Stress, Sick, Pain, Euthanasia; Should I Euthanize My Fish? Important

Discussion in 'Freshwater Fish Disease' started by Crimson_687, Jun 11, 2019.


how do you euthanize fish?

  1. clove oil

    2 vote(s)
  2. other method

    1 vote(s)
Multiple votes are allowed.
  1. Crimson_687

    Crimson_687Well Known MemberMember

    Dallas, Texas
    I was unsure what to upload this as, so I created it as a thread. If it is possible to move this to a more appropriate location, I will do so. This took me a long time to compile, so I apologize in advance if it was over extensive or lengthy. Please post your own experiences and comments so others can benefit from them!
    So I will include an index with this, so you can skip to the section that is best applicable to your fish. Essentially, this is a set of questions that will help you assess your fish. Please add your own personal experiences. Other fishkeepers will benefit from your experience! I chose to begin with questions that will help you determine if your fish is stressed since the decline in fish health begins with stress. From stress, I move on to sickness, then pain, then it concludes with euthanasia and proper disposal.
    1- Is My Fish Stressed?
    2- Why Is My Fish Stressed?
    3- Is My Fish Unhealthy?
    4- Is My Fish Sick?
    5- Is My Fish In Pain?
    6- Should I Euthanize My Fish?
    7- How Can I Euthanize My Fish?
    8- The Euthanasia Of Invertebrates
    9- Proper Disposal Of A Dead Fish
    1-is my fish STRESSED??
    Things To Look For:
    -Faded color?
    -Clamped fins?
    -Unusual behavior?
    -Loss of appetite?
    -Avoidance of other fish?
    -Decreased activity?
    2- Why is my fish stressed?
    Potential Causes Of Stress In Fish
    - Are my water parameters pristine?
    - Is my water temperature unusual or fluctuating?
    - Is the fish being harassed?
    - Have there been any recent spikes or fluctuations in the water?
    - Are you up-to-date on your water changes?
    - Did you recently do a water change that may have been stressful?
    - Was your aquarium light on passed usual hours?
    - Did your fish sleep properly?
    - Was there any disturbance in/around aquarium?
    - Was anyone tapping on the aquarium?
    - Did a tankmate recently be added or removed?
    - Was the tank layout changed?
    - Is your tank an appropriate environment for the fish?
    - Does the fish have the proper amount of space it will need to thrive not only as a juvenile but also as an adult?
    - Does the fish need more/fewer individuals of his/her own kind?
    - Are there any meds/contaminants in the tank?
    - Are all elements in the tank properly working? (filter, heater, powerheads, airstones, etc)
    - Is my fish being outcompeted for space and/or food?
    - Are the temperature and water hardness appropriate for the fish?
    - Was the fish properly acclimated?
    3- is my fish UNHEALTHY?
    Injuries In Fish Can Occur.
    - Fin damage(s)?
    - Scale damage(s)?
    Fish May Have Digestive Problems.
    - Is my fish bloated?
    - Is my fish constipated?
    - Am I feeding my fish a proper, balanced diet?
    - Am I overfeeding my fish?
    - Are my water parameters pristine?
    Fish May Suffer From Underlying Health Issues.
    - Does my fish have tumors?
    - Does my fish have swim bladder disorder?
    - Does my fish have a deformity?
    - Does my fish have cancer?
    - Does my fish have cataracts?
    Fish Grow Older. (signs of old age may vary among fish and depend on lifespan)
    - Is my fish in his/her golden years, months, weeks, days?
    4- Is my fish SICK?
    - Inflamed, red, swollen, prolapsed anus?
    - Are worms protruding from anus?
    - Dropsy? (pineconing, fluid buildup)
    - Complete loss of appetite?
    - Discolored, swollen, inflamed gills?
    - Rapid or heavy breathing?
    - Deteriorating tissue?
    - Discolorations, marks, flukes, worms, external parasites on body/fins?
    - Improper swimming?
    - Swollen body?
    - Sudden casualties among tankmates?
    - Swollen/protruding eyes?
    - Ragged fins?
    - Visible cysts?
    - Open sores?
    - Internal bacterial/parasitical infection?
    Always Quarantine Sick Fish! monitor your other fish closely.
    5- is my fish in PAIN?
    - Is my fish responsive?
    - Is my fish swimming with purpose?
    - Does breathing look like a chore for the fish?
    - Is my fish breathing rapidly and shallow?
    - Breathing slowly, and with a lot of effort?
    - Visibly exhausted?
    - Visibly struggling?
    6- should I EUTHANIZE my fish?
    - Have I tried medication(s)?
    - Are the medications not helping/making my fish worse?
    - Was the fish being properly medicated?
    - Has my fish been struggling for a long time?
    - Is my fish in pain?
    With certain conditions, a fish can continue to live happily, with proper accommodations
    - Can my fish live comfortably, despite his/her condition?
    - Will my fish's condition continue to manifest?
    - Can my fish continue to live, until an extent of manifestation of his/her health condition?
    7- How to Euthanize a fish?
    Avoid Netting Your Fish. this will stress them.
    the best method is clove oil. this is an anesthetic for fish, and in an overdose, will euthanize your fish.
    -Clove oil can usually be purchased from a store that sells essential oils.
    -Clove oil is also found in PIMAFIX, a readily available fish medication.
    potential concerns of clove oil
    though I have not found any, consider adding the clove oil in several small-medium dosages rather than all at once. make sure your fish is DEAD, not anesthetized. it is always good to add more clove oil once your fished is anesthetized and leave the fish in there for a while before removal. depending on your dosage, water volume, and the fish itself, the fish should fall asleep quickly, but no longer than 15 minutes.
    other methods
    some of these methods require the fish to be removed, which is extremely traumatizing. the effectiveness of these methods is also questionable. overall, it is agreed that clove oil is more humane.
    - Decapitation; not recommended
    - Breaking of the spine; not recommended unless you are an expert
    -Fisherman method; this requires a lot of skill to know exactly where to place the blade.
    - Vinegar/Vodka; this will damage their gills painfully
    - Freezing; this one is debatable, freezing may not always be effective and is a slow process. fish are also cold-blooded.
    8- Euthanasia of invertebrates?
    A half-eaten, struggling shrimp. A crushed snail. A shrimp in its final moments, twitching and struggling. Whatever it may be, invertebrates will sometimes have to be euthanized. Unfortunately, there is no direct method; invertebrates are not as straight forward as fish, who are vertebrates. Here are some suggested methods:
    - Salt
    - Crushing between paper towel
    - Being eaten by other fish
    - Being eaten (the fish must be big enough to properly do this)
    do not feed sick animals to healthy animals. shrimp can carry bacterial or parasitical infections.
    - Being crushed
    - Decapitation
    9- animal disposal
    - DO NOT flush him/her down the toilet. this will negatively affect your drainage systems and is illegal in some places. this is also disrespectful to your fish.
    - You can bury the individual.
    - Make sure the dead fish will not end up in waterways where the native fish can be infected.
    - DO NOT feed the individual to another animal. by doing this, you are cross-contaminating fish and tanks. also, the fish has clove oil in its system; if a fish is dead, it cannot remove chemicals from its body.
    - Burning can be an option.
    - You can place the fish in a sealed bag, and from there safely stow away in the disposal.
    Last edited: Jun 11, 2019
  2. notBrandon

    notBrandonValued MemberMember

    The content is nice, but maybe try to capitalize and use appropriate spaces to make it more visually appealing, as well as easier to read.

    For instance, I recreated parts of your post:

    I. Is my Fish Stressed?
    II. Why is my Fish Stressed?
    III. Is my Fish Unhealthy?
    IV. Is my Fish Sick?
    V. Is my Fish in Pain?
    VI. Is Euthanasia the Right Option?
    VII. How can I Euthanize my Fish?
    VIII. General Guide- Euthanasia of Invertebrates
    IX. Proper Disposal of the Fish

    I would find that more visually appealing, although I may have gone overboard on the capitalization.
  3. nikm128

    nikm128Fishlore VIPMember

    Your Imagination
    5 years
    It's a great idea, I just think the current form looks a bit intimidating as a huge wall of text.
  4. OP

    Crimson_687Well Known MemberMember

    Dallas, Texas
    I’ll see if I can get on my laptop later an edit it. I didn’t really notice that it was hard to read bc on my laptop it showed it differently then it would on a mobile device, but thankyou for mentioning!
  5. Lovecich

    LovecichValued MemberMember

    Reston VA
    1 year
    Great information. I had no trouble reading it, but I'm on a laptop.
Similar Threads Forum
Stress Or Sick? Rainbowfish Freshwater Fish Disease
Help Pea Puffer Sick? Freshwater Fish Disease
Sick Molly? Or Stress Freshwater Fish Disease
Goldfish Is Sick And Stress Sitting, Hillstream Loach Takes The Opportunity To Sit On Him Freshwater Fish Disease
What Is Making My Fish Sick? Freshwater Fish Disease
Rescued Betta Needs Help Asap. Freshwater Fish Disease
Betta Scale Issue? Freshwater Fish Disease

Become a Fishlore Member