

The need for water changes in a high-tech planted tank is not all about nitrate build up.

The way around the need for so much maintenance in a CO2 enriched tank (as ruud stated above) is to lower the light and temp enough so that the tank works more like a low-tech one. I've done this myself, and it does reduce the amount of maintenance required (especially trimming). In my experience, the plants still grow a smidgeon faster, but they retain much of their high-tech growth forms.

Personally, I think low-light, CO2 tanks are an under-utilized approach.
 

Advertisement
Personally, I think low-light, CO2 tanks are an under-utilized approach.
What are the advantages? Many people use (as I used to myself) CO2 so that they can grow a wider range of more demanding high light plants. Otherwise you would be spending extra money on a tank that would appear to be quite similar to an ordinary low tech planted tank, but with a little more maintenance.

I guess one advantage might be that you could leave the lights on a little longer without the same algae risk?
 
What are the advantages?
I think there's a few:
  1. Water changes can be a source of CO2 instability in low-tech tanks, because tap water often has more dissolved CO2 than tank water. Therefore, in low-tech tanks, water changes can trigger algae that grow when CO2 is unstable (like BBA and staghorn). With proper CO2 injection, these algae types rarely show up.
  2. Plants can divert more resources to using available light if they don't have to deal with low CO2. Therefore, plants can grow in even lower light levels if CO2 is readily available.
  3. Many plants are easier to grow if CO2 is added.
  4. Plants look a bit different when growing in CO2 enriched conditions (aesthetic consideration).
  5. Most natural habitats have higher dissolved CO2 levels than a typical low-tech tank; therefore, injecting CO2 can provide a better approximation of nature.
 
Hello i have a lower light tank with co2 injection (1bps) light on 7hours. I havent done a water change in like 2-3 months. I add a small amount of ferts macro and micro pre mixed salts every few days. Evrything is growing great and not much alage. Only thing i should do right now is trim some plants because its looking too overgrown.
 
If yuou want a low-maintenance setup, make sure you get a proper CO2 injection system including a 5# CO2 tank, dual stage regulator, solenoid valve on a timer and a good bubble counter. Such a setup will cost around $250. With such as setup, the CO2 tank should only need to be refilled every 3-4 months. Small CO2 bottles need frequent refilling, which is contrary to your low-maintenance scheme.
 
Advertisement



Advertisement








Advertisement




Back
Top Bottom