Do You Guys Think This Will Support A 60 Gal Tank?

Paulsz

Member
Hello,

I have this shelf unit and just wondering if you guys think it would support a 60 gallon tank. The unit is 66 inches x 18 inches and about 30 inches tall. A 60 gallon would fit on top, I'm just worried it won't support the weight. I took out the drawers for you guys to see the inside. What do you think?


1f407d6372a56d1a59dd4fd5a4ee0c60.jpg



4b5772f82751e19dcc1422e517d8574c.jpg


I could also provide more numbers (measurements) or pictures if needed
 

MikeRad89

Member
No way I'd try to do that. Need more support in the corners.
 

AllieSten

Member
Nope. It would have to be able to support 600+ lbs. that does not look like it could support half of that.
 

Zahc

Member
That's a bit sketchy imo, I wouldn't risk it.
 

jmaldo

Member
You're looking at around 700 lbs., I would not trust it. Don't forget the weight of the dresser, make sure the floor can support the entire setup.
 

Diesmali

Member
Maybe with the drawers in...but even then it would be risky.
 

James17

Member
Sorry, no way it supports that tank without adding a good amount of support.
 
  • Thread Starter

Paulsz

Member
Thank you for the input! That was quick and yeah I have my 20 gal on there now so Ill leave that there and won't put my 60 gal instead
 

OnTheFly

Member
I'm a woodworker so I'll give you my best shot.

We'll start with the good news. The strength of the vertical lumber would surprise people, provided the joints are solid. You can use a single 2x4 to support one end of a car if you placed it perfectly. It's paneled on three sides which adds tremendous strength and prevents it from racking. (Flexing horizontally at the joints). Unless that paneling is glorified cardboard instead of particle board.

Here's the bad news. It doesn't match the footprint of your tank so the weight is not bearing directly over the strongest part of the stand. That's a problem if the top is not thick and strong. Most LFS stands are made of particle boards and poorly constructed, but they match the outside dimension of the tank for a reason.

I think it would probably work, but I don't have to clean up the mess if I'm wrong. If I was going to try it I would fill the aquarium about halfway up and see if the stand wobbles at all. Then make a decision. If it moves horizontally at all I wouldn't do it.
 

2211Nighthawk

Member
Nope. I tend to take risks with my stands but I woulden't trust that.
 
  • Thread Starter

Paulsz

Member
OnTheFly thanks for the info but I guess I won't risk it and instead just have my 20 gallon on there
 

2211Nighthawk

Member
If you need a stand, I had ripped the top off a China cabinet that had lots of supports right down the middle, top to bottom front to back. That had a 45 on it and it never had issues.
 
  • Thread Starter

Paulsz

Member
I might just build a stand over the summer. Not sure what to do with the 60 gallon at the moment and I'm a little busy with work so I probably won't get to the tank until summer anyway
 

JRS

Member
OnTheFly said:
I'm a woodworker so I'll give you my best shot.

We'll start with the good news. The strength of the vertical lumber would surprise people, provided the joints are solid. You can use a single 2x4 to support one end of a car if you placed it perfectly. It's paneled on three sides which adds tremendous strength and prevents it from racking. (Flexing horizontally at the joints). Unless that paneling is glorified cardboard instead of particle board.

Here's the bad news. It doesn't match the footprint of your tank so the weight is not bearing directly over the strongest part of the stand. That's a problem if the top is not thick and strong. Most LFS stands are made of particle boards and poorly constructed, but they match the outside dimension of the tank for a reason.

I think it would probably work, but I don't have to clean up the mess if I'm wrong. If I was going to try it I would fill the aquarium about halfway up and see if the stand wobbles at all. Then make a decision. If it moves horizontally at all I wouldn't do it.
Paulsz I hope you don't mind if I ask this for my use, maybe it might be an idea for you. OnTheFly As a woodworker, do you think a 55 could go on top of kitchen cabinets, all plywood construction with a 1 3/4 thick black limba wood counter top?
 
  • Thread Starter

Paulsz

Member
No problem JRS. I already got my answer so I'm good
 

OnTheFly

Member
Paulsz said:
OnTheFly thanks for the info but I guess I won't risk it and instead just have my 20 gallon on there
It will hold a 20 without question.
 

OnTheFly

Member
JRS said:
Paulsz I hope you don't mind if I ask this for my use, maybe it might be an idea for you. OnTheFly As a woodworker, do you think a 55 could go on top of kitchen cabinets, all plywood construction with a 1 3/4 thick black limba wood counter top?
Yes, easily. You could support 1000+ pounds on a 4ft section of most kitchen cabinets. The thick top is extremely strong. It's all about the racking and sheeting eliminates that. Take a good look at a Petco stand. They look flakey because they are made of junk. The sheeting on all sides is why they don't fail.
 

JRS

Member
OnTheFly said:
Yes, easily. You could 1000+ pounds on a 4ft section of most kitchen cabinets. The thick top is extremely strong. It's all about the racking and sheeting eliminates that. Take a good look at a Petco stand. They look flakey becaue they are made of junk. The sheeting on all sides is why they don't fail.
I have a construction background myself but in design, so my instinct says yes. But it is nice to have another opinion. I agree about the petco particle board stands. I personally would be a bit leery putting a 400+ lb tank on them, but I am sure they work otherwise there would be issues.
Thanks for the confirmation.
 

OnTheFly

Member
JRS said:
I have a construction background myself but in design, so my instinct says yes. But it is nice to have another opinion. I agree about the petco particle board stands. I personally would be a bit leery putting a 400+ lb tank on them, but I am sure they work otherwise there would be issues.
Thanks for the confirmation.
Your welcome. I am new in the fish hobby after a long break. I want to build some fancy oak stands for a huge tank this winter but I know I would spend a month building it. I own one of those cheezy stands for a 60G. They are strong enough with a wide margin, but only 14" deep so you better put it on a level floor. I bet somebody didn't and tipped one over. Now that would be a really bad day with cichlids flopping around on the living room carpet.
 

Herkimur

Member
I looked at the picture and cringed without even reading the text.
NO Way !
This is what you need or buy one already made (which is more expensive than buying a saw, the lumber and some screws).

4f42c2e77ff9c0b414d5f8c2b732be22.jpg
 

OnTheFly

Member
Herkimur said:
I looked at the picture and cringed without even reading the text.
NO Way !
This is what you need or buy one already made (which is more expensive than buying a saw, the lumber and some screws).

4f42c2e77ff9c0b414d5f8c2b732be22.jpg
That will hold 1500 LBS. It should hold an aquarium lol. You did a nice job. Joints look tight.
 
Top Bottom