Fish Died During Vacation

Discussion in 'Freshwater Beginners' started by Animalfriend26, Apr 17, 2018.

  1. Animalfriend26

    Animalfriend26 New Member Member

    Hello guys! My 13 gallon tank had 4 guppies inside, 2 platies and I had more recently added 5 neon tetras. Two weeks ago I had to leave for one week, so I changed the water and fed them the day before. One week later I returned to find 2 of my guppies and 1 of my platies dead. The other fish looked fine and the ammonia was zero.The next day after that I had to leave again for another week. When I returned the other platy was dead as well. I changed the water yesterday and checked the paremeters today and everything looks fine! I don’t understand what went wrong. Could it have happened out of hunger? I was told that fish can do fine without food for a week. Do you have any suggestions as to what I can do to prevent this in the future? And what seems even stranger to me is that the guppies and platies who are generally considered hardier than tetras died and the tetras look just fine!
     
  2. trainandfishguy

    trainandfishguy Valued Member Member

    How ling have you had your tank? How long ago did you add the neons? Could be a mini cycle took place when you added the new fish..
     
  3. OP
    OP
    Animalfriend26

    Animalfriend26 New Member Member

    I’ve had the tank since January and added the tetras around 3 weeks ago.
     




  4. x

    xloe Valued Member Member

    This happened to me like a month ago. We left for just three days and I came back to a dead platy....I could not find any reason at all for her death and it seemed very weird that she would just happen to die during those three days.
    Maybe they miss us too much when we are gone.
     
  5. trainandfishguy

    trainandfishguy Valued Member Member

    It wasn't out of hunger. I think it was just a case of bad luck. We all hate when fish die but its part of the hobby.
     
  6. Ryan P

    Ryan P Valued Member Member

    also are you doing the test before or after the water change? I seem to have missed that part.
     
  7. OP
    OP
    Animalfriend26

    Animalfriend26 New Member Member

    I have done tests both before and after water changes and all seemed fine!
     
  8. FishFish221

    FishFish221 Well Known Member Member

    What are you using to test the water? If they are strips, then they can get contaminated by the air and not give an accurate reading.
     
  9. OP
    OP
    Animalfriend26

    Animalfriend26 New Member Member

    Nope! I use liquid tests. :/
     
  10. Sam2671

    Sam2671 Valued Member Member

    It does sound like it was just bad luck, especially taking into account the tetras were fine and the guppies and platy wasn’t
     
  11. Abby565

    Abby565 Valued Member Member

    Thats really weird! If the parameters were fine and they were fed before you left, I don't see why they would have died. Maybe just bad stock that didn't die till now.
     
  12. OP
    OP
    Animalfriend26

    Animalfriend26 New Member Member

    Yeah and the weird thing is the other two guppies are just fine! If it was some illness wouldn’t it have affected them as well? The last thing I can think of is maybe aggressiveness? There was always some nipping and some chasing around but never to the point of fin ripping! I can’t believe that in just one week they got that aggressive!
     
  13. Mcasella

    Mcasella Fishlore VIP Member

    It can be those specific fish got the dose of bad genes needed to make them weaker, while your current guppies have better genes and aren't as weak.
     
  14. M

    Madeline Peterson New Member Member

    When you say you changed the water, do you mean a full water change? A full water change removes all the beneficial bacteria, which basically restarts your tank at stage 1 of cycling.
    Also, you mention ammonia, but did you check your nitrites? Those are dangerous, too.
     
  15. Alaina Leigh

    Alaina Leigh Valued Member Member

    I dont think the BB is in the water column. A full water change, for example, would not effect the BB. It's in the filter media, substrate and decor/plants.
     
  16. OP
    OP
    Animalfriend26

    Animalfriend26 New Member Member

    No, after the cycle was established I have never done a full water change. I only do around 30% water changes once a week, as instructed by AqAdvisor. Also, yes I have checked both nitrites and nitrates and their levels are completely normal.
     
  17. FriarThomasIII

    FriarThomasIII Well Known Member Member

    Make sure your information is correct next time before you comment, that way someone doesn't do the wrong thing. Almost all the bacteria is in the substrate, the filter media and any plants. Hardly any is in the water column.
     
  18. OP
    OP
    Animalfriend26

    Animalfriend26 New Member Member

    Since you mentioned it, a quick question out of the subject, I’m going to be moving next month. Will draining the aquarium and just keeping enough water for the substrate, decorations and filter disrupt the cycle?
     
  19. dwarfpufferlover

    dwarfpufferlover Well Known Member Member

    You mention fin nipping which is important.

    You leave for a week, and the aggressors get more aggressive because they are hungry then bully the others to death.
    Do you have any pics of the dead ones?
     
  20. OP
    OP
    Animalfriend26

    Animalfriend26 New Member Member

    No, unfortunately I don’t have any pictures but almost all of their bodies were half when I found them. They seemed rotten or eaten away maybe? But the thing is the fish that died were the most “aggressive” ones in the aquarium.
     




  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice