Somewhat Odd Parameter Readings?

SuperK

Well Known Member
Messages
612
Reaction score
143
Points
78
Experience
1 year
So, I replaced my filter since my old one wasn't working, the tank hadn't been cycled but it has fish. (Really long story, not my choice, if you would like an explanation I'm happy to give one.) So of course I'm stuck having to do a fish-in cycle. Tank is overstocked slightly, 6 phantom tetras (which I'm hoping to rehome very soon), 2 cories (I'm aware they need schools of 6 but I cannot in this tank and will be rehoming them) and a betta. The tank is a 12gal cube. Anyway, I've done two tests since the filter was replaced

Yesterday: 0/0/0
Today: 0/0/0
b2c68e1cd7114ad645000bd9dc445eab.jpg

I replaced the filter about two days ago, I haven't done a water change since I replaced it. I just find it odd that with this bioload, the levels are so... Low. I know that cories have quite high bioloads, then I believe it's tetras, with bettas having quite a low bioload. Could it be that there's ammonia present in the water but it isn't enough to show on the readings? I put the nitrate and ammonia side by side since both 0 readings are a yellow colour, and they look pretty similar.

Anyone have an explanation for this? Clearly the tank isn't cycled. Either I'm colourblind or there's really nothing in the tank at all. I haven't even seen a bacterial bloom or anything. It's odd. I've cycled tanks but usually I do have ammonia present, especially since my water has chloramine which produces ammonia when removed. (My conditioner removes chlorine and chloramine)
Is this normal?
 

KinsKicks

Fishlore VIP
Messages
4,089
Reaction score
2,709
Points
353
Experience
More than 10 years
Hello,

Although I don't have an explanation (yet), the color does look very slightly green, .25-.50. I do say slightly. You may have some good bacteria existing in the water that is slightly curbing it for you.
 
  • Thread starter
  • Thread Starter
  • #4

SuperK

Well Known Member
Messages
612
Reaction score
143
Points
78
Experience
1 year
When were the fish added? What's the pH and temp? Are you using a bacteria supplement?
Fish were added about a month ago with a diff uncycled filter. Temp is 22-23 degrees c (not sure what that is in F) I haven't checked pH but as far as I know that's not really important?? If you want to know last time I checked it was about 7.2. If it really is important I can check it again. I don't use bacteria supplements, I probably would if I could buy any haha.

Hello,

Although I don't have an explanation (yet), the color does look very slightly green, .25-.50. I do say slightly. You may have some good bacteria existing in the water that is slightly curbing it for you.
Yeah I'd say possibly somewhere in between 0 and .25, I've seen .50 before and this def isn't .50. My camera may have made the colours a little off because they look a little different to irl.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

el337

Fishlore Legend
Messages
17,133
Reaction score
3,063
Points
358
Experience
4 years
Fish were added about a month ago with a diff uncycled filter. Temp is 22-23 degrees c (not sure what that is in F) I haven't checked pH but as far as I know that's not really important?? If you want to know last time I checked it was about 7.2. If it really is important I can check it again. I don't use bacteria supplements, I probably would if I could buy any haha.
pH is actually important in cycling since bacteria populates at a much higher rate when the pH is higher. You'd want it at least 7.0 and not dip any lower than that. Can you test out of the tap and tank?

That temp is really too low for the betta. I'd increase it to about 80F.
 

AllieSten

Fishlore VIP
Messages
5,689
Reaction score
3,611
Points
448
Experience
2 years
pH is actually important in cycling since bacteria populates at a much higher rate when the pH is higher. You'd want it at least 7.0 and not dip any lower than that. Can you test out of the tap and tank?

That temp is really too low for the betta. I'd increase it to about 80F.
I second this. If your pH is too low or too high your tank will never cycle. So the pH is very important.

I had my pH crash a few weeks back and ended up losing my cycle all together. I had been having a pH 6.8-7.2 consistently for 3 months before that and it crashed due to having a low mineral content (kH/gh). Dropped to below 6. Got it all situated now though. Things are back on track lol

I also agree about tank temp. 22C = 72F Bettas need to be kept at around 27C (80F) or at the very lowest you could do 25C (78F) but only if absolutely necessary.
 
  • Thread starter
  • Thread Starter
  • #7

SuperK

Well Known Member
Messages
612
Reaction score
143
Points
78
Experience
1 year
pH is actually important in cycling since bacteria populates at a much higher rate when the pH is higher. You'd want it at least 7.0 and not dip any lower than that. Can you test out of the tap and tank?

That temp is really too low for the betta. I'd increase it to about 80F.
I can do that
I'll try and increase the temp but I have read they can go kinda low
It might even be 25, I can't remember
I just know that when it was about 80F the other fish became really lethargic, I had no problems before
The betta eats fine and swims fine, he hasn't had any sickness at all
I've read that they can live in about 76F minimum before
 

BeanFish

Well Known Member
Messages
2,909
Reaction score
1,681
Points
158
While bacteria (Nitrosomonas and nitrobacter) do prefer certain pH and temperature saying that your tank wont cycle if your pH has a certain level is not logical.
AllieSten, I think you lost your cycle because you shocked everything, not because of the pH itself.
Nitrosomonas prefers an optimum pH of 6.0-9.0 and a temperature range of 20 to 30°C.
Nitrobacter are widely distributed in both aquatic and land environments. Nitrifying bacteria have an optimum growth between 25-30 °C, and cannot survive past the upper limit of 49 °C or the lower limit of 0 °C, limiting their distribution even though they encompass a variety of habitats. Nitrobacter have an optimum pH between 7.3 and 7.5, and will die in temperatures exceeding 120 °F (49 °C) or below 32 °F (0 °C).According to Grundmann, Nitrobacter seem to grow optimally at 38 °C and at a pH of 7.9, but Holt states that Nitrobacter grow optimally at 28 °C and grows within a pH range of 5.8 -8.5 and has a pH optima between 7.6 and 7.8.
All the info can be found in Wikipedia.

In my opinion the optimum temp for Bettas is 25 Celsius. And even tho I do not have a test kit myself it looks like your ammonia can be .25 ppm and not 0, it does not look bright as 0 looks.
 
  • Thread starter
  • Thread Starter
  • #9

SuperK

Well Known Member
Messages
612
Reaction score
143
Points
78
Experience
1 year
I second this. If your pH is too low or too high your tank will never cycle. So the pH is very important.

I had my pH crash a few weeks back and ended up losing my cycle all together. I had been having a pH 6.8-7.2 consistently for 3 months before that and it crashed due to having a low mineral content (kH/gh). Dropped to below 6. Got it all situated now though. Things are back on track lol

I also agree about tank temp. 22C = 72F Bettas need to be kept at around 27C (80F) or at the very lowest you could do 25C (78F) but only if absolutely necessary.
Yeah tank is about 25, just checked

Anyway, both tank and tap are 7.6. However I've never heard people say this before, even with newbies who have similar pH. Of course maybe it may make a difference but I've honestly never heard that. Like I've cycled tanks before with the same pH and never had a problem, even though my canister ended up losing it's cycle because my dad decided to turn it off
 

AllieSten

Fishlore VIP
Messages
5,689
Reaction score
3,611
Points
448
Experience
2 years
Yeah tank is about 25, just checked

Anyway, both tank and tap are 7.6. However I've never heard people say this before, even with newbies who have similar pH. Of course maybe it may make a difference but I've honestly never heard that. Like I've cycled tanks before with the same pH and never had a problem, even though my canister ended up losing it's cycle because my dad decided to turn it off
You may never ever have issues, but without testing you can't be sure. That is the point of testing. Just to double check that you aren't having pH problems.

Mine is directly related to my tap water hardness or softness in my case.

@BeanFish my cycle was lost because of the shock yes, related to the pH dropping from 6.8 to below 6 in 24 hours. So the pH did affect my cycle, indirectly. But there are tons of newbies that are trying to cycle their tanks and have a pH of 6 and can't figure out why after 4-6 weeks, they still aren't cycled. So it is an important factor, and can be easily remedied when you know the cause of the problem. (All I had to do was add crushed coral to my filter)
 
  • Thread starter
  • Thread Starter
  • #11

SuperK

Well Known Member
Messages
612
Reaction score
143
Points
78
Experience
1 year
You may never ever have issues, but without testing you can't be sure. That is the point of testing. Just to double check that you aren't having pH problems.

Mine is directly related to my tap water hardness or softness in my case.

@BeanFish my cycle was lost because of the shock yes, related to the pH dropping from 6.8 to below 6 in 24 hours. So the pH did affect my cycle, indirectly. But there are tons of newbies that are trying to cycle their tanks and have a pH of 6 and can't figure out why after 4-6 weeks, they still aren't cycled. So it is an important factor, and can be easily remedied when you know the cause of the problem. (All I had to do was add crushed coral to my filter)
Ive always had a steady pH of 7.6, it was 7.6 in the last tank and 7.6 in this one

I'm not sure what else could be affecting it, it's just odd that it's complete 0 with the stocking I have and my tank
 

BeanFish

Well Known Member
Messages
2,909
Reaction score
1,681
Points
158
You may never ever have issues, but without testing you can't be sure. That is the point of testing. Just to double check that you aren't having pH problems.

Mine is directly related to my tap water hardness or softness in my case.

@BeanFish my cycle was lost because of the shock yes, related to the pH dropping from 6.8 to below 6 in 24 hours. So the pH did affect my cycle, indirectly. But there are tons of newbies that are trying to cycle their tanks and have a pH of 6 and can't figure out why after 4-6 weeks, they still aren't cycled. So it is an important factor, and can be easily remedied when you know the cause of the problem. (All I had to do was add crushed coral to my filter)
The research is there. Your bacteria died becuase of shock not because your pH was 6. There are a lot of variables in a fishlore thread to take that as a proof that bacteria will not grow in a pH of 6.
Will it be helpful if your pH is in the mid 7s? Yes. Is it necessary? Nope.
I dont even have a test kit tho so I cant care much about pH LOL. But bacteria should be able to grow in a pH of 6.
 

Danjamesdixon

Well Known Member
Messages
2,650
Reaction score
473
Points
108
Experience
3 years
This may sound trivial;

but did you bang the Nitrate 2# bottle hard? Like, really hard? It's not uncommon for the Catalyst to settle at the bottom of the bottle, rendering it useless.
 

AvalancheDave

Well Known Member
Messages
1,626
Reaction score
835
Points
148
Experience
More than 10 years
Bottle #2 apparently contains a suspension so the most important thing is probably to squeeze the drops out of it immediately after shaking it so it doesn't have time to settle.
 
  • Thread starter
  • Thread Starter
  • #16

SuperK

Well Known Member
Messages
612
Reaction score
143
Points
78
Experience
1 year
This may sound trivial;

but did you bang the Nitrate 2# bottle hard? Like, really hard? It's not uncommon for the Catalyst to settle at the bottom of the bottle, rendering it useless.
Yeah I do, I shake all my bottles before using them anyway, habit I guess haha
I'm still getting like really really trace readings of ammonia and like, 0 everything
 
Toggle Sidebar

Aquarium Calculator

Follow FishLore!





Top Bottom