Is a red belly piranha good in a 40 gallon long tank?

if I put one in and then the other one later will they be aggressive towards eachoher

 

if I put 1 in now and 1 in later will they be aggressive towards each othert

 

maybe

and didnt mean to create an argument here seems to me more like a debate but like to say a few last words

Jon all fish grow differently my gradpa got 6 angels in a 29 gallon tank some became 5-6 inches long and some only 3 why that is its just nature as for piranahs some will get 12+ inches and some may stay only 6or8 inches its called nature and think about it what's the likelyhood of a friend of mine whos a kid getting a bigger tank then what he got anytime soon young kids are usually unemplowyed and when we get a job we save for colleg or a car as I am sure you are awar of since you are 14 and I am not sure wher eyou get all your money from whether you are rich or your parents give you a lot but where we live you can't get employed until you are 14 with a worker permit and that's at mcdonalds at 15 some stores and at 16 a few more stores but you get minimum wage 5.35 an hour I believe but I want this forum to stay nice and enemy free so before we start hating each other from a silly debate like this lets just leave it alone and try to help my friend and not scare away any newcomers

 

since you said all fish grow different sizes couldent I get two and if one starts to grow to rapidly take it bake to the petstore. I love my fish but you don't have to go by the rules for everything I mean if I get two and one gets to big I can give it back or sell it right?

 

problem petsupermarket doesn't take back fish and once your pirahana I don't know of any fw lfs's around us that will take it so you could try selling it on various places but it would be hard to ship it so if you want to have the posiblity of going through the trouble go ahead

 

well I would think the pirrahna would be worth going through that trouble wouldent you. also it doesent neccasarly have to grow really big it might fit well who knows jon seemed to know a lot and he was o ym side

 

expect the worst

 

were is Jon though usually he is on all night long everyday

 

i9 will expect the worst but I probably fined some who will buy it especially if or buy or swap idea works

 

I don't know where JON is maybe he is busy he will probably be on later

 

how would you ship it

 

I could have a pick up only or I probably could give it to a store by my moms work I mean they have some big red belly pirrahnas

 

hey Jon was on earlier today but I wonder when and why he didnt post anything here

hope gunnie and butterfly come on soon

 

ya same here they are really knowledgabel(not that you are not atmmachine816) and they can hel pme in a big decision like this I hope they come

 

I think gunnie has already spoken I think she disagreed with putting one pirahana in there

 

yes but she also said I can I have my own opionion. I don't know what I'm going to do but ill tell everyone over the weekend

 

I'm on but I'm not in a very argumentative mood... just do what you want... if worst comes to worse I'm sure you'll find someone to take one of the pirahnas off ure hands.

 

Ok thanks I think I'm getting two andthen selling one if it gets to big or if the tank is too dirty so I think I'm getting two.

 

K gl and most importantly hf... make sure you watch them closely and just do what you think is right. check with other pirahna owners and clean your tank often... make sure to be careful when cleaning your tank though lol... pirahnas yikes!

 

yes I heard you have to get them young so they don't bit you're finger. my dad said as a joke once they get big lets play a gam. the game is who ever sticks there hand in the longest wns you might have to be called knubs after it but you would win lol

 

also thanks for your cauton.I am a dedicated fish owner and will do what ever it takes to keep the one/two pirrahnas happy

 

lol

well have fun and don't lose ne fingers

glad to here that last post

 

n/p thanks for all of your help

 

sounds like you have some thinking to do tonight greg

 

yes I sure do what a big decision wow

 

Just thought I give you guys a small update, one of his pirhanas died and the one left is now feeding on rosy reds.

 

Thanks for the update
Carol