New Guppies Dying

Discussion in 'Freshwater Beginners' started by freshwaterfish1, Apr 12, 2017.

  1. freshwaterfish1

    freshwaterfish1New MemberMember

    So I have a 20 gallon freshwater tank that was cycling for something like a month and a half to two months. A few days ago, I bought 4 corydoras and 4 guppies. There are also 7 ember tetras in there that I'm temporarily keeping for my sister, so I know it's slightly overstocked, but that's temporary. There's also a cherry shrimp and 2 bamboo shrimp.

    Yesterday, I woke to find a guppy dead and laying on the bottom. Body looked fine. I was worried maybe the current was too strong, so I turned it off tonight. I did notice one of my guppies was hanging out near the surface throughout the day, but she didn't look like she was gulping and she still ate happily. This morning, however, she was dead; again, body looks fine.

    I'm really worried the other guppies will die as well and I don't know what's going on. Tested ammonia; it's 0ppm, not to mention the shrimp are doing perfectly fine, and I think they tend to be more sensitive to toxins. Other ideas please?! Thanks for your help!

    Other info: 80°F; slightly acidic pH due to driftwood
  2. Polyrhythm

    PolyrhythmValued MemberMember

  3. OP

    freshwaterfish1New MemberMember

    I gave them about 20 minutes of half their water and half mine. That's what I've always done for new fish.
  4. lilabug4545

    lilabug4545Well Known MemberMember

    Have you tested for nitrItes? NirAtes?
  5. HDavid

    HDavidValued MemberMember

    Could have been just regular stress, or his inbreeding fought up with him. Most guppies wind up being inbred and have health problems because of it. If just one dies it is more then likely just a fluke. If 3 or more die then it's something with your tank.
  6. Herkimur

    HerkimurWell Known MemberMember

    80 F is too high for Guppies.
    Guppies like the water on the hard and alkaline side.
    When the mineral content isn't high enough they go into osmotic shock.
  7. happygolucky

    happygoluckyWell Known MemberMember

    Where did you buy them? Is your tank actually finished cycling? How long were the guppies in the tank for?

    As you said, your shrimp are fine, so I would suspect that the fish were just weak and succumbed to stress. It is really difficult to keep guppies alive from big box stores, from what I have seen most don't make it past 6months. I would try a smaller LFS or ordering from a trusted guppy breeder, whether from or a local.
  8. OP

    freshwaterfish1New MemberMember

    Okay I'll try to answer everyone at once.
    1. How do I up the mineral content?
    2. I read that their range is 75-82°. 80 is too high?
    3. I bought them from a LFS that I trust very much. He is very knowledgable, and he and I know each other pretty well.
    4. How do I keep any more from succumbing to stress, if that is the culprit?
  9. BeanFish

    BeanFishWell Known MemberMember

    Leave the pH like that.
    You added a bunch of fish in a short period of time maybe the filter can't support the bioload? Fish hanging at the surface is never a good sign. I got 8 corydoras paleatus recently that were in bad conditions, one of the 8 was hanging around at the surface a lot of the time. Guess what happened, it died.
  10. OP

    freshwaterfish1New MemberMember

    But my corys are happy, shrimp are happy. All levels look good to me. I really don't think it's toxins.
  11. TheFishGirl

    TheFishGirlValued MemberMember

    It also depends on what store you buy them from example : my pet quarters sold me guppies that ended up having dropsy. My petco has guppies full of ich. Petsmart has decent ones. My LFS always has ripped fins or females have birthing problems. I've actually gone to trying to buy online from home breeders instead.
  12. Discusluv

    DiscusluvWell Known MemberMember

    Like beanfish said, a bioload issue. Do frequent water changes over the next week or two, add Seachem's Stability after each change to aid nitrifying bacteria to match increased bioload.
  13. OP

    freshwaterfish1New MemberMember

    If it were a bioload issue, wouldn't that be showing up in the water tests? Also wouldn't my other fish and invertebrates be showing signs?
  14. Discusluv

    DiscusluvWell Known MemberMember

    What tests have you done? Just ammonia?
  15. BeanFish

    BeanFishWell Known MemberMember

    What are your exact parameters and when did you test your water?80F is a little bit high, are you sure you have enough surface agitation? Happy is a very broad and relative statement. And when there are bioload issues the weakest will die reducing the bioload and letting the other fish live, or at least that is what I think.
    The fact that they looked good on the outside does not mean they were healthy, if they were healthy they wouldnt have died. The only way to know for sure is by opening up the fish and getting gill samples, skin samples, etc... stuff most of us wont do because we lack resources to do a bacterial culture, put samples under the microscope and even the knowledge to open a fish up without destroying it, I tried opening that corydora up and it was a failure, the body was too small for the "tools" I had.
  16. JRS

    JRSWell Known MemberMember

    Did you test for nitrates? If using API, did you shake bottle 2 30 seconds and test tube for 1 minute. If not you can get false low readings.
  17. OP

    freshwaterfish1New MemberMember

    Just did that. Still 0ppm
  18. Discusluv

    DiscusluvWell Known MemberMember

    00ppm nitrates??... that's odd... you should have some nitrate reading in a cycled tank.
  19. OP

    freshwaterfish1New MemberMember

    Oh, sorry. I meant ammonia. I'll check nitrates and nitrites a little later, but I still very much doubt that that's the problem.
  20. Discusluv

    DiscusluvWell Known MemberMember

    Lol! yeah, ok... get the tests.