Need new stocking idea

Discussion in 'Aquarium Stocking Questions' started by Betta Splendid 1, Aug 14, 2015.

  1. Betta Splendid 1Well Known MemberMember

    So soon before getting the fish for my 29 gallon tank I did a little research on otocinclus one of the fish I was going to get and I kept hearing stories otocinclus dies after a couple days perfect water parameters. I don't want a fish that was that sensitive. So could some one please help me replace the otocinclus on my stocking plan. The plan was 8 harlequin rasboras, 6 black phantom tetras, 1 hoeny gourami and 6 otocinclus. So any other suggestions instead of the otocinclus.

  2. el337Fishlore LegendMember

    What about corydoras? :) Or are you looking for something to eat algae?

  3. Betta Splendid 1Well Known MemberMember

    My substrate is smallish pebbles so I think corydoras are a no no already thought about them before. I am not looking for something to eat algae particularly but it would be nice.
  4. Dom90Fishlore VIPMember

    You could replace the 6 oto's with a BN pleco if you want a "cleaner fish".
  5. Betta Splendid 1Well Known MemberMember

    A bristle nose pleco would fit in my tank? It would be cool, still open to suggestions
  6. Dom90Fishlore VIPMember

    Oh yea definitely, there's many members here who keep one in a 20 or 29g. They only get up to 4".
  7. Betta Splendid 1Well Known MemberMember

    I think I could get one of those what are the point of those things on the bristle nose pleco are those barbels

    So a 29 gal tank can fit 8 harlequin rasboras, 6 black phantom tetras, 1 hoeny gourami and 1 bristle nose pleco.
    Last edited by a moderator: Aug 14, 2015
  8. Dom90Fishlore VIPMember

    Yea I believe that should work.
  9. tyguy7760Fishlore VIPMember

    You could also do a clown pleco for another type of pleco that would work. Both need driftwood in the tank if you don't already have some

    If the gravel is smooth I wouldn't worry about the cory's. If it is low grade cheap gravel that has sharp edges then yes but smooth stone or high grade gravel should be fine. I have them in my tank with very smooth gravel and also have a friend that has had false julii and panda cory's in gravel for a couple of years and their barbels are huge.

    I myself have 3 oto's that I tried out (was concerned about the same thing you were that I had seen so many horror stories about how delicate they are) and they are doing fine. I have a theory of why people think they are so sensitive.

    1) Oto's in particular go through a lot before they come to your tank. They are usually half starved as many do not eat the algae wafers very well. Usually by the time you get them they are on the brink and do not make it. It's important to have a good stock from your LFS.

    2) I think a lot of times people buy them to clean their algae and they do a fantastic job. But after a few weeks, when they have consumed all of the algae, they starve. Oto's should have at least a fresh veggie a week and many fish keepers do not go this extra step.

    If you want to try Oto's I wouldn't let the horror stories scare you. You could pick up 2 or 3 and test them out for a month. If they live, you can add to the group.

    I personally am sticking with the 3 I originally bought. They seem happy and keep round bellies. I don't want to risk it adding any more and they don't really school together anyways. I know many people on here disagree with me and that's fine. But my 3 are very healthy, fat, and happy.
  10. junebugFishlore LegendMember

    Otos will be fine in your tank.... I don't get why you'd discount them if they're the fish you want. They should, however, be added last, and you should try to get captive bred specimens, or specimens that have lived captively for several weeks. You'll also want to make sure your tank has a healthy algae colony for them to feed them until you can train them onto prepared foods.

    If you decide not to get them anyway, a small species BN pleco would be probably the most ideal alternative. You want a species that stays under 5", some do get quite a bit larger so be sure you know what you're buying.
  11. EmilyClick28Valued MemberMember

  12. Anders247Fishlore LegendMember

    Angels wouldn't work in this size tank though, and guppies and mollies aren't exactly something one would get to replace otos...
    How about a school of 6 kuhli loaches?

  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice