Small Contained Ecosystem?

Discussion in 'Freshwater Invertebrates' started by Spollack, Jul 14, 2015.

  1. Spollack

    SpollackNew MemberMember

    I just took a new job and they don't allow open aquariums on desks, so my plan is to get a bottle/jar I can cork and put a Marimo algae and a couple shrimp in there. Is there any flaw in this plan? Any help would be awesome! Thanks.

    Something like this :

    but with a couple cherry or glass shrimp?
     
  2. BDpups

    BDpupsWell Known MemberMember

    It's worth a try. But with no water movement, I'm not sure how long term shrimp would last. You would have to change the water daily.


    Sent from my iPhone using Fish Lore Aquarium Fish Forum
     
  3. Dom90

    Dom90Fishlore VIPMember

    I noticed you said you would put a cork so the shrimp wont escape. But the problem with that is, the oxygen inside the bottle/jar will run out eventually, thus suffocating the specimens.
     
  4. OP
    OP
    Spollack

    SpollackNew MemberMember

    I could uncork and recork it (to allow fresh oxygen), but do the shrimp really need moving water? How do the ecoshpheres support shrimp then?



    thanks
     
  5. BDpups

    BDpupsWell Known MemberMember

    Those are cool. I'm not sure how they work. But I know shrimp can be sensitive to ammonia and such. I guess water movement may not be necessary, but stagnant water is not something I would think dwarf shrimp would do very well in. Just my opinion.

    I'm going to keep an eye on this and see how it works out.


    Sent from my iPhone using Fish Lore Aquarium Fish Forum
     
  6. OP
    OP
    Spollack

    SpollackNew MemberMember

    Does anyone else have any insight on this matter?
     
  7. stargazerwolf

    stargazerwolfValued MemberMember

    They might survive for a bit, survive, not thrive. Those completely closed "ecosystems" might last awhile but I can't imagine that the shrimp are happy. There is no way for there to be a complete ecosystem in an enclosed environment like that. It's just water, a plant and shrimp, oxygen would eventually run out but I assume they last for a bit because the shrimp and plants give each other what they need to a point. Also part of those enclosed ones is you have to put them in the window for sun some of the time to grow algae for the shrimp or they will run out of food. Even still that give no variety in their diet. If you put them in a jar I'd change out water daily, give them just a bit of food and they could be ok...however, I'd never do that to a living thing. Shrimp do like to swim. I see them swim across the whole front of my 10 gallon. In there, they could barely swim at all. Its kind of like when people have a bird in a cage and never let them out, they will live, but can't say they'd be happy.

    So while it is possible, I don't suggest keeping them in something so small. I personally wouldn't do anything smaller than a gallon, but even that is pushing it. I had some shrimp in a 2.5 gallon and they didn't do well even with a heater and filter.
     
  8. Gena

    GenaWell Known MemberMember

  9. EricV

    EricVFishlore VIPMember

    They short answer is that they don't over the long term. The issue isn't so much the food an oxygen but rather the lack of mineral replacement. Both plants and shrimp use minerals from the water which will eventually be used up thus killing them. It's the same reason why you can't keep plants and shrimp in pure distilled or ro water over the long haul.
     
Loading...