Tank Size To Large??

Tank size to big??

  • To big

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    9
  • Poll closed .

Dayne Clarke

New Member
Messages
8
Reaction score
1
Points
3
So I caught an awesome sale the other day and couldn't resist purchasing. 1 dollar a gallon and 25% off of any aqueon HOB filter so I bought a 29g tank and a 30g filter didn't go oversized due to only putting one fish in and that's minimal when it comes to ammonia and bad bacteria.
So after a week of cycling and filtering we put my son's betta fish in there. Day 3 he seems to be eating very little. From what I can tell his stomach isn't caved in at all and he seems brighter and more active. The question I'm having is, is there such a thing of having to large of a tank for one fish?
Reason I really bought the tank is to soon put Rosie's in for when I finish my 90g tank which will hold maybe a few piranhas. Thanks everyone who helps out.
 

Mike the fish keeper

Valued Member
Messages
174
Reaction score
57
Points
38
So I caught an awesome sale the other day and couldn't resist purchasing. 1 dollar a gallon and 25% off of any aqueon HOB filter so I bought a 29g tank and a 30g filter didn't go oversized due to only putting one fish in and that's minimal when it comes to ammonia and bad bacteria.
So after a week of cycling and filtering we put my son's betta fish in there. Day 3 he seems to be eating very little. From what I can tell his stomach isn't caved in at all and he seems brighter and more active. The question I'm having is, is there such a thing of having to large of a tank for one fish?
Reason I really bought the tank is to soon put Rosie's in for when I finish my 90g tank which will hold maybe a few piranhas. Thanks everyone who helps out.
Ive heard of Bettas needing short tanks because they come up to take breaths from time to time.
 

happygolucky

Well Known Member
Messages
979
Reaction score
34
Points
73
Experience
2 years
What fin-type is your betta? A fully-finned betta will have a very difficult time getting to the top of the tank for each breath he takes, it will wear him out quickly. Also, a much larger tank can make a fish shy for a few days, but this should wear off quickly.

Do you know what an actual "cycle" is? I am not trying to be condescending at all, but I'm just wondering since you said "after a week of cycling", when it normally takes much longer. Though ammonia/waste build-up is probably not the reason for the betta not eating since it is a small fish in a large tank, it is still important to know.
 

Al913

Fishlore VIP
Messages
7,623
Reaction score
1,909
Points
323
Experience
5 to 10 years
Also, just want to note that when it comes to filters you actually want to judge the size by the gph not what the box say its for. For HOBs you want 8-10x the gph for the size tank so for a 29 gallon you want at least a total gph of 232. For canisters you want at least 5x the gph.
 

FishL:))

Well Known Member
Messages
807
Reaction score
304
Points
78
Experience
2 years
So I caught an awesome sale the other day and couldn't resist purchasing. 1 dollar a gallon and 25% off of any aqueon HOB filter so I bought a 29g tank and a 30g filter didn't go oversized due to only putting one fish in and that's minimal when it comes to ammonia and bad bacteria.
So after a week of cycling and filtering we put my son's betta fish in there. Day 3 he seems to be eating very little. From what I can tell his stomach isn't caved in at all and he seems brighter and more active. The question I'm having is, is there such a thing of having to large of a tank for one fish?
Reason I really bought the tank is to soon put Rosie's in for when I finish my 90g tank which will hold maybe a few piranhas. Thanks everyone who helps out.
He'll be one happy Betta!! You'll be totally fine.
 
  • Thread starter
  • Thread Starter
  • #10

Dayne Clarke

New Member
Messages
8
Reaction score
1
Points
3
What fin-type is your betta? A fully-finned betta will have a very difficult time getting to the top of the tank for each breath he takes, it will wear him out quickly. Also, a much larger tank can make a fish shy for a few days, but this should wear off quickly.

Do you know what an actual "cycle" is? I am not trying to be condescending at all, but I'm just wondering since you said "after a week of cycling", when it normally takes much longer. Though ammonia/waste build-up is probably not the reason for the betta not eating since it is a small fish in a large tank, it is still important to know.
I know a lot of times a cycle should take 3 to 4 weeks with your bacteria and filtration but my thing is the fish came from a 1 gallon tank and had no filter didn't see where there should be a problem at all. I don't believe the fish is a full fin but I am taking a stab in the dark in that aspect.
 

MaddieTaylah

Well Known Member
Messages
603
Reaction score
289
Points
78
Experience
5 to 10 years
If you put something like a betta leaf near the surface of the water, your betta will have an easier time getting up to the surface for air as it will be able to rest on it & be closer to the surface.
 

MikeRad89

Well Known Member
Messages
3,029
Reaction score
1,411
Points
198
Experience
5 to 10 years
Betta splendens don't need to breathe atmospheric oxygen. Doesn't matter how tall your tank is.
 

EternalDancer

Well Known Member
Messages
625
Reaction score
265
Points
53
Experience
1 year
Betta splendens don't need to breathe atmospheric oxygen. Doesn't matter how tall your tank is.
So this is new...

I was under the impression that although a chilled out betta may not worry with atmospheric oxygen, a more feisty fish would require the additional O2.

What makes you say they don't need the AO?

I'm definitely still learning about these guys.
 

MikeRad89

Well Known Member
Messages
3,029
Reaction score
1,411
Points
198
Experience
5 to 10 years
They're facultative air breathers. In the wild they live in sedentary bodies of water with little to no surface agiatation meaning very little has exchange.

Facultative means optional more or less, so in the wild you'll see splendens use their labyrinth organ far more than in the household aquarium.

There are a number of commonly kept species that are considered obligate air breathers however; most of which are gouramis.
 
Toggle Sidebar

Aquarium Calculator

Follow FishLore!





Top Bottom