Pipe Organ Coral Has Not Opened In 1-2 Months. Help Asap!

Status
Not open for further replies.

Sebastian Perdomo

Valued Member
Messages
125
Reaction score
28
Points
53
Location
Tampa, Florida
Experience
4 years
I got a pipe organ coral colony back in late February. It was fine for a week or two, but since then it hasn't opened. I've read that debris could cause the coral not to open so I tried brushing it with a toothbrush (a brand new one of course with no chemicals added). No luck. The only thing that ended up happening is that the white stuff on top of the tube got brushed off as well as just a little of the red tube. I've tried moving it around my tank to see if it liked the different flow, higher lighting, higher lighting and direct flow, low flow, and now I'm trying medium flow with low lighting.
The only chemical additives in the tank is a bit of "Chemi-Clean" for the bit of red slime algae on my rocks. Other than that I get the typical brown algae on the glass and sand and I remove that.
I took my water to my LFS yesterday and they said my parameters are perfect.
I need your help on what to do. Anything helps.

@Xbox62 @Tyler Fishman @KinsKicks @yupp
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Esimm03

Well Known Member
Messages
2,003
Reaction score
903
Points
148
Location
London, UK
Experience
3 years
I got a pipe organ coral colony back in late February. It was fine for a week or two, but since then it hasn't opened. I've read that debris could cause the coral not to open so I tried brushing it with a toothbrush (a brand new one of course with no chemicals added). No luck. The only thing that ended up happening is that the white stuff on top of the tube got brushed off as well as just a little of the red tube. I've tried moving it around my tank to see if it liked the different flow, higher lighting, higher lighting and direct flow, low flow, and now I'm trying medium flow with low lighting.
The only chemical additives in the tank is a bit of "Chemi-Clean" for the bit of red slime algae on my rocks. Other than that I get the typical brown algae on the glass and sand and I remove that.
I took my water to my LFS yesterday and they said my parameters are perfect.
I need your help on what to do. Anything helps.

@Xbox62 @Tyler Fishman @KinsKicks @yupp
Hi,
Sounds odd... I haven't kept a pipe organ before so can't give solid advice, I'm planning on getting one however. Have you tried feeding it with something like reef roids or similar to get it to come out or something?

Sorry I can't give too much help.

Ethan
 
  • Thread starter
  • Thread Starter
  • #3
OP
Sebastian Perdomo

Sebastian Perdomo

Valued Member
Messages
125
Reaction score
28
Points
53
Location
Tampa, Florida
Experience
4 years
Hi,
Sounds odd... I haven't kept a pipe organ before so can't give solid advice, I'm planning on getting one however. Have you tried feeding it with something like reef roids or similar to get it to come out or something?

Sorry I can't give too much help.

Ethan
I have tried feeding it Mysis Shrimp, but I'll purchase some reef roids to see if that helps.
 

Iverg1

Well Known Member
Messages
1,554
Reaction score
642
Points
108
Location
Minnesota USA
Experience
1 year
Do you have any fish in there. It could be your over feeding in that case you should get some shrimp,crab,snail. Not an expert just googled
 

stella1979

Moderator
Messages
7,482
Reaction score
9,600
Points
608
Location
Florida
Experience
5 to 10 years
No experience with a pipe organ, but I do not recommend feeding an unhappy coral. It will get what it needs from the light, and should use it's energy getting better instead of digesting foods.

What comes to mind from my own experience is my first Ricordea shroom. It didn't look happy after the first few days in my tank, so I moved it, just like you. Weeks later it still wasn't happy so I moved it again. This went on a few times over 5-6 months. Finally, I put it back in the first spot, where I had thought it would be happy in the first place, and swore to leave it alone no matter what. Wouldn't you know it? A couple months after that it finally settled and looked happy. Soon after it propagated itself by moving, (a tiny move) most it's body off of the little rock it came on and into the main rockscape... precisely what I'd hoped would happen. It left a small part behind so now I have two of that guy.

Best advice? Corals like stability most of all. Keep the pipe organ in its low flow/med light spot, leave it alone, keep parameters stable and hope for the best.
 

Esimm03

Well Known Member
Messages
2,003
Reaction score
903
Points
148
Location
London, UK
Experience
3 years
No experience with a pipe organ, but I do not recommend feeding an unhappy coral. It will get what it needs from the light, and should use it's energy getting better instead of digesting foods.

What comes to mind from my own experience is my first Ricordea shroom. It didn't look happy after the first few days in my tank, so I moved it, just like you. Weeks later it still wasn't happy so I moved it again. This went on a few times over 5-6 months. Finally, I put it back in the first spot, where I had thought it would be happy in the first place, and swore to leave it alone no matter what. Wouldn't you know it? A couple months after that it finally settled and looked happy. Soon after it propagated itself by moving, (a tiny move) most it's body off of the little rock it came on and into the main rockscape... precisely what I'd hoped would happen. It left a small part behind so now I have two of that guy.

Best advice? Corals like stability most of all. Keep the pipe organ in its low flow/med light spot, leave it alone, keep parameters stable and hope for the best.
Ah, I thought if it was fed it may encourage it to come out, it worked for my tube worm, but that's not a coral.

I'd recommend reef roids anyway, as they have great results
 
  • Thread starter
  • Thread Starter
  • #8
OP
Sebastian Perdomo

Sebastian Perdomo

Valued Member
Messages
125
Reaction score
28
Points
53
Location
Tampa, Florida
Experience
4 years
Do you have any fish in there. It could be your over feeding in that case you should get some shrimp,crab,snail. Not an expert just googled
Yes, I do have 5 fish in there. My whole clean-up crew is due for a replacement considering there is one hermit left. Thanks for the advice. where did you find that info?

Ok, no garentee, do your other coral seem to be ok?

Maby @stella1979 or @grantm91 have experience.
My other coral with the exception of a bleaching Setosa are doing fine. I moved the Setosa near where I keep my Blasto to see if it would enjoy the lower light.
 

stella1979

Moderator
Messages
7,482
Reaction score
9,600
Points
608
Location
Florida
Experience
5 to 10 years
In my experience softies just melt when they die. I've had zoas just wither away to nothing. When I lost a torch coral, the tentacles started turning brown and slimy and eventually, it lost all it's flesh.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Toggle Sidebar

Water Change Frequency?

  • Daily

    Votes: 1 1.3%
  • Weekly

    Votes: 53 67.9%
  • Every Two Weeks

    Votes: 10 12.8%
  • Monthly

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • As Needed (from test kit results or based on knowing your tank)

    Votes: 14 17.9%




Top Bottom