Car wash sponge Question

Discussion in 'Freshwater Beginners' started by upgrade, Apr 10, 2010.

  1. upgrade

    upgradeValued MemberMember

    Alright my friend saw a video about breading angels and told me when mine bread you should use a huge car wash sponge as a sponge filter.

    I'm thinking this is a very bad idea.

    But he thinks it will help keep the water cleaner.

    His idea:

    2Ft long PVC pipe, drill holes but a bunch of car wash sponges on it. bingo, jumbo sponge filter.

    I think that would kill fish?

    Leave your thoughts
    434.jpg Thanks!
  2. Jrobber

    JrobberWell Known MemberMember

    Has he tried it before?
  3. OP

    upgradeValued MemberMember

    Nope, he just saw a video on youtube and thought i should use it
  4. Jrobber

    JrobberWell Known MemberMember

    Hmm...sounds fishy.

    Just joking, I've never heard of anything like that, but I'll let someone who has breed Angels take this one.
  5. OP

    upgradeValued MemberMember

    Ya, because I'm sure you just cant use any old sponge.
  6. Meenu

    MeenuFishlore VIPMember

    well, it seems like a sponge filter is a good idea. I don't know what the difference is between different sponges (well, except the ones with detergent/soap already in them - big no-no)...

    in the DIY section of the forum, there is info about how to make a sponge filter.
  7. OP

    upgradeValued MemberMember

    Cool, thanks. I cant seem to find any about what type of sponge to use
    Last edited: Apr 11, 2010
  8. MindTravel3r

    MindTravel3rValued MemberMember

    Theoretically it should work well as long as there is nothing in the sponge that changes the water chemistry or adds poisons.

    I am using a Hydro Sponge III on my 27 gal tank, and it works great as a biological filter. My ammonia and nitrites have been at zero since my tank has been cycled. However, I don't think that a DIY approach is cost effective as the basic sponge, hard plastic structure which holds the sponge, and plastic tubing cost about 10 USD total. It would probably cost 6 or 7 dollars for the parts, and then you have a small project on your hands.
  9. Butterfly

    ButterflyModeratorModerator Member

    Already made sponge filters are very inexpensive so I personally wouldn't take a chance on the car wash sponge. Many sponges that are manufactured to be used over and over(like car wash sponges, sponges for cleaning at home etc.) have something in them to discourage mold and mildew. This would not be good for your fish.
    This is what I use in the larger tanks need an air pump to run it.
    This is what I use in a smaller tank
    Need an air pump to run it also.
  10. TedsTank

    TedsTankWell Known MemberMember

    Also check out KENS. He has a great selection of sponge filters, not to mention fish food, shipping supplies, and heaters.
  11. Butterfly

    ButterflyModeratorModerator Member

    OOOOOH I forgot about Kens :)
  12. OP

    upgradeValued MemberMember

    When you say "kens" do you mean "" or some other kens?

    Thanks in advance