I'm puzzled

  • Thread starter

chrt396

Well Known Member
Messages
1,575
Reaction score
15
Points
83
Experience
1 year
Not new to this...well aware of the cycle...but this 55 gallon African tank has me puzzled. Filled r' up with Prime'd water...added Tetra Safe start..added 8 fish. You would THINK that I would be noticing some ammonia after 1 week. NOTHING! Every reading I take shows zeros across the board. No Nitrates,,,Nitrites or Ammonia. Do these fish pee or poop? I'm getting ready to help them with a specimen!!!!

Every tank I have of any size..has shown ammonia is less than 1 week. This one...NOPE! I did add 5 1/2 tablespoons of aquarium salt to the tank upon recommendation from the local fish expert. I hear that salt is a very controversial subject within the African Cichlid owners...but he was pretty strong in his recommendation..so I did. Would salt affect the readings?

OR....

Am I just being impatient? I don't want to starve off the Tetra Safe Start without any ammonia. How long can that stuff last without a host??
 

Aqua Hero

Well Known Member
Messages
811
Reaction score
12
Points
53
Experience
More than 10 years
you have zero nitrates in an african chiclid tank? I'm pretty sure you haven't cycled your tank properly
 
  • Thread starter

chrt396

Well Known Member
Messages
1,575
Reaction score
15
Points
83
Experience
1 year
Aqua Hero said:
you have zero nitrates in an african chiclid tank? I'm pretty sure you haven't cycled your tank properly
No kidding!! It cannot even start the cycle without ammonia. I'm saying that there are no traces of ANYTHING!! WHERE IS THE AMMONIA?

As you said..this is an African Cichlid tank and they eat sloppily...I would assume that they pee and poop...so WHERE IS THE AMMONIA? My bacteria needs some food!!!!!!!!
 

Rogue

Valued Member
Messages
431
Reaction score
5
Points
63
Experience
5 years
How long was it between the time you added the Safe Start and when you added the fish?
 

Aqua Hero

Well Known Member
Messages
811
Reaction score
12
Points
53
Experience
More than 10 years
Wait if its zero ammonia then that's completely normal. It means your bacteria is eating to ammonia fast enough so that there are no traces in the water. This is the same with nitrites. However, with nitrates it's pretty hard and rare to have zero. And in an African cichlid there must be nitrates.

Are you testing the water properly
 

KarenLM

Well Known Member
Messages
741
Reaction score
3
Points
63
Experience
1 year
With TSS you add it and let it do its thing for 2 weeks - no testing.

Are you feeding the fish daily? If so, and the fish are acting normal I would just let it be for the 14 days, then test.
 
  • Thread starter

chrt396

Well Known Member
Messages
1,575
Reaction score
15
Points
83
Experience
1 year
Aqua Hero said:
you have zero nitrates in an african chiclid tank? I'm pretty sure you haven't cycled your tank properly
It is 1 week old!! I don't really expect much in nitrates. I do expect ammonia...which turns to nitrite...THEN nitrates.

Rogue said:
How long was it between the time you added the Safe Start and when you added the fish?
Added the TSS the next day. Introduced 5 specimens and 1 8oz bottle the next day.
 

Aqua Hero

Well Known Member
Messages
811
Reaction score
12
Points
53
Experience
More than 10 years
chrt396 said:
It is 1 week old!! I don't really expect much in nitrates. I do expect ammonia...which turns to nitrite...THEN nitrates.
I'm confused, if you cycled your tank you shouldnt have any ammonia or nitrites. That's the whole point of cycling the tank. Did you cycle it for a week or has it been a week since you cycled it
 
  • Thread starter

chrt396

Well Known Member
Messages
1,575
Reaction score
15
Points
83
Experience
1 year
KarenLM said:
With TSS you add it and let it do its thing for 2 weeks - no testing.

Are you feeding the fish daily? If so, and the fish are acting normal I would just let it be for the 14 days, then test.
'
I'm waiting...somewhat impatiently. I have been feeding regularly..although lightly. They are messy eaters and let a lot drop to the bottom. They may scavenge after I walk away...but you would think with the wasted food...that would be a catapult to the ammonia stage. It's been a week,,,and I now have 11 fish in the tank! NO AMMONIA!!!! Wat up wit dat?? I mean...that tube is as yellow as it can be. The Nitrates...same. Nitrites..as blue as the sky!

Fish are acting normal and ornery. I replaced about 50 pounds of rock in the tank today...since I didn't like the color scheme of the rock...stirred up a lot and irritated a few fish. They were actively seeking out new hiding places and swimming in and out of the openings that I left for them. I'll keep testing...but heck....my 90 gallon and both my 29's started showing signs of the cycle within 4 days. You would think with these crazy guys in the tank, that it would show up on day 2.

I'm overstocked for a cycle..but again...I am impatient...and doing so has made a heck of a lot more peace in the tank.

OH..by the way...these Africans have some size to them as well. They are NOT juveniles. They have their color and are between 3 and 4 inches lip to tip.

Aqua Hero said:
I'm confused, if you cycled your tank you shouldnt have any ammonia or nitrites. That's the whole point of cycling the tank. Did you cycle it for a week or has it been a week since you cycled it
My friend....the tank is NOT cycled!! Repeat...it is NOT cycled. There are no traces of anything at this point. The whole topic here is WHY I am not showing any ammonia. I am aware of the cycle..but I have never seen a tank not establish ammonia after 1 week with ANY type of fish..especially Africans. I can handle the cycling of the tank...the question I have is WHY there is no ammonia. If you have a answer to that..please let me know.
@Jsigmo Anders247
 

kidster9700

Well Known Member
Messages
1,332
Reaction score
2
Points
133
Experience
More than 10 years
Well I think the guess is that the bacteria are eating the ammonia. But it sounds like the stuff you added might be messing with the tests if it says to wait two weeks before checking your water parameters. So I would wait until it's been 14 days and then check it.
Basically, the test is either showing up incorrect from the TSS or ???


 
  • Thread starter

chrt396

Well Known Member
Messages
1,575
Reaction score
15
Points
83
Experience
1 year
The Good Lord did NOT bless me with patience. Sigh!!! I guess I could actually sit there, watch them and enjoy them..instead of worrying about it.
 

kidster9700

Well Known Member
Messages
1,332
Reaction score
2
Points
133
Experience
More than 10 years
chrt396 said:
The Good Lord did NOT bless me with patience. Sigh!!! I guess I could actually sit there, watch them and enjoy them..instead of worrying about it.
I know what you mean. Just enjoy your tank.


 
  • Moderator

jdhef

Moderator
Messages
14,279
Reaction score
3,408
Points
583
Experience
More than 10 years
One would think that you would be seeing either ammonia, nitrites or nitrate. So I'll ask the obvious question first, Are you sure your test kit has not expired? Also if using the API kit are you really shaking the snot out of bottle #2?

Other than that, just go with it and keep an eye on things.
 
  • Thread starter

chrt396

Well Known Member
Messages
1,575
Reaction score
15
Points
83
Experience
1 year
jdhef said:
One would think that you would be seeing either ammonia, nitrites or nitrate. So I'll ask the obvious question first, Are you sure your test kit has not expired? Also if using the API kit are you really shaking the snot out of bottle #2?

Other than that, just go with it and keep an eye on things.
I have two API test kits. Both are good til 2019 and 2020. I do the rumba with bottle number two and practice my drum solos with it.

Guess...I should be practicing patience. My ammonia test liquid is gonna get some usage this next week!

It's just amazing how 6 cherry barbs and 4 gold barbs can show ammonia in a 29 gallon in 5 days...and 11 African beasts can't produce enough to do it in a week! I even double checked my Fluval 406 to make sure I didn't put any carbon in it. NOPE...did not! I get involved in projects in the wee hours so..who knows!
 

KarenLM

Well Known Member
Messages
741
Reaction score
3
Points
63
Experience
1 year
Patience is a virtue. I suggest you hide your test kit for another week then pull it out, unless your fish start showing signs of stress or illness.

TSS tells you to not test for a reason - you'll panic!

Sit back and relax. Let the TSS work its magic.
 

Dom90

Fishlore VIP
Messages
5,449
Reaction score
10
Points
223
Experience
3 years
Another reason I like to advocate Stability, the readings aren't as crazy and the spikes aren't as spikey. But that's just my opinion.


 
  • Thread starter

chrt396

Well Known Member
Messages
1,575
Reaction score
15
Points
83
Experience
1 year
KarenLM said:
Patience is a virtue. I suggest you hide your test kit for another week then pull it out, unless your fish start showing signs of stress or illness.

TSS tells you to not test for a reason - you'll panic!

Sit back and relax. Let the TSS work its magic.
I guess I didn't read the "no testing" part. That would have saved me some key strokes and a few gray hairs!
 
  • Thread starter

chrt396

Well Known Member
Messages
1,575
Reaction score
15
Points
83
Experience
1 year
Just an update. Yesterday...I noticed a change in testing. I took two days off from stressing..and yesterday I noticed the ammonia went to .25 ppm..so I added another bottle of TSS...and today, the readings are .25ppm ammonia, .25ppm nitrates...and 5.0ppm Nitrate. We are now on the ride!! Protect and preserve mode!!
 

csawyer98

New Member
Messages
23
Reaction score
0
Points
26
Experience
5 years
The prime may have been the culprit. When I use prime the ammonia and nitrites drop to nothing because they are converted into a slightly different chemical structure that is less toxic and some test kits don't pick up on the safer substances

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using Fish Lore Aquarium Fish Forum mobile app
 
  • Thread starter

chrt396

Well Known Member
Messages
1,575
Reaction score
15
Points
83
Experience
1 year
csawyer98 said:
The prime may have been the culprit. When I use prime the ammonia and nitrites drop to nothing because they are converted into a slightly different chemical structure that is less toxic and some test kits don't pick up on the safer substances

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using Fish Lore Aquarium Fish Forum mobile app
You are right to a degree..however..I only added Prime when the tank was originally filled up then waited two days before I added bacteria. THEN I added fish...and more fish. Have not primed the tank at all during cycle nor have I changed water. The cycle is progressing. .25 Ammonia...0 nitrites and 5ppm of nitrates. All is going well...so far. It should be completed this week or next.

I actually added another bottle of TSS when the ammonia started to show to make sure that bacteria was present. I wasn't sure if within the entire 1 1/2 week wait with no ammonia had starved off hte bacteria. Since I wasn't sure..and it wasn't going to hurt to add another bottle of TSS..except my wallet...I added the TSS
 
Toggle Sidebar

New Threads

Similar Threads

Aquarium Calculator

Aquarium Photo Contests

Follow FishLore!

FishLore on Social Media





Top Bottom