Gone Without A Trace

Discussion in 'Freshwater Beginners' started by Robjoco, Apr 22, 2018.

  1. RobjocoValued MemberMember

    Is there a Bermuda Triangle in my tank?! 2 fish have vanished in the last week. I took apart the hob (fluval 70) to make sure they didn’t get sucked up, and there’s also nothing in or around decor.

    I’m currently cycling my new 55 gallon tank.
    Started cycling 30 March. Used api tap conditioner and api QuickStart.
    Upon questionable advice from the internet, added 10 young white clouds on 6 April.
    After about a week, only finding 9 fish. Convince myself that the store miscounted.
    On 18 April, switched to seachem prime and stability.

    This morning, I’m down to 8 fish. They seem too small to swallow the evidence overnight! What’s happening?

    pH: 8.2
    Ammonia: .25
    Nitrite: .5
    Nitrate: 5

    Sorry if this is too much detail. I’m just perplexed.

  2. SeasoldierWell Known MemberMember

    Hi, well your Ph, ammonia & nitrite aren't going to make life comfortable for the fish & the ammonia & nitrite over time will kill them. What temperature do you have your water at? Are you doing water changes to bring the parameters down? I don't know where the remains of the fish would have gone but they are a pretty small fish so will decompose fairly fast especially if the others are feeding on them, just a thought but is your tank covered? White clouds are known to jump out of open topped tanks.

  3. 75g Discus TankFishlore VIPMember

    They either jumped, died and got eaten, or died and are in a spot where you can't see them. I would suggest that you return your fish and to not buy any fish until the tank is fully cycled.

  4. RobjocoValued MemberMember

    Thanks for the input.

    Yes, there’s a lid.

    The temp is regulated at 22 C.

    My city water is 8.2 pH and hardness 150 ppm. I chose white clouds because this fits perfectly to the parameters listed on seriouslyfish. They are all active and appear healthy, and have grown since I brought them home.

    Yes, I’m doing 25% changes weekly.

    As I return to the hobby, I’m finding so much conflicting info and advice. A challenge, indeed. I was told online not to worry about the hardness and pH since it will be the same as the lfs, and just needs to be kept steady.
  5. SeasoldierWell Known MemberMember

    Looks like you're doing everything spot on, Ph for white clouds should be 6 to 8 but as you said as long as it's stable then they should be OK at 8.2, don't know why a couple of them have died, you may have just got a couple of weak ones in the group & they died naturally, how are your other ones doing?
  6. mattgirlFishlore VIPMember

    In my opinion you should be doing a lot more when it comes to water changes while doing a fish in cycle. 25% weekly might work once this tank is cycled but to keep the fish safe you really need to get those numbers down or rendered harmless.

    It is good that you are using prime as it is supposed to render the ammonia and nitrites less harmful when the total of the two are less than one as I see yours are.

    You should be adding a full dose of prime every day that the numbers are less than 1 and if the 2 combined are over 1 do a water change to get them back under 1 and then add a full dose of prime.

    As long as you are registering ammonia and/or nitrates Prime needs to be added every day.

    Amazingly fish bodies do seem to just disappear. I think it has probably happened to every one of us at some time or another.
  7. RobjocoValued MemberMember

    Thank you. All the others are doing well, growing and starting to color up nicely.
  8. RobjocoValued MemberMember

    Ok thanks. I’ll increase water changes and keep doing Prime. And thanks for the reassurance!

  9. Thunder_o_bFishlore VIPMember

    Contrary to popular belief the Grays abduct more than people:stig:

    Small fish can be consumed by tank mates very quickly.

    I agree with what the others have posted.

    Best wishes.
  10. mattgirlFishlore VIPMember

    You're very welcome. Let your tests be your guide as to how much and when you need to do a water change.

    I see you are registering nitrates so it appears your cycle is progressing as it should unless you have nitrates in your source water. Have you run your tests on that water?

    Starting with 10 little fish (now 8) you shouldn't have to do as many water changes as I did for my 55 but I had a LOT more fish in mine while it was cycling. Just run your tests daily and go from there.
  11. connor31556New MemberMember

    This happened multiple times to me I lost at least 4 corydoras with out a trace practically turned the tank inside out looking for them but never managed to find them and I have a lid on mine
  12. RobjocoValued MemberMember

    Well at least I’m not alone in this!

    Yes, my tap today:
    Ammonia: .5
    Nitrite: .25
    Nitrate: 5
    Last edited by a moderator: Apr 22, 2018
  13. mattgirlFishlore VIPMember

    That explains where the nitrates are coming from. Maybe unusual seeing all 3 in tap water but not out of the realm of possibility. Once your tank is fully cycled those low numbers on the ammonia and nitrites shouldn't cause a problem as long as you continue using Prime .

    Once you see those nitrates start rising you will know you are close to cycled.
  14. Jenoli42Well Known MemberMember

    right so your tap has both toxins but all is not lost! that's a good source of food for both colonies of bacteria... you just need prime with every water change as you know.

    your cycle is progressing if your tank has lower ammonia than your tap & your nitrites are on the rise. nitrobacter grow more slowly so the nitrites can be stubborn but then suddenly in like 48 hours they disappear & your nitrates spike & you're cycled :)
  15. RobjocoValued MemberMember

    Yay thanks! I’m so excited!

    Oh jenoli42 and mattgirl, you’ve given me hope! Thank you!!!
    Last edited by a moderator: Apr 22, 2018

  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice