I'm really glad you found a filter you're happy with!!!hcda24 said:I had the Tidal on a 60 gallon and to be honest I love SeaChem and use them for all chemicals/filtration/etc, but the Tidal filter is not one of their best products. I added their Carbon and Purigen go it and the water bypass became unbearable to the point where I had to run it at half speed just to prevent it. I ended up returning it and biting the bullet on buying a canister filter. Such a better choice. Amazon is a great place to get one for a great price too.
I think you must be right, the larger ones are not fully utile. Glad yours works good, Seachem really makes great products.Ferretlady said:I'm really glad you found a filter you're happy with!!!
I wonder if maybe there are just a few faulty ones out there, or possibly a bit of tweaking Seachem needs to do on the larger models? I recall seeing one Youtube review (on the larger model), in which the guy mentioned the same thing about the overflow (on the larger model). (Though I did see other videos where people were happy with theirs & didn't have any problems. It's quite odd!!!) I finally decide to get it - since Seachem does seem to have a good guarantee on it, and it seemed that most people were happy with it.
I have to say, I am still thrilled with my Tidal 55!! The first week I had it, I'd added a decent amount of their carbon & a purigen pack to it, and had also added a bit more Matrix to the bag of Matrix included with the filter. I specifically watched (and re-checked on several occasions) to see if there was any overflow issue at all at top speed & it was perfectly fine! At present, I've removed the purigen & carbon, since I'm trying to get my cycle started, but I added some extra (sponge/floss?) & it's still doing great at top speed. Once my tank is fully cycled, I'll probably add the Purigen back in at least. I'm really sorry that you had such problems with yours!
But I truly am glad that you found a filter that you love! I've heard a lot of good things about canisters - but my present set-up doesn't really allow for that, and my tank is small enough for HOBs to be sufficient.
What do you mean the larger ones.. I'm planing on either the 75 or the 110, so which would be a better option for this overflow problem on a 30-40gallon, still deciding on the size. And I'm going to turn down the flow a lot on the 110 since I heard that when at full blast, the filters make some noisehcda24 said:I think you must be right, the larger ones are not fully utile. Glad yours works good, Seachem really makes great products.