New Set Up. Tell Me If I Am Wrong!

James105

Active Member
Member
Messages
50
Reaction score
13
Location
England
Experience
3 years
HI Guys,

I have recently set up a 125 Fluval Roma that is currently cycling. It has a EheI'm 350 classic filter installed and I have a U3 if it is needed. For substrate, I have used Caribsea eco-complete.

I have researched and researched on my stock, and I have come to the following list:

3x Pearl Gourami
7x Neon Dwarf Rainbow
3x Bolivian Ram
10x Neon Tetras
8x Checkered Barb
1x Bristlenose
6x Dwarf Chain Loach

I am hoping I have got it perfect, but I would much appriciate if you could tell me if you can see any issues with my setup
 
  • Thread starter
  • Thread Starter
  • #3
OP
J

James105

Active Member
Member
Messages
50
Reaction score
13
Location
England
Experience
3 years
AJE said:
Is that gallons?
HI mate!

No it's a 33.5 gallon tank. I put the list into AquaAdvisor which said it would be at 145% stock level. Given it has a pretty big filter installed my assumption is that it will be ok.
 

treadingwater

Active Member
Member
Messages
246
Reaction score
205
Location
Illinois
Experience
More than 10 years
James105 said:
HI mate!

No it's a 33.5 gallon tank. I put the list into AquaAdvisor which said it would be at 145% stock level. Given it has a pretty big filter installed my assumption is that it will be ok.
If you want to overstock your fish, that's your choice however, going by the controversial inch per gallon rule, at full size, you're looking at 84 inches of fish in a 33 gallon (that's without decorations and anything else that's going to take away water volume and swim space in your tank.)

You need to ask yourself if your fish are going to be comfortable and have enough room to swim. You'll still need to do more water changes as well. What did say about your water change frequency with the filter you chose?
 

jdhef

Moderator
Moderator
Member
Messages
14,364
Reaction score
3,475
Location
South Jersey
Experience
More than 10 years
Many people believe that with enough filtration they can overstock there tanks. And there are times when you want an overstocked tank. Apparently you would want to overstock African Cichlid tanks for example.

But assuming the fish you want to stock your tank with will be able to tolerate crowded conditions, the other thing you need to keep in mind is overfiltration will allow the tank to process more ammonia and the resultant nitries, but that will mean there will be much more nitrate being produced. So you would most likely have to be upping your water change frequency to a few times a week.
 
  • Thread starter
  • Thread Starter
  • #6
OP
J

James105

Active Member
Member
Messages
50
Reaction score
13
Location
England
Experience
3 years
treadingwater said:
If you want to overstock your fish, that's your choice however, going by the controversial inch per gallon rule, at full size, you're looking at 84 inches of fish in a 33 gallon (that's without decorations and anything else that's going to take away water volume and swim space in your tank.)

You need to ask yourself if your fish are going to be comfortable and have enough room to swim. You'll still need to do more water changes as well. What did say about your water change frequency with the filter you chose?
jdhef said:
Many people believe that with enough filtration they can overstock there tanks. And there are times when you want an overstocked tank. Apparently you would want to overstock African Cichlid tanks for example.

But assuming the fish you want to stock your tank with will be able to tolerate crowded conditions, the other thing you need to keep in mind is overfiltration will allow the tank to process more ammonia and the resultant nitries, but that will mean there will be much more nitrate being produced. So you would most likely have to be upping your water change frequency to a few times a week.
Thanks for your points gents! I definitely do not want to overstock my tank, it's cruel as well as hard work. I have swapped out the dwarf rainbows for some spotted blue eyes which are smaller and I may leave out the tetras as well. I have put this into Aquadvisor, which now says I am at 106% stocking level.

Hopefully you guys agree that would work well?
 

BottomDweller

Fishlore VIP
Member
Messages
9,583
Reaction score
6,076
Location
England
Experience
5 to 10 years
I would drop the pearl gouramis. They need a longer tank and prefer warmer water to the rest of your stock.
The footprint of the tank is the bare minimum I would keep dwarf chain loaches in. You could still keep them and be ok but I prefer to give fish more room if possible so I would personally swap them for something else.
I would stick to 1 larger mid dwelling school rather than 3 small schools. The fish behave more naturally and are happier in bigger groups and you don't really have the space for 3 schools.

You could do this at 72-75f. It would be fully stocked imo
1 dwarf gouramI or 3 honey gouramis
2 bolivian rams or 1 bristlenose pleco
10 neon tetras or checkered barbs
10 spotted blue eyes
8 dwarf chain loaches or 12 panda cories

It is better to understock than to overstock. Overstocking means you need heavy filtration and frequent large water changes. It can stress the fish out to be so crowded. Disease often spreads faster in heavily stocked tanks too. In the stocking I suggested above it wouldn't hurt to drop some of the fish.
 

Feohw

Fishlore VIP
Member
Messages
4,218
Reaction score
5,558
Location
Ireland
Experience
2 years
With the loaches, barbs, blue eyes, rams, gouramI and pleco I got 121% stock with 106% filtration capacity. I don't tend to trust aqadvisor too much though, I use it as a very basic view of where the stock is, but not as a final say. Is there going to be plants?

I'd also keep just a pair of rams in this size a tank. Making sure that you know how to sex them well before you go. Three could work if there's plenty of plants and decor to block line of sight and multiple possible territory locations too. But unless that's the case it would be best for just two of them.
 
  • Thread starter
  • Thread Starter
  • #9
OP
J

James105

Active Member
Member
Messages
50
Reaction score
13
Location
England
Experience
3 years
BottomDweller said:
I would drop the pearl gouramis. They need a longer tank and prefer warmer water to the rest of your stock.
The footprint of the tank is the bare minimum I would keep dwarf chain loaches in. You could still keep them and be ok but I prefer to give fish more room if possible so I would personally swap them for something else.
I would stick to 1 larger mid dwelling school rather than 3 small schools. The fish behave more naturally and are happier in bigger groups and you don't really have the space for 3 schools.

You could do this at 72-75f. It would be fully stocked imo
1 dwarf gouramI or 3 honey gouramis
2 bolivian rams or 1 bristlenose pleco
10 neon tetras or checkered barbs
10 spotted blue eyes
8 dwarf chain loaches or 12 panda cories

It is better to understock than to overstock. Overstocking means you need heavy filtration and frequent large water changes. It can stress the fish out to be so crowded. Disease often spreads faster in heavily stocked tanks too. In the stocking I suggested above it wouldn't hurt to drop some of the fish.
I really like that list, it seems to "flow" better than my original. Thank you! any reason why It would be the Bolivan rams OR the bristlenose?
 

BottomDweller

Fishlore VIP
Member
Messages
9,583
Reaction score
6,076
Location
England
Experience
5 to 10 years
You could have both but they both stay near the bottom and can both be quite territorial. If the rams pair up they could be even more territorial. Plecos have quite a heavy bioload too so if you were to get one then it may be an idea to lose some other fish, wouldn't necessarily have to be the rams though.
 
  • Thread starter
  • Thread Starter
  • #11
OP
J

James105

Active Member
Member
Messages
50
Reaction score
13
Location
England
Experience
3 years
Feohw said:
With the loaches, barbs, blue eyes, rams, gouramI and pleco I got 121% stock with 106% filtration capacity. I don't tend to trust aqadvisor too much though, I use it as a very basic view of where the stock is, but not as a final say. Is there going to be plants?

I'd also keep just a pair of rams in this size a tank. Making sure that you know how to sex them well before you go. Three could work if there's plenty of plants and decor to block line of sight and multiple possible territory locations too. But unless that's the case it would be best for just two of them.
Yes I saw the website more as a cautious guideline than a black and white rule book. I will be planting the tank enough to break sightlines along with lots of hiding caves. I was going to have 1 male Bolivian Ram along with 2 females. You don't advise this?

BottomDweller said:
You could have both but they both stay near the bottom and can both be quite territorial. If the rams pair up they could be even more territorial. Plecos have quite a heavy bioload too so if you were to get one then it may be an idea to lose some other fish, wouldn't necessarily have to be the rams though.
Ok I get you. I already have the pleco and he is my prize buddy, so I will not be parting with him. If I wanted to do both, do you reccomend a male and a femal pair?
 

Feohw

Fishlore VIP
Member
Messages
4,218
Reaction score
5,558
Location
Ireland
Experience
2 years
James105 said:
Yes I saw the website more as a cautious guideline than a black and white rule book. I will be planting the tank enough to break sightlines along with lots of hiding caves. I was going to have 1 male Bolivian Ram along with 2 females. You don't advise this?
I have a male and three females together in a 200l (53g) tank. They are fine together but they can be a bit territorial, especially when breeding. They don't mind other fish but can chase one another a little bit. Nothing too bad, they even chill together at times. Even so in a tank of that size I would only do a male and female. Another female could get stressed out too much when the others are breeding. Again my rams are never very bad with one another and no damage is done even when breeding, but stress can be a killer and mine are in a larger tank. Likely with plenty of cover and plants a third could live in there happily, but for the sake of surety I'd do two.

Even with a male and a female they aren't guaranteed to pair up. So make sure there are areas of the tank where they can both set up territories and spend their time. Likely they would pair eventually though.

Just make sure to know how to sex reliably if you get them. For me the breeding tube is most reliable. A males tube would look like the first pic, a females like the second.
Screenshot_20190528-233355.png
Screenshot_20190627-014930.png
 

Momgoose56

Fishlore VIP
Member
Messages
6,010
Reaction score
3,904
Location
Arizona
Experience
More than 10 years
James105 said:
Thanks for your points gents! I definitely do not want to overstock my tank, it's cruel as well as hard work. I have swapped out the dwarf rainbows for some spotted blue eyes which are smaller and I may leave out the tetras as well. I have put this into Aquadvisor, which now says I am at 106% stocking level.

Hopefully you guys agree that would work well?
Much better!
 

angelcraze

Fishlore VIP
Member
Messages
5,974
Reaction score
4,262
Location
Canada QC
Experience
More than 10 years
James105 said:
Yes I saw the website more as a cautious guideline than a black and white rule book. I will be planting the tank enough to break sightlines along with lots of hiding caves. I was going to have 1 male Bolivian Ram along with 2 females. You don't advise this?
I just had to agree with Feohw, I also like to keep a minimum of 3 females to a male. I keep Blue rams, but the way Feohw explained it is exactly the way they are too. In a 33g, I would only keep a male/ female pair. I have to replace my male, but my 3 females still chase eachother often in my 120g!
 

New Threads

Follow FishLore!

FishLore on Social Media

Online statistics

Members online
93
Guests online
2,032
Total visitors
2,125

Aquarium Photo Contests

Aquarium Calculator

Top Bottom