Raspy's in trouble!!

Oh no!

I noticed some white (looks like foam sort of) on the side of Raspy this morning just behind his right fin (on the side of his face).

I want to get him some medicine (if it's treatable) but I'm not sure which kind to get him.


Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated!!!!!!!!

 

Pimafix and/or Melafix. I would suggest both. Neither will hurt it and both might help, depending on what it is.

 

Raise the temperature to 85 degrees slowly about a degree every 2 hours or so and leave it there for 14 days at least.  Sounds like you are starting an Ich outbreak.  This is the easiest and quickest way to eradicate it and does not require the need for medication most times.  The Melafix and Pimafix will not hurt but are not necessary if you start and keep up the raised temperature to get the parasites off of him and kill them in the heated water.  They will turn loose of him at this temperature and die due to no host to draw off of.  I got this remedy from Butterfly and it works. 

I am so sorry that he is ill, please keep us informed of his progress.  Ich is a cool water disease and strikes with a vengeance on Bettas.

Rose

 

Ich doesn't look like foam though, it looks like salt grains. If it looks like foam, I think its probably more likely a fungus. Thus my recommendation for Pimafix/Melafix.

 

I'm not sure if it's ich because his water is always above 84 degrees just because of the temperature in the apartment.


is there a disease he could get from the warm temperature? It was 105 degrees outside today ....


I'm going to go out tomorrow and get some Pimafix and Melafix for him. I sure hope that takes care of it.


Thanks.

 

Ich looks like small round grains of salt have been sprinkled on it. If it doesn't look like that, its something other than ich. They can still get ich with higher temps, the lifecycle of the ich parasite is just sped up with higher temps.

 

If it is a fungal infection it will probably look like little cotton tufts on him in some way. They may not be really fuzzy just a little foamy as you said. If that is the case then you may need something a little stronger than Melafix and Pimafix. Something more like Fungus Clear Tabs from Jungle Labs, they are a little faster acting and will not be so gentle to allow the fungus to continue to take ahold while they start to work.

Rose

 

Ok. Thank you. It does look a bit cottony on him. It doesn't seem to be hurting him, just a nuissance I'd imagine.


I think I'm going to go out to the store today and see what I can find.


Thanks so much for everyone's responses!!

 

Well, Raspy has had his medicine. It turned the water blue/green ... I think that is supposed to happen??


I ended up getting the Fungus Clear by Jungle Labs ... I'm not sure how long it is supposed to take but hopefully this cures the problem!

 

Yes the water is supposed to turn the blue/green color and it is to stay in the tank for 4 days. Then you do a 25% water change and if he still has the problem you dose him again for 4 more days and then you do another 25% change and put the carbon back in the filter. You did take the carbon out of the filter, didn't you? The carbon will take the medicine out of the tank and so if the carbon is still in it needs to come out.

Rose

 

Yes, I did take the carbon out of the filter. That part was on the back of the package so thank goodness I did that.

Raspy looked a little confused when his water started changing colors but I'm not sure if he notices anymore. Lilex keeps swimming over to the side where Raspy's tank is and staring like "What IS going on in there?!?!"


I'll keep an eye on Raspy for a few days then and see how he's doing. Is a second dose usually necessary, or does one dose do the trick?


Thanks so much for your help!!

 

Well, the first treatment time is finished but the growth is still there. I did the 25% water change and treated the water again.


Any suggestions if this second treatment doesn't take? Should I buy some Melafix and Pimafix and try that?


Thanks!

 

Can you get a pic of the problem area?

S.

 

Yes the picture would help to see if the problem is actually what we have been treating it for.

The Melafix and Pimafix are possibly the mildest medications you can get.  So if the Tank Buddies do not work they will probably not improve the situation.  Is it improved at all?  It could be that it is just going to have to have the second round to do the job.  If this does not work at all though then the next step is the antibiotics.  Here are some options to see what might sound the most like what you are dealing with.  They will probably be available elsewhere but these are for examples to look for.









All of these treat Cotton Mouth Disease as well as a lot of other common fish problems.  They will not be able to be used on him over and over so I would get the smallest package you can as your tank is not large.  Usually they recommend 1 tablet or capsule for 10 gallons so if your tanks are 5 gallons a card of 8 capsules or a bottle of 20 would more than get you through the dosing and probably get you some to save in case Lilex ever needs them.  If they come in capsules and only ask you to use a half of one I usually just pour the whole capsule out on a paper towel and try to separate the pile into two equal piles and dissolve one half of it and wrap the other half up for the next day (Waxed paper works the best).

I am hoping yet that the Tank Buddies work as they have for many of the people here.  There have been a few times that people have had to go onto another med, but usually the Tank Buddies have taken care of it.  Melafix and Pimafix work great for finrot and sometimes in conjunction with the rise in temperature for a bad case of Ich, but I have never had luck with them on a Fungal Infection.  Please let me know how things are going and if there is any information I am missing.

Rose

 

I tried to take some pictures but they didn't come out. I tried for about 20 minutes and didn't get a single one :-( Raspy was not happy with me!!!


When I came home from work today and saw Raspy it appears that his fin may be detaching from his body .... He stays pressed up against the side of his tank and I can see the fin on the other side working twice as hard.


Please be honest ... is there a chance he won't make it?

 

Now it is sounding like some kind of finrot. I am so sorry that this is happening and you have me thoroughly stumped. I am afraid that there is indeed a chance that he may not make it, but there have been Bettas that I thought would never make it and they pulled through just fine. Remember DENNIS who had been squeeze and worked over by a 3 year old and been terribly hurt, and he made it, but it took a long time. And there is Satin who has been ill with one thing or another for a long time and is still with us. So do not give up heart, but do realize that there is the possibliity that he cannot go on. I am afraid it is kind of up to his will to live as to how hard he will fight.

If his temperature is above 82 degrees and he is getting the medication and has clean water and will eat for you, then I cannot think of anything else you can do. If you would feel better, you can treat the finrot with Melafix and Pimafix but it will not do a thing for the Cotton Mouth Fungus. I did check and they can all be used together, but you must be careful of the dosages and not overdose him. Myself I would take the Tank Buddies out of the water and change the water and put Melafix in the water and make sure that the water is scrupulously clean even if you have to do daily water changes and keep it at between 82 and 85 continuously. His water parameters need to be as close to perfect as possible so if you have high nitrates or something in your water, you may want to supplement with SPRING WATER (bottled) - not distilled or drinking water. (50/50 with tap water or so)
Just while he is so sick and then slowly go back to whole tap water if you want. But only if your parameters are out of line, otherwise it is too expensive. (I know as I use 18 gallons of the stuff a week and it really runs up)

Please let me know what your parameters are and how he is doing and what you decide to do. This is a serious situation and I am so sorry you are having to go through it. I shall say some prayers for you both and send my best wishes to both of you. I have told my little ones about the trouble that Raspy is having and I believe they are sending their best too. I will keep looking to see if I can come up with something else.

Rose

 

Thank you so much.

I do want to do all of the things you suggested if it will help him. I surely don't want to lose him.

He is eating just fine and is active for the most part although he does spend a lot of time in the back of his tank I think because it is hard for him to swim right with that fin out of commission at the moment.

I will go out tomorrow and get a test kit and post my parameters. How do I go about "removing the tank buddies"? They completely dissolve in the water so I guess I'm unclear as to what you mean by this ...

Shall I put the carbon filter back in the tank?

Sorry if I seem to be misunderstanding. I just don't want to do something incorrectly and cause him more stress than he is already going through.

I do know that there are fishies out there that have gone (or are going) through worse and I only hope that Raspy will fight as hard as they have. He is a fiesty little guy and I know that he enjoys the life he has had.

I will not give up on him!!

Thanks again.
Kelly :'(

 

Do another 25% water change and put the carbon back in the filter and within 4 hours the residual medication will be considered gone from the tank and you can apply new medication but remember that you will have to remove the carbon again before putting in the new medication.

Kelly, I did not tell you about those other fish to diminish the situation you are facing. I merely wanted you to know that it is possible to have very sick fish and for them to recover. I know that poor little Raspy is receiving the very best of care and I do apologize if I am getting too wordy but I never know when I write what people understand and what they do not so I get to "blabbering on".

Just take good care of you too. Raspy needs you to be in good shape and if you worry yourself sick you cannot be good to him or to Lilex. Also please be sure to spend a little quality time with Lilex. They tend to pick up on sadness and it makes them stressed. You do not need to have another Betta in bad shape due to depression. Sorry to add a new problem, but he needs to have a pat from you.

Please let me know how things are going.

Rose

 

Rose,

I know that you did not tell me about the others to diminish my situation. I was merely stating that I do remember what others have gone through and it would be wonderful if Raspy is able to conquer this as well.

I will keep you posted on what is going on. I am going to the pet store first thing in the morning and will get a test kit at least and if I can afford it some Pima/Melafix.

Should I do the water change before I test the water or after? Will the medication affect the water parameters?


Thanks for all of your help. You are always free to "blabber on" because I am sure that there are many that read the forum that don't register so if it helps someone else, that's great! I was one of those people for a bit before I registered for the forum but now I am so glad that I did. I would be so lost without you and everyone else who has helped me!!!!

I have been spending some good quality time with my babies tonight. They are both currently asleep underneath their plants and I am about to go to sleep myself. I am not worrying myself sick (as I know from past experience that does absolutely NO GOOD) but I am concerned for Raspy.


I'll post again in the morning with test results.
Kelly

 

If you can only afford one medication of the two get the Melafix. The Pimafix is more for Parasitic Infestations.  Melafix is for Infectious Conditions.  Right now I believe we are dealing with an infection rather than a parasite.  Omorrokh had very good luck with water changes and Melafix when her Otos had finrot. 

The medication should not change the parameters but you could try taking them both ways just to see. I would think that if they were going to they would have to mention it in the literature but nothing is mentioned and I do not recall it ever happening when I used it. You may also want to test your tap water as I never realized that my tap water was HIGH nitrate until I tested it right out of the tap. I kept trying to bring it down and it was high before I even had a chance to do anything to it. That is why I now use Spring Water for most of my changes. (our water gets above 50 and sometimes 80 at times).

Good night.  I hope all of you sleep well.

Rose

 

I wasn't able to buy the test kit today because I was unaware that it was around $30. I did buy some Melafix though.

I am going to search online and see if I can find the test kit for a cheaper price and I believe that I will be able to.


Should I go ahead and change the water and treat with Melafix? Raspy is looking quite better today ... The fungus seems to have subsided quite a bit ....

 

- or cheaper here -


On this one you can either buy just the tests you want which I did or the whole master test kit which I believe most folks do.

I am glad that he is doing better but now that you say the fungus is better I am wondering if you shouldn't go ahead and let the Tank Buddies finish out their work and THEN go to the Melafix.  Hope it is not too late.

I am sorry to confuse you but if the medicine is working I hate to see you stop until it is done.

Rose

 

I had the same thought as well. If the medication seems to be working why mess with it?


He has about 2 more days on the second dosing of Fungus Clear so I suppose I"ll just wait it out before changing water and giving Melafix.


Thanks!

 

Good we'll try that then. I am so glad that you are seeing improvement. In two more days the white areas might be gone and we can start to see what to do with that fin. I am glad to hear that his eating isn't disturbed. this means he doesn't even know he has been sick. Poor little guy!

Now the both of you need a good nights rest (sorry the nurse in me just slipped out)

Rose

 

And a good night's rest we will have!!


Thanks for all of your thoughts, comments and good wishes. I really believe they helped!!!!


Raspy says thanks too!!!!
;D ;D ;D ;D ;D

 

I don't know if this will help but at one point back when I had TenshI she turned brown and couldn't swim to save her life I have never seen a live fish turn that color with some love and care she did recover tho so it is very possible even if u don't know what ur doing to get a fighter fish and especially bettas they fight their own reflections so a bit of illness shouldn't take them out really or if it does not for too long good luck with Raspy I hope he feels better

Inari

 

Good morning. I hope all is better.

Rose

 

Good morning!


Raspy is continuing to look better. I've posted a picture of him (very blurry due to the water I believe) but I've put a yellow circle around where the damage was/is.

I believe the fungus is mostly gone as it is not really white anymore. I think whatever damage is there right now is due to his fin damage perhaps. I wish I could get a better picture of him but I think the green water is really affecting the outcome of the pictures...


We'll see what happens!

 

for the test kit I got a master test kit for 21.99 usd it will test a total of 700 samples per test (ammonia, pH, High pH, nitrates, nitrites 700 of each)

 

Fin damage can take a few weeks to repair so do not despair. Really clean water and good water parameters and Melafix and a temperature of about 82 to 84 degrees will be the best thing for him after the Tank Buddy treatment is over. I am glad the white area is gone, but please make sure it is really gone before the Tank Buddy is completely stopped as we so do not want a relapse. They can be withdrawn for a period of about 3 days and restarted if they need more treatment but it is very doubtful that this will be needed. Just go ahead and do the 25% water change and put the carbon back in the filter and run like usual. Then after about 8 hours you can start the Melafix. If you would feel better or if the water parameters are a bit off you may want to even do a 50% water change since he is having fin trouble. I know when I was having fin trouble with Marty I did 50% changes about 2 times a week even though Melafix doesn't recommend a change until 7 days of medication has been administered. I figured that was for most bacterial infections but clean water is also a great factor in healing damaged fins and it worked for Marty, but it does take a long time for them to repair. Patience which is some of the hardest thing to practice with a sick Betta is what you have to have. Tell both of the boys hello.

Rose

 

When I told them you said hello all fins were waving wildly!

Raspy has one more day of the Tank Buddies before his second treatment is over. I will do a water change on Tuesday when I get home from work and put the filter back in and administer Melafix on Wednesday evening. Hopefully that will be sufficient.

- Thanks!

 

Sounds like a good plan and you should have a really good idea by then if you have a good cure with the Tank Buddies.

The Melafix can take over and go from there and perhaps finish up the job when there is only the fin problem to take care of.

I love the fin wave.

Rose

 

IDK if melafix takes care of finrot but I know petco sells some 'cure all' stuff that I know as a fact does when InarI was still in his bowl he started getting some fin rot from where tenshI had fought back (for everyone who doesn't remeber TenshI was my female that I made the mistake of putting in with InarI oops) I found this said it was supposed to help with fin growth and well it sure as does his fins regrew before I knew it and he was being as feisty as ever. anway idk if that would but if u want the name of it let me know also it was dirt cheap like $3 bottle for a bottle to treat I think 10-20 gallons

 

Raspy is doing SO much better! The fungus is gone!! YAY!! ;D ;D ;D


I never did add any Melafix (even though I do have it) and I still haven't been able to get a test kit (little financial trouble of late) ....


Raspy's water still has a hint of green to it ... does this mean that the medicine from the Fungus Clear is still in the tank or not? I did the water change and replaced the carbon like I was supposed to. I was hesistant to add Melafix without checking first.


Thanks in advance!!!!

 

If there is no more fungus, you don't need the Melafix and the carbon will take the other medication out some more probably otherwise the water changes will eliminate it little by little and it will do him no harm. I am so glad that he is okay!!!!

Keep us up to date on the little guy. Raspy, be good. You worried your Mom.

Rose

 

What about the fin regeneration? Does the Melafix help that or was that something else? Or does it just take time?

 

I know if Raspy was in a very tiny tank (1 gallon or so) i'd say use bettaremedy or is it bettafix....idk off hand and i'm not digging it out but that is a very watered down version of a mix of other meds I do know there are things on the market to help with fin growth but unless his fins are horrible i'd say just give him some time they will grow back in time

 

Raspy is not in a tiny tank. He has had the luxury of a 5 gallon hex tank since he came into my life ;D


I'm sure with time his fin will come back ... I just didn't know if there was a product that would help him along.

 

There might be...if you are considerablely concerned about his fins I would suggest going to your lfs and seeing what they have you never know

 

I am so sorry. I had forgotten about that. There have just been so many lttle sick buddies lately and I am so glad that you reminded me. Yes the carbon needs to be removed from the tank again and the Melafix put in the tank (1/2 teaspoon in 5 gallons every day for 7 days) and then a water change 25% and then continue for another 7 days and another water change until the fin regrowth is accomplished. I can promise it will take longer than 7 days. That fin is active and he is going to keep trying to use it so it will take a while for the new tissue to mend. Tell him that I do apologize for forgetting , I do not want his feelings hurt. :-[

Let me know how it goes. He is going to seem drowsy, but that is normal. This is a herbal remedy so prolonged usage will not hurt him and it will look like it puts a oil on the surface but it is okay for him. It smells wonderful, I think.

Rose