Static Water And Fish

will they live in static water?


  • Total voters
    1
Chillin
  • #1
I'm reading that I can have a fish in shallow water and the movement from the fish will help circulate air into its area?...
I just went and got an air pump for some gold fish and finding out that I do not need it..it has no filter on it as well, but gets 1 gallon water changes daily
what I am wating to do is put a preggo guppy in to an empty 10 gallon tank with no pump, ect..
will it survive just fine in an empty tank with just water?
I also have prego swordtails that I maybe swap into the tank also? idk
now thinking a heater would be a bonus...
 
FishFor2018
  • #2
I'm reading that I can have a fish in shallow water and the movement from the fish will help circulate air into its area?...
I just went and got an air pump for some gold fish and finding out that I do not need it..it has no filter on it as well, but gets 1 gallon water changes daily
what I am wating to do is put a preggo guppy in to an empty 10 gallon tank with no pump, ect..
will it survive just fine in an empty tank with just water?
I also have prego swordtails that I maybe swap into the tank also? idk
now thinking a heater would be a bonus...
No it will not survive, without a heater. Alsothe filter helps them get oxygen so without one your fish will become stressed and die. Sorry it’s not what you where hoping for
 
Chillin
  • Thread Starter
  • #3
I'm reading a lot of the O2 intake is purely from water agitation
also seeing that water levels matter as well for purely relying on the fish to stur the water for agitation..
so maybe in the bottom of a 1 gallon jug till the fry pop out?
might just breakdown and use the jug in the tank with holes in it
 
david1978
  • #4
Essentially what your trying to do used to be called a swamp tank. Yes it can be done but takes lots of care setting up and maintaining. Its much easier and less expensive to just throw a filter on it.
 
Chillin
  • Thread Starter
  • #5
from what I understand if you have treated water for fish and throw a filter on it, it will disturb the live-ability for the fish?
so adding an air line would seem more acceptable for now?
 
david1978
  • #6
A filter will not harm your fish. Every fish deserves a filter. Beneficial bacteria live in the filter media and use up the ammonia and nitrites so they don't harm your fish. Yes a bubbler will do the agitation for gas exchange but nothing else.
 
Chillin
  • Thread Starter
  • #7
alright been looking at sponge filters and I have a spair large filter cartage, maybe set it in the take above the air stone with some space in between?
could that work doing some filtering
thinking of laying it flat so the air passes threw it, lava rocks holding it all together lol
 
Jellibeen
  • #8
I suggest you use an actual sponge filter.
 
Chillin
  • Thread Starter
  • #9
they are not sold in any of my pet shops around here, have to order them online......
maybe I can do that some time...idk
 

Similar Aquarium Threads

  • Question
Replies
13
Views
394
fishkeepinginaisa
Replies
25
Views
377
Kmarroquin89
  • Locked
Replies
5
Views
1K
Roc70
Replies
12
Views
150
ruud
Replies
16
Views
2K
Momgoose56
Advertisement


Top Bottom