need help

Status
Not open for further replies.

bigones1993

New Member
Messages
33
Reaction score
0
Points
31
Location
new jersey
Experience
1 year
ok so i have a 55 gallon semi aggressive tank but my fish are dying due to being definned i have 6 tiger barb who i feel my be the problem and also 5 mosquito fish who i caught at a local lake so far i have lost 2 clown loach and almost one bala i had to transfer him to a hospital tank today because his tail had been nipped badly i also have 3 blue ram cichlad and a small bull head catfish i feel like the cat fish could have killed the clown loach but not the bala the cat is too slow i need help heres a list of all the fish BEFORE the i lost the clowns and moved the bala 6 tiger barb 5 mosquito fish 3 blue ram cichlad 2 clown loach 2 bala shark 2 cory catfish 1 sail fin pleco 1 spotted pleco 1 zebra danio 1 red tail shark 1 bull head catfish i need some advice what should i do how should i figure out which fish to blame somebody help im still a newbie and not too ashamed to learn i am eager to learn and not lose any more fish i loved those clown loach

on top of that i was always told clown loaches get along well with tiger barbs should i buy more tigers? by the way i seperated the mosquito fish into another tank to hopefully find out who is responsible
 
Last edited by a moderator:

AmazonPassion

Moderator
Messages
8,606
Reaction score
542
Points
478
Location
Denver
Experience
More than 10 years
Welcome to Fishlore....

Before you do anything else, I would suggest reading up on the Nitrogen Cycle since your profile states that you don't know it. I'm "suspecting" that your fish are dying because of ammonia poison and not because of the other fish in the tank. However, I am just speculating because I do not know your water parameters.

I would read this link first: https://www.fishlore.com/NitrogenCycle.htm

Then I would do additional more readings: https://www.fishlore.com/aquariumfishforum/threads/read-first-freshwater-beginner-important-topics.14296/

If you have a liquid test, I suggest testing your water to see if you have a cycle going...most people including myself recommend API Master Test Kit. You are checking for ammonia, nitrite, and nitrates.
 
  • Thread starter
  • Thread Starter
  • #3
OP
B

bigones1993

New Member
Messages
33
Reaction score
0
Points
31
Location
new jersey
Experience
1 year
thanks for a the info is it possible that due to these cycles the fish become weak and easy prey for the tigers because every fish that has died has has significant cunks of tail missing and the bala has a very chiped up tail as well
 

luke355027355027

Well Known Member
Messages
1,429
Reaction score
9
Points
123
Location
bel air maryland
Experience
2 years
Ill start out with clown loaches arent aggressive fish and they grow way to big for a 55. Secondly if the tiger barbs arent nippping it may be the danio. I would rehome the bala as they grow to be a foot long and are shy.

You could substitute clown loaches with a school of red tailed loaches which look at the same except their blue with orange fins. I would alao try to rehome the sailfin pleco as they get pretty big. I dont know about mosquito fish and if you want to keep the corys i would increase their school to five

Agreed if you dont know about the nitrogen cycle thats probally the most important thing

On a side note ninjaed
 

AmazonPassion

Moderator
Messages
8,606
Reaction score
542
Points
478
Location
Denver
Experience
More than 10 years
I didn't want to bombard you with a lot of information at first.

To answer your question yes. Some of the species you have listed aren't compatible with each other, tank size, and some are extremely sensitve and shouldn't be in uncycled tank.
 

luke355027355027

Well Known Member
Messages
1,429
Reaction score
9
Points
123
Location
bel air maryland
Experience
2 years
I didn't want to bombard you with a lot of information at first.

To answer your question yes. Some of the species you have listed aren't compatible with each other, tank size, and some are extremely sensitve and shouldn't be in uncycled tank.
Small clown loaches would be the first to go in an uncycled tank
 
  • Thread starter
  • Thread Starter
  • #7
OP
B

bigones1993

New Member
Messages
33
Reaction score
0
Points
31
Location
new jersey
Experience
1 year
ok so heres where i stand the danio is one of five i had in the ten gallon 4 died again definning i figured going to a much bigger tank would help the problem the poor little guy is the soul survivor and he is very scared of other fish he keeps a big distance from others i feel bad for him i will get more danios for him one day when this is all settled but because he is scared i dont think its him and none of my fish look sick they all have good color and act normal the only weird act i see is the balas and only the balas do this they will hover vertically nose down tail up in the middle of the tank i do not know if this is normal i have seen both the tigers and mosquitos chase others around and the bull head as well and i am aware of the size issue with many of my fish i plan to go even bigger one day but due to my current lease agreement on my house i am limited to what i have im already 5 gallons over and again thanks for the advice keep it coming and thanks for reading my thread and long response
 
  • Thread starter
  • Thread Starter
  • #8
OP
B

bigones1993

New Member
Messages
33
Reaction score
0
Points
31
Location
new jersey
Experience
1 year
and also was it wise to move the bala out of the 55 due to his tail? and please tell me more about what of my fish should not be together i love my fish i want to reduce conflict in my tanks as much as possible

and heres another idea i want some advice on should i put all my suspected tail nippers into my other tank transfer the ones in my other tank into my 55?

should i try for a more peaceful tank community since im a newbie?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • Thread starter
  • Thread Starter
  • #10
OP
B

bigones1993

New Member
Messages
33
Reaction score
0
Points
31
Location
new jersey
Experience
1 year
ok so last night i put all my accused fin nippers into one tank i woke up to find that two of my mosquitos in much worse shape than just definned they were mutilated and my biggest tiger who is older than the other 5 by a few months is very agressive towards the others today whats my next step? seperate him from the others? i need some help here
 

Samurai Jack 77

Valued Member
Messages
238
Reaction score
3
Points
113
Location
Duluth, Minnesota
Experience
1 year
I agree with Amazon. Your first step should be to Rehome all the fish and Then make sure to cycle the tank. You can't just throw fish in different tanks that aren't cycled cause you'll never get rid of the real problem.
 
  • Thread starter
  • Thread Starter
  • #12
OP
B

bigones1993

New Member
Messages
33
Reaction score
0
Points
31
Location
new jersey
Experience
1 year
i understand that the tank needs a cycle but i cant simply rehome them the one tank i have that is cycled is much to small for them and in the process of find other enthusiasts who could help at the rate they are going none will be left i really need help to stop the fighting until the tank is cycled they were fine for two weeks then all of a sudden they decided they didnt like who was in the tank with them i need some help to fix this while the big tank is cycling
 

Thunder_o_b

Fishlore VIP
Messages
9,484
Reaction score
5,849
Points
508
Location
North East Ohio…USA
Experience
More than 10 years
i understand that the tank needs a cycle but i cant simply rehome them the one tank i have that is cycled is much to small for them and in the process of find other enthusiasts who could help at the rate they are going none will be left i really need help to stop the fighting until the tank is cycled they were fine for two weeks then all of a sudden they decided they didnt like who was in the tank with them i need some help to fix this while the big tank is cycling
Do you have a petco near by? The one near me will take fish off your hands and then give them for free to people that will take them. Not the best solution, but may be your only option.
 
  • Thread starter
  • Thread Starter
  • #16
OP
B

bigones1993

New Member
Messages
33
Reaction score
0
Points
31
Location
new jersey
Experience
1 year
BaH... from experience and stories anything that ends in "barb" is trouble lol
i feel almost the same way i love tiger barbs but they have been trouble and no there is not a petco near i get my fish from a petsmart and they are almost an hour away but thanks for all the advice guys at this point im almost at a total loss of ideas i put 4 of my small ones back in the big tank they seem ok right now calm and together i dont like moving the fish around so much in the small tank three fish are going at it the oldest barb the gold skirt tetra and the small barb is caught in the mix i might take the small one out but heres the thing what if in a few months i get all the cycle down and regulated and the tigers get this way again or if it was already cycled and it happened later down the road with other fish what is a remedy im eager to learn as i am still a newbie
 

flyinggogo

Valued Member
Messages
373
Reaction score
2
Points
103
Location
Omaha, NE
Experience
2 years
Ok, if you do not want your head to explode, grab a phone book call your LFS's and ask them if they use sponge filters. If yes ask/beg them to sell you one. Pop that in your tank and boom, cycle problem solved. Then you can concentrate on the real issue of rehoming some fish. Post a add on CL or something similar and try to rehome the bala or the barbs or vice versa. Personally i would keep the bala and rehome the barbs. Keeping barbs limilts what you can put in your tank by a lot. If you keep the bala, get a school of them. You will be fine with the balas in the 55 for a long time, but you will have to rehome them or get a bigger tank eventually. Chances are your balas will be 7 or 8 inches fully grown, but they can be 14 inches. So while everyone that says you need to get rid of everything now has your fish best interest at heart, they know that you can keep the balas in a 55 for like 2+ years and are giving you bad advice with good intentions.
 
  • Thread starter
  • Thread Starter
  • #18
OP
B

bigones1993

New Member
Messages
33
Reaction score
0
Points
31
Location
new jersey
Experience
1 year
and heres another possible outcome the catfish like the pleco is a night feeder and the deaths more often than not happen at night this bull head who also got moved into the small tank yesterday may be the killer he cant catch the tigers but the mosquitos he could and the loach i dont think the bala but if the bala was sleeping or something i guess he could thoughts?
 

flyinggogo

Valued Member
Messages
373
Reaction score
2
Points
103
Location
Omaha, NE
Experience
2 years
One more thing why do you have a bullhead. I think they like cold water so the warm water you need is probably making it mad and killing it
Edit: pretty much all native species are predators
edit 2: and might be illegal
 
  • Thread starter
  • Thread Starter
  • #20
OP
B

bigones1993

New Member
Messages
33
Reaction score
0
Points
31
Location
new jersey
Experience
1 year
Ok, if you do not want your head to explode, grab a phone book call your LFS's and ask them if they use sponge filters. If yes ask/beg them to sell you one. Pop that in your tank and boom, cycle problem solved. Then you can concentrate on the real issue of rehoming some fish. Post a add on CL or something similar and try to rehome the bala or the barbs or vice versa. Personally i would keep the bala and rehome the barbs. Keeping barbs limilts what you can put in your tank by a lot. If you keep the bala, get a school of them. You will be fine with the balas in the 55 for a long time, but you will have to rehome them or get a bigger tank eventually. Chances are your balas will be 7 or 8 inches fully grown, but they can be 14 inches. So while everyone that says you need to get rid of everything now has your fish best interest at heart, they know that you can keep the balas in a 55 for like 2+ years and are giving you bad advice with good intentions.
thank you atleast someone is willing to help and not just go on and on about the cycle i understand it was a HUGE mistake to introduce fish without cycling the tank but whats done is done yes the fish can be rehomed and if any of you guys live in new jersey heres my email alexmolloy_1993@yahoo.com im willing to work something out and i will be moving away from semi agressive i think i need to learn more about that style community i also read that in some shoals having one or two larger or smaller barbs may cause them to be stressed but im not sure if thats the problem. my biggest worry right now is the adult barb and my gold skirt tetra hate each other and i now have five young barbs in a tank with a fancy guppy witch even as a newbie i know is a recipe for disaster
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Toggle Sidebar




Top Bottom