Which one would be better? Help

  1. samantha.h

    samantha.h Valued Member Member

    I have a 20 gallon tank that currently houses 3 mystery snails and will soon also have 2 fancy goldfish. I'm going to buy a new filter that's bigger because I know the goldfish are big waste producers.

    I'm looking at the AquaClear HOB filter. They have one that's for up to 50 gallons that filters 200 Gal/Hr, and they have one that's for up to 70 gallons that filters 300 Gal/Hr.

    For 2 fancy goldfish and 3 mystery snails, would you say the 200/50 or the 300/70 would be better? I'm sure it's obvious but I need some second opinions, please. :)
  2. Camille

    Camille Valued Member Member

    For a 20 gallon I really don't think that the the 300/70 is necessary all you need is the 200/50.

    Good luck Samantha!
  3. B

    Borisbbadd Guest

    I would go with the 200/50.
  4. Meenu

    Meenu Fishlore VIP Member

    since you are going to be overstocking, and goldfish produce a lot of waste, I'd go with the 70, personally.
  5. s

    stanman New Member Member

    I have a 200 on my 20 and it moves a lot of water,I believe thats all you need.The other is overkill for that size tank.
  6. bolivianbaby

    bolivianbaby Fishlore Legend Member

    My vote is for the 70. I have 5 goldies in a 55g. With two goldies in a 20g, there's less gallons of water for the waste. The higher gph, the better, IMO.:)