Yeah, that's what it was the other times. This happened to me twice yesterday, the first time though it was a post that took a while to show up. I have scrolled down to see if it's buried, it isn't. I even went to page 2.
So apparently this is just a dumb glitch. Because I went through and deleted every single subscribed thread on the first page and some of the second page and it still didn't go away....... how do I get rid of it? ryanr
Perhaps..... I'll try marking all forums read and see if that gets rid of one of them, it probably won't get rid of the other one though.
Edit: @Coradee, nope, didn't work. :-\
Edit again: after visiting the posts you moved (dwarf gouramis and angels in a 20g) one notification went away, the other one is still there and refuses to go away. ryanr, can you help?