Is This Tap Safe Safe?

Esimm03

Well Known Member
Messages
2,003
Reaction score
903
Points
148
Experience
3 years
Hi,

So someone gave me there old fish tank and it had things like a filter and heater ect...

There was a bottle of tetra tap safe in there and as I need some more I thought of using it, however the price label said it's from a local pet store that closed down about 2 years ago and they said the tank had been in the shed about 5 years, is it safe to put it in my tank ?


Ethan
 

Nanologist

Well Known Member
Messages
1,927
Reaction score
3,008
Points
298
Experience
3 years
Is it the "Aquasafe" product?

To my knowledge, Seachem Prime and Tetra Aquasafe uses Sodium Hydroxymethane Sulfinate (hence the sulfur smell) and does not expire.

Other dechlorinators use Sodium Thiosulfate, but usually have a expiration date on the bottle of a few years.

At any rate, if it's not Tetra Aquasafe I would toss it anyways and get a bottle of that or Seachem Prime. They are inexpensive and work much better than the alternatives.
 
  • Thread starter
  • Thread Starter
  • #5

Esimm03

Well Known Member
Messages
2,003
Reaction score
903
Points
148
Experience
3 years
Is it the "Aquasafe" product?

To my knowledge, Seachem Prime and Tetra Aquasafe uses Sodium Hydroxymethane Sulfinate (hence the sulfur smell) and does not expire.

Other dechlorinators use Sodium Thiosulfate, but usually have a expiration date on the bottle of a few years.

At any rate, if it's not Tetra Aquasafe I would toss it anyways and get a bottle of that or Seachem Prime. They are inexpensive and work much better than the alternatives.
Hi,

It is tetra aquasafe, it smells of sulfur.

Also I'm setting up an RO unit soon as I'm getting a marine tank, if I use this in my freshwater tanks do I not need to use any sort of decloranator?

Thanks,
Ethan
Is it the "Aquasafe" product?

To my knowledge, Seachem Prime and Tetra Aquasafe uses Sodium Hydroxymethane Sulfinate (hence the sulfur smell) and does not expire.

Other dechlorinators use Sodium Thiosulfate, but usually have a expiration date on the bottle of a few years.

At any rate, if it's not Tetra Aquasafe I would toss it anyways and get a bottle of that or Seachem Prime. They are inexpensive and work much better than the alternatives.
 

SuperK

Well Known Member
Messages
612
Reaction score
143
Points
78
Experience
1 year
Hi,

It is tetra aquasafe, it smells of sulfur.

Also I'm setting up an RO unit soon as I'm getting a marine tank, if I use this in my freshwater tanks do I not need to use any sort of decloranator?

Thanks,
Ethan
If you're talking about RO, from what I've heard people are against using it mainly because it takes out a lot of the minerals and other things freshwater fish need. Marine water is different (salinity and such aside). If you wanted to use RO most likely you would need to add minerals back which would be more expensive than adding dechlorinator.

Then again I could be wrong, if anyone could clarify that'd be great. I was considering getting one but after I read about it I read it wasn't necessary.


Edit: I forget to talk about the dechlorinator. From what I know you still have to add it, but again I could be wrong. I've never used RO so I've not had experience. I've only read up on it a bit.
 

RyleighJ

Valued Member
Messages
427
Reaction score
155
Points
88
Experience
Just started
That looks like a Julian date to me. 10 300 23. 10 is the month, 300 is the day of the year, and 23 is the year. So October 27, 2023.

I have no clue how long dechlorinator is supposed to last, but based on what others have said I don't think that's too unreasonable of a date.
 

Nanologist

Well Known Member
Messages
1,927
Reaction score
3,008
Points
298
Experience
3 years
Hi,

It is tetra aquasafe, it smells of sulfur.

Also I'm setting up an RO unit soon as I'm getting a marine tank, if I use this in my freshwater tanks do I not need to use any sort of decloranator?

Thanks,
Ethan
From DFS website: "Reverse osmosis removes virtually everything from tap water, including essential minerals your aquarium inhabitants need to flourish. Most marine salt mixes already contain these minerals and the use of RO conditioners is not necessary. However, freshwater aquariums require re-mineralization to achieve the desired pH."

As mentioned it's more expensive to remineralize water than to dechlorinate tap water.

I also wanted to add, if you're concerned at all with the expiration then I would personally toss it out and buy some more. I prefer Seachem Prime and wish I'd known about it when I was a teenager. It may seem like it's more expensive (because the purchase price is more) but in fact it is by far the most cost effective.

I remember adding somewhere around 48 drops per gallon of cheap Top Fin dechlorinator to a 5 gallon tank. That was never fun counting over a hundred drops for each water change. The Prime is 2 drops per gallon... In the long run you save both time and money.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • Thread starter
  • Thread Starter
  • #9

Esimm03

Well Known Member
Messages
2,003
Reaction score
903
Points
148
Experience
3 years
I also wanted to add, if you're concerned at all with the expiration then I would personally toss it out and buy some more. I prefer Seachem Prime and wish I'd known about it when I was a teenager. It may seem like it's more expensive (because the purchase price is more) but in fact it is by far the most cost effective.

I remember adding somewhere around 48 drops per gallon of cheap Top Fin dechlorinator to a 5 gallon tank. That was never fun counting over a hundred drops for each water change. The Prime is 2 drops per gallon... In the long run you save both time and money.
Ok,

I'm just worried ill do a water change and the next morning everything is dead.

I'll grab another bottle tomorrow.

Ethan
 
Toggle Sidebar

Aquarium Calculator

Follow FishLore!





Top Bottom