Will Coral Sand Increase Ph Like Crushed Coral?

ivyninja

Member
My pH has dropped to 6.4 and my cycle seems to have stalled.

I went to my LFS and asked if they had crushed coral, and he gave me a bag of coral sand. Is that the same thing, or will it at least have the same effect?

I'm planning to put a handful in a stocking in next to the pump (which is in a back compartment of the tank) - does that sound ok?

I will need to get a KH/GH test kit and eventually try to figure out how to manage levels long term, but for now I just want to get my cycle going again as soon as possible.
 

Asomeone

Member
If the sand is just a finer version of crushed coral than yes It'll have an effect. If you're not setting up a marine tank I question why you're using this as a substrate at all. For certain cichlids this makes sense since it raises PH but otherwise...why bother? Your Ph seems very low while using crushed coral, as it normally raises the PH I use crushed coral to bring the PH up in a african cichlid tank to around 8.0
 
  • Thread Starter

ivyninja

Member
Asomeone said:
If the sand is just a finer version of crushed coral than yes. If you're not setting up a marine tank I question why you're using this as a substrate at all. For certain cichlids this makes sense since it raises PH but otherwise...why bother?
I'm not using it as a substrate - I have river sand/gravel as my substrate. As I said in my original post, I am cycling my tank and the pH has dropped too low and the cycle has stalled.
 

fissh

Member
sand will not increase ph.
 
  • Thread Starter

ivyninja

Member
fissh said:
sand will not increase ph.
Regular sand or coral sand?
 

Asomeone

Member
ivyninja said:
I'm not using it as a substrate - I have river sand/gravel as my substrate. As I said in my original post, I am cycling my tank and the pH has dropped too low and the cycle has stalled.
If it is crushed coral it will raise PH, no question.
 

fissh

Member
yes crush coral will increase ph.
 

Momgoose56

Member
ivyninja said:
My pH has dropped to 6.4 and my cycle seems to have stalled.

I went to my LFS and asked if they had crushed coral, and he gave me a bag of coral sand. Is that the same thing, or will it at least have the same effect?

I'm planning to put a handful in a stocking in next to the pump (which is in a back compartment of the tank) - does that sound ok?

I will need to get a KH/GH test kit and eventually try to figure out how to manage levels long term, but for now I just want to get my cycle going again as soon as possible.
"Coral sand" isn't really purely coral but rather exoskeletons of marine animals, mollusks and limestone sand. It does contain limestone but I'd be hesitant putting sand into the filter area because of the risk of damaging the impeller. The other problem with using a fine grained sand is that it packs down and water won't circulate through it very well so it may not be as effective as crushed coral or aragonite. I'd call the lfs and ask if they have aragonite. It's another calcium carbonate rock that works just as well as crushed coral for raising pH and KH.
 
  • Thread Starter

ivyninja

Member
Momgoose56 said:
"Coral sand" isn't really purely coral but rather exoskeletons of marine animals, mollusks and limestone sand. It does contain limestone but I'd be hesitant putting sand into the filter area because of the risk of damaging the impeller. The other problem with using a fine grained sand is that it packs down and water won't circulate through it very well so it may not be as effective as crushed coral or aragonite. I'd call the lfs and ask if they have aragonite. It's another calcium carbonate rock that works just as well as crushed coral for raising pH and KH.
Thanks. I’ve put some coral sand in a media bag in my tank tonight (not near the filter) and will see what happens overnight, but will go to my other LFS tomorrow and see if they have something more suitable.
 
  • Moderator

jdhef

Moderator
Member
What size is this tank? If it isn't too big, just buy a cuttle bone and put it into the tank.
 

Most photos, videos and links are disabled if you are not logged in.

Log in or register to view



Top Bottom