Better algae cleaner Help

  1. Trojan Member Member

    I have a 12 gallon tank. Should I get an Otto or Mystery Snail to be my tank cleaner?
     
  2. flyin-lowe Well Known Member Member

    Ive never had an otto but I hear that they will eat a lot of algae.
     

  3. Shawnie Fishlore Legend Member

    ottos do fabulous..be require a tank thats been running a few months....with the fish you have, and their ability to scavenge constantly, you shouldnt have that much to clean..whats the cleaning you need done?
     
  4. acolli51 Member Member

    I had a lot of algae in my 20gal before I bought 3 ottos and then they kept it clean(er). One died on me for some odd reason a couple months ago but I plan to put 2-3 more back in for total of 4-5 and I think they will keep it pretty spotless. I have heard that they like to been in small schools of at least 4-5 so that is one reason to get a few but also I think that amount will keep most tanks under 30gal pretty clean from algae. My guess would be 4 would keep a 12gal pristine.
     

  5. Trojan Member Member

    I have one GBR, 1 platy & 1 red fin tetra, 1 frog. Have been using a magnet cleaner. Thought I would add something to the tank to help keep clean. Not sure how many Otto's I can add.
     
  6. Shawnie Fishlore Legend Member

    ahhh i was going by your aquarium info ...updating it might help some :)

    good luck!
     
  7. Trojan Member Member

    Sorry, just updated my info
     

  8. Trojan Member Member

    Can I keep an Otto by itself or do I have to have multiple Otto's?
     
  9. Diggly Well Known Member Member

    they are happier in groups so I would recommend 3 at least.
     
  10. Shawnie Fishlore Legend Member

    dont be sorry :) I was going on what you had listed thats all...but I think you are at maximum stock with the fish you have in a 12g tank.....not that ottos are huge fish or big waste producers, the ones you do have need the space ...but thats just my advice..im sure others will have some also :)
     

  11. rt12 Member Member

    Both would be fine but snails require better water quality. For algae eaters though its a toss up as to whether or not they actually eat the algae. Snails do a decent job most of the time though