HOB or Canister?

Discussion in 'Polls' started by Isabella, Jan 25, 2006.


If you had a tank between 75 - 125 gallons, which filter would you get?

  1. Hang On Back

  2. Canister

  1. Isabella

    IsabellaFishlore VIPMember

    If you could have a tank as large as at least 75 galllons, up to 125 gallons, which filter would you get and why? Would you get more than one of the same kind?
  2. dahly

    dahlyValued MemberMember

    I like the ease of cleaning and non existant monthly added cost of my Aqua Clear HOB's. Cleaning is a breeze and with their low cost at purchase, I can get two and get the 10x filtering capacity recommended for less than one cannister filter.
  3. Dino

    DinoFishlore VIPMember

    With I like Aquaclears very much, the rena Filstar cannister filters push a great deal more water thru a larger amount of media.

    Thats the way I would go for bigger tanks.

  4. Butterfly

    ButterflyModeratorModerator Member

    I really like my HOB filters, for their ease of cleaning.
  5. Gunnie

    GunnieWell Known MemberMember

    I personally hate HOB filters but still use them on some of my tanks. Canister filters are my favorite filters.
  6. OP

    IsabellaFishlore VIPMember

    Thank you for the replies :)
  7. atmmachine816

    atmmachine816Fishlore VIPMember

    canisters are too expensive for me right now so i just use hob
  8. Jason

    JasonWell Known MemberMember

    I'm gettin a canister for my new tank
  9. 0morrokh

    0morrokhFishlore VIPMember

    HOB filters are cheaper and easier, but due to their design are much less efficient. So, if I had enough money (which I probably wouldn't ;)), I would go with a canister.
  10. COBettaCouple

    COBettaCoupleFishlore LegendMember

    2 HOBs, each rated for that tank capacity, one on each side.
  11. darkwolf29a

    darkwolf29aValued MemberMember

    Both. :D

    But, then...I have a 75 gallon, with an Oscar in it, and I use the cannister for biofilteration and the HOB as the water polisher. ;)
  12. Sabi

    SabiWell Known MemberMember

  13. Tayful

    TayfulValued MemberMember

    Canister all the way, I have a 70g and that's what I'm using. :)
  14. hockeyref88

    hockeyref88Well Known MemberMember

    I have canisters on all of mine and love them. If cost is an issue I can understand not using one, but only for that reason.

  15. sirdarksol

    sirdarksolFishlore LegendMember

    I answered "Canister" but it kind of depends on the range. I have a 90g with a HOB, but it also is understocked, has a lot of plants, and has a refugium with lucky bamboo to provide extra biological filtration and to draw nitrates from the water. If I were to only have one kind of filter on a larger tank than that, it would be a canister.
  16. Tumbleweed

    TumbleweedWell Known MemberMember

    I prefer a canister filter. I use the Fluval 405 on my 100gal tank and love it. Really quiet, easy to use, and has a great biological filter on it. Plus I think the tank looks much cleaner having the filter under it hidden in the stand and only 2 pipes hanging on the back vs. a large filter system itself hanking on the tank.
  17. MousePotato

    MousePotatoWell Known MemberMember

    I agree with Tumbleweed. Plus, my HOB does make such a mess on the wall, the lights, me, when I get too close... They are easier to clean, but they also need cleaning more often.
  18. CoryMac

    CoryMacValued MemberMember

    Canister & HOB together the more the better;)
    Last edited: Apr 8, 2009
  19. bettafish2816

    bettafish2816Fishlore VIPMember

    canister! if they made canisters small and cheap enough i would get one for every single one of my tanks!
  20. FL CommunityFans

    FL CommunityFansWell Known MemberMember

    Where's the option for BOTH?!

    I run a canister on all large tanks as well as a HOB. The canister is my primary bio-filter and the HOb I stuff full of AC sponges to act as a supreme mechanical filter. 4 of 100/70 sponges in an emp400 a long with the marineland blue pad and you'll have some nice mech. filtration ;)