Freshwater refugium tank?

Status
Not open for further replies.

ZanderFTW

Active Member
Member
Messages
199
Reactions
0
Location
Near toronto
Aquarium Details  
Gender
Male
Nickname
Zander
Gallery
Yes
Occupation
student
Quarantine?
no
List any water conditioners and test kits used:
Api Master test kit
Experience
2 years
Do you know of and understand the Aquarium Nitrogen Cycle?
Yes
Aquarium Size
75g
Aquarium Type
Freshwater Fish Only
Fish, Plants, Inverts, etc.
FISH:
Nitrite
0ppm
Temperature
78
pH
7.9
Skimmer
No
Aquarium Filter Type
Ehiem 2215
I was just wondering if people ever had a refuguI'm tank for their freshwater tank to filter their water. I was just interested in this because you get to do less water changes and stuff.

this is what got me interested skip to 6.50 if your lazy
 
Last edited:

toosie

Fishlore VIP
Member
Messages
4,400
Reactions
601
Aquarium Details  
Gallery
Yes
Quarantine?
yes
List any water conditioners and test kits used:
api, prime
Experience
More than 10 years
Do you know of and understand the Aquarium Nitrogen Cycle?
Yes
Aquarium Size
85
Aquarium Type
Freshwater Planted Tank
Fish, Plants, Inverts, etc.
5 Discus, 5 Wild Blue Rams, 11 cardinals, 2 kuhli, 8 cory catfish, 9 otos, 1 farlowella cat, Plants include; Amazon Swords, Aponogetons, Micro Sword, Dwarf Baby Tears, Windelov, Bacopa Caroliniana
Aquarium Start Date
??
Ammonia
0
Nitrite
0
Nitrate
5-10
Temperature
83
pH
6.6
Lighting
T5 HO (78w)
I think the refugium is a very good way to filter a tank. There are several benefits to running a refugium, one being it adds extra water volume for the fish without having to have a larger tank. You can accomplish a visually fuller looking tank this way.

My main beef is the idea that is often presented in that you don't have to do near as many water changes because the nitrates stay low. There are really so many more reasons for providing water changes than just to lower nitrates. Unless there is always a full variety of minerals being supplied to the tank, the fish and plants will suffer from deficiencies. Some of these deficiencies in fish aren't easy to diagnose and are often misdiagnosed as some other type of disease. Fresh water provided by water changes helps to maintain that constant supply of minerals and it really takes the need out of trying to figure out what types of minerals you should be trying to add to the tank. Water changes are a cheaper way to provide these minerals than having to buy other sources. Fresh water takes much of the guess work out of these things and can only benefit your fish.

I think the worst reason to have a great filtration system of any kind is to avoid water changes. It's best to do both. Have a great filtration system, one you can understand and maintain properly AND regular large water changes. That way your fish get to enjoy the best of both worlds.
 

toosie

Fishlore VIP
Member
Messages
4,400
Reactions
601
Aquarium Details  
Gallery
Yes
Quarantine?
yes
List any water conditioners and test kits used:
api, prime
Experience
More than 10 years
Do you know of and understand the Aquarium Nitrogen Cycle?
Yes
Aquarium Size
85
Aquarium Type
Freshwater Planted Tank
Fish, Plants, Inverts, etc.
5 Discus, 5 Wild Blue Rams, 11 cardinals, 2 kuhli, 8 cory catfish, 9 otos, 1 farlowella cat, Plants include; Amazon Swords, Aponogetons, Micro Sword, Dwarf Baby Tears, Windelov, Bacopa Caroliniana
Aquarium Start Date
??
Ammonia
0
Nitrite
0
Nitrate
5-10
Temperature
83
pH
6.6
Lighting
T5 HO (78w)
A refugium is a separate little eco system that feeds to and from the main tank. It uses mechanical as well as biological filtration. The water is usually cycled threw the refugium quite slowly in order to allow more contact time with the biomedia. It's designed to grow plants and algaes in it as a part of the whole filtration system so it uses a light to promote life and growth.

A sump is more designed to keep the water level the same in the main tank at all times and provides more water volume for the fish. It provides an area to use heaters, thermometers, skimmers, and other equipment without cluttering up the appearance of the main tank. It isn't designed to promote life so no lighting is required.

I'm sure there is more than just this for differences so maybe somebody else will have more to add.
 

soltarianknight

Fishlore VIP
Member
Messages
5,282
Reactions
63
I see, I always though sumps were used to support extra space for bacterial growth so you could support higher bioloads . I was wrong lol. Thank you for the detailed responce
 

toosie

Fishlore VIP
Member
Messages
4,400
Reactions
601
Aquarium Details  
Gallery
Yes
Quarantine?
yes
List any water conditioners and test kits used:
api, prime
Experience
More than 10 years
Do you know of and understand the Aquarium Nitrogen Cycle?
Yes
Aquarium Size
85
Aquarium Type
Freshwater Planted Tank
Fish, Plants, Inverts, etc.
5 Discus, 5 Wild Blue Rams, 11 cardinals, 2 kuhli, 8 cory catfish, 9 otos, 1 farlowella cat, Plants include; Amazon Swords, Aponogetons, Micro Sword, Dwarf Baby Tears, Windelov, Bacopa Caroliniana
Aquarium Start Date
??
Ammonia
0
Nitrite
0
Nitrate
5-10
Temperature
83
pH
6.6
Lighting
T5 HO (78w)
No, I don't think you were wrong. I believe sumps do use bio balls or other bio media, but beneficial bacteria doesn't require light in order to live. The fact that there is bio media in a sump, as well as extra water, means it does help with higher bioloads. It doesn't necessarily help with nitrate levels though, and because of the benefits of plants in a refugium, nitrate levels are able to be naturally kept lower.
 

soltarianknight

Fishlore VIP
Member
Messages
5,282
Reactions
63
I see....you know this means I have to make one now right? I could see how this could be useful with high stock tanks like cichlids, or larger tanks that are harder to do large WC on.
 

ryanr

Moderator
Moderator
Member
Messages
11,467
Reactions
1,433
Location
Melbourne, Vic
Hi, I've moved this topic to the Advanced Freshwater Topics, as it is a not-so common Freshwater approach.

As for sump vs refugium - many sumps incorporate the refugium as a section, so the two terms are often mistankingly used synonomously. Toosie's description is pretty much spot on
 

toosie

Fishlore VIP
Member
Messages
4,400
Reactions
601
Aquarium Details  
Gallery
Yes
Quarantine?
yes
List any water conditioners and test kits used:
api, prime
Experience
More than 10 years
Do you know of and understand the Aquarium Nitrogen Cycle?
Yes
Aquarium Size
85
Aquarium Type
Freshwater Planted Tank
Fish, Plants, Inverts, etc.
5 Discus, 5 Wild Blue Rams, 11 cardinals, 2 kuhli, 8 cory catfish, 9 otos, 1 farlowella cat, Plants include; Amazon Swords, Aponogetons, Micro Sword, Dwarf Baby Tears, Windelov, Bacopa Caroliniana
Aquarium Start Date
??
Ammonia
0
Nitrite
0
Nitrate
5-10
Temperature
83
pH
6.6
Lighting
T5 HO (78w)
Do lots of research because there is more to it all than what I have explained. I only touched base on the type of refugium the OP is asking about which acts as the filtration system for the main tank, and it sounds like the type you may want to try. There are other types of refugiums out there that aren't intended to be a part of the filtration system.

I think most sumps utilize a wet and dry type of system for filtration, but again, there are probably different ways to set one up.

I'm not an expert on either of these systems so I know there is a lot I don't know about them, but I've tried to tell you as much as I could. Research them as much as possible so that you can design one based on your needs, and please don't use them as a substitute for water changes or gravel vacs because those things are still very important.
 

soltarianknight

Fishlore VIP
Member
Messages
5,282
Reactions
63
No worries, I understand the concept, just wasn't sure the difference. There is no substitute for WC or regular maintenance.
 
OP
Z

ZanderFTW

Active Member
Member
Messages
199
Reactions
0
Location
Near toronto
Aquarium Details  
Gender
Male
Nickname
Zander
Gallery
Yes
Occupation
student
Quarantine?
no
List any water conditioners and test kits used:
Api Master test kit
Experience
2 years
Do you know of and understand the Aquarium Nitrogen Cycle?
Yes
Aquarium Size
75g
Aquarium Type
Freshwater Fish Only
Fish, Plants, Inverts, etc.
FISH:
Nitrite
0ppm
Temperature
78
pH
7.9
Skimmer
No
Aquarium Filter Type
Ehiem 2215
I didn't realize you could actually buy these things you would have to do the plumbing and get the plants for the refugium though.
 

Aquarist

Fishlore Legend
Member
Messages
39,041
Reactions
377
Location
On the beach
Aquarium Details  
Gender
Male
Nickname
Ken
Gallery
Yes
Quarantine?
YES!
List any water conditioners and test kits used:
Prime
API Master Test Kit
Experience
More than 10 years
Do you know of and understand the Aquarium Nitrogen Cycle?
Yes
Aquarium Type
Freshwater Fish Only
Nitrite
0
Skimmer
No
Tank #2 Type
Freshwater Fish Only
Tank #2 Ammonia
0
Tank #2 Nitrite
0
Tank #3 Type
Freshwater Fish Only

pirahnah3

Fishlore VIP
Member
Messages
4,334
Reactions
40
Location
central MA
Aquarium Details  
Gender
Male
Nickname
Jim
Gallery
Yes
Occupation
Environmental Specialist
Quarantine?
No
List any water conditioners and test kits used:
API liquid test kits
Experience
Just started
Do you know of and understand the Aquarium Nitrogen Cycle?
Yes
Aquarium Size
75
Aquarium Type
Freshwater Planted Tank
Fish, Plants, Inverts, etc.
15 Serpe Tetras for now, 5 Australian Rainbow fish, 3 OTO's. Too many plants to list
Aquarium Start Date
August 2011
Ammonia
0
Nitrite
0
Nitrate
10-15
Temperature
76
pH
7.2
Lighting
48inch 2 bulb T5HO 108W
Aquarium Filter Type
HOB, Powerhead, Canister
Aquarium #2 Size
20 High
Tank #2 Type
Freshwater Fish Only
Tank #2 Fish, Plants, Inverts, etc.
5 Long Fin Zebra Danios, 10 Black skirt tetras, 5 green corys, 2 dwarf corys. Wisteria is planted and floating in the tank.
Tank #2 Start Date
July 2011
Tank #2 Ammonia
0
Tank #2 Nitrite
0
Tank #2 Nitrate
10-20
Tank #2 Temperature
76
Tank #2 pH
7.4
Tank #2 Lighting
8,000K 15W T8
Tank #2 Filter Type
HOB, UGF with power head
It can and will work, I can verify this not form a fish point of view but from chemistry and work. The plants will do a wonderful job just be sure to select plants appropriately as you really don't want to have to add to the tanks to keep them working well. Most times you will see simple plants in a setup like that.

I have been looking at going a bit more complex but as a separate tank and that's just a whole different ball park even.
 

Aquarist

Fishlore Legend
Member
Messages
39,041
Reactions
377
Location
On the beach
Aquarium Details  
Gender
Male
Nickname
Ken
Gallery
Yes
Quarantine?
YES!
List any water conditioners and test kits used:
Prime
API Master Test Kit
Experience
More than 10 years
Do you know of and understand the Aquarium Nitrogen Cycle?
Yes
Aquarium Type
Freshwater Fish Only
Nitrite
0
Skimmer
No
Tank #2 Type
Freshwater Fish Only
Tank #2 Ammonia
0
Tank #2 Nitrite
0
Tank #3 Type
Freshwater Fish Only
Good morning,

Starfuel1, I am moving your post and related posts to create a thread of its own. I will post a link to your new thread here in just a moment.

Thanks!

Ken

Here is the link to your new thread:
 
OP
Z

ZanderFTW

Active Member
Member
Messages
199
Reactions
0
Location
Near toronto
Aquarium Details  
Gender
Male
Nickname
Zander
Gallery
Yes
Occupation
student
Quarantine?
no
List any water conditioners and test kits used:
Api Master test kit
Experience
2 years
Do you know of and understand the Aquarium Nitrogen Cycle?
Yes
Aquarium Size
75g
Aquarium Type
Freshwater Fish Only
Fish, Plants, Inverts, etc.
FISH:
Nitrite
0ppm
Temperature
78
pH
7.9
Skimmer
No
Aquarium Filter Type
Ehiem 2215

extreoxy

New Member
Member
Messages
20
Reactions
0
Location
Australia, Melbourne
Aquarium Details  
Gender
Male
Gallery
Yes
Quarantine?
no, guess i should but where do i put it:/
List any water conditioners and test kits used:
dechlorinator, excel atm, florish, aquariums salts? to adjust kh/gh
Experience
2 years
Do you know of and understand the Aquarium Nitrogen Cycle?
Yes
Aquarium Size
540l
Aquarium Type
Freshwater Planted Tank
Fish, Plants, Inverts, etc.
clown loachs, BN, otto,DG,rummy nose, cardinals,platties, 1 red cherry shrimp probably >_>( hard to see it),rosy tetra i think, blue rams and leopard orange finned croy(at least thats what i think it is)
Aquarium Start Date
can't remember
Ammonia
0
Nitrite
0
Nitrate
usually 25-50 :/
Temperature
27
Lighting
3, 6 foot aquarium lights
Aquarium Filter Type
2 external canister filters(one 700L one-> 2078)
wouldn't a Freshwater refugium just be a aglae scrubber?
 

Featherfin

Active Member
Member
Messages
321
Reactions
1
Aquarium Details  
Gallery
Yes
I think it's a great way to filter an unplanted (or even planted of course) tank!

If you have an algae problem in the tank due to excess nutrients, and your new refugium can then out-compete the algae for nutrients, then I believe the refugium would act as an algae scrubber. However, the refugium will also work to keep water quality cleaner as well which is the main bonus.

I have a silver dollar/severum tank that I've been meaning to do this to. I have a big wet/dry filter with plenty of room for plants. I just need to get around to buying a light for it and then I'll have my refugium going. It's a 180g and my only permanently non-planted tank... it seriously needs some plants for the nitrates so I'm hoping the refugium will make an impact.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest threads

Top Bottom