55 Gallon Tank jack dempsey and oscar

raam96

Member
Hi, i'm saving up for a 55 gallon tank and am wondering if a jack dempsey and an albino tiger oscar would be compatible in the tank together. I know it would be tough to keep it clean but i'd be able to keep up with it.
 

bolivianbaby

Member
They are compatible, but I wouldn't advise putting them both in a 55g. That won't leave them a lot of swimming space.

For an oscar and a JD, in my opinion, a minimum 75 gallon would be a good size tank for swimming space. Granted, that's just my opinion.

Let's see what other responses you get to help you make your final decision.
 
  • Thread Starter

raam96

Member
well i've been doing research and i'm kinda thinking against the oscar. I still want the JD for sure tho. would a JD and my pleco in my 20 gallon (supposed to grow to 16") be ok? if not what else could I have. I really want a JD and possibly one other fish with him.
 

bolivianbaby

Member
The common plecos that grow to 16" need a minimum of 55g. JD's also require a minimum of 55g.

With my JD's, I've kept (successfully) convicts, rainbow cichlids and an RTS. I'm also keeping salvinI cichlids with a non-spawning pair of JD's, but this is new, so I can't say it's been successful yet.

Blue acara and firemouths are also two species that I've heard are compatible with JD's.

I'd advise saving up for the 55 gallon tank, though. That will be a wonderful habitat for your JD and you can research species you'd like to keep him/her with.

Since you mentioned saving up for the tank, don't forget Craigslist is an excellent source for less expensive tanks.
 
  • Thread Starter

raam96

Member
thanks bolivianbaby.
 

bolivianbaby

Member
Anytime
 

cm11599ps

Member
I have an Oscar & JD. They are both about 5" long right now. They dont' chase each other around the tank, but hey do go mouth to mouth with each other with their mouths wide open.

I would suggest a bigger tank.
 

blueiristyson

Member
Yeah a lot of tank space is very important for two cichlids that get 10 in +
 

Hendrix Fish

Member
Hahahaha, sorry I was just looking up an answer (I know this thread was from a while ago) and this guy said a Dempsey needs 714 gallons .
 
Top Bottom