Bettas and guppies

  • Thread starter

Christopher

New Member
Messages
37
Reaction score
0
Points
156
I have always wanted a betta but will they fight with common guppies because Iwas tolled that they will fight with other large finned fish. Also, if i get one, how do i give the betta his/her food without having the other fish get it first can the bettas be trained to be hand fed ???
 

MaryPa

New Member
Messages
45
Reaction score
0
Points
156
I would say don`t put the Betta in with Guppies. The reason for me saying tis is because I had a Betta Jump a tank divider and eat my guppy fry. She was bloated and stayed ill for a couple days.
 

Butterfly

Fishlore Legend
Messages
22,864
Reaction score
120
Points
518
Experience
More than 10 years
1)The guppies eat much faster than your betta also and he might not get enough to eat.
2)Guppies are such busy little beasties the betta will be greatly annoyed and start to nip fins I'm afraid.
3) Your betta needs to be able to get to the surface to breathe without being harrassed.
They just are not a good mix. Sorry
Carol
 

0morrokh

Fishlore VIP
Messages
4,472
Reaction score
12
Points
208
Experience
5 to 10 years
Also I've heard of Bettas mistaking Guppies (with their big, colorful fins) for another Betta and attacking them as such. So they are difinately not compatible.
 

chickadee

Fishlore VIP
Messages
6,627
Reaction score
22
Points
358
Experience
5 to 10 years
It just isn't a good idea for either fish. I agree with the others.

Rose
 

ricky2272

New Member
Messages
14
Reaction score
0
Points
151
Hello, In my fish tank i have a male betta and also two male guppys and they get on just fine.there is never any ripped fines or anything. they are all healthy. ;D i think that you are ok to get a betta.
 

Boxermom

Valued Member
Messages
446
Reaction score
0
Points
176
Of course this is just my opinion, but I think its rather irresponsible to recommend putting fish together that are notorious for not getting along. Yes, there may be exceptions to every rule but for the most part, one should consciously avoid purposely putting them in danger.
 

chickadee

Fishlore VIP
Messages
6,627
Reaction score
22
Points
358
Experience
5 to 10 years
Please always be aware that the temperment of all bettas do differ. It is really unwise to recommend that someone do something reckless with their pets when it is their tanks that we are trying to help with. Please do not recommend something to someone else based on what has happened in only one instance. It is such a heartbreak to lose fish, and it is not our place to suggest someone do something that would ordinarily not be a good idea. We have some very young members who not only do not have the money to use to experiment with but who are not experienced fish parents and they take things to heart. (I am speaking young in both years and experience) I do not want to see them discouraged because they got the wrong information here and had a fish loss.

No a betta cannot go into the tank with the guppies. One species or the other will attack the other. Guppies have been known to be fin nippers and will cause the betta trouble even if you have a really good betta who decides to leave everyone live in peace around him. Most bettas however, will attack the guppies as if they were fellow bettas (or any other fish with long fins).

Rose

 

SunnShadow

Valued Member
Messages
230
Reaction score
0
Points
176
Boxermom said:
Of course this is just my opinion, but I think its rather irresponsible to recommend putting fish together that are notorious for not getting along. Yes, there may be exceptions to every rule but for the most part, one should consciously avoid purposely putting them in danger.
chickadee said:
Please always be aware that the temperment of all bettas do differ. It is really unwise to recommend that someone do something reckless with their pets when it is their tanks that we are trying to help with. Please do not recommend something to someone else based on what has happened in only one instance. It is such a heartbreak to lose fish, and it is not our place to suggest someone do something that would ordinarily not be a good idea. We have some very young members who not only do not have the money to use to experiment with but who are not experienced fish parents and they take things to heart. (I am speaking young in both years and experience) I do not want to see them discouraged because they got the wrong information here and had a fish loss.

No a betta cannot go into the tank with the guppies. One species or the other will attack the other. Guppies have been known to be fin nippers and will cause the betta trouble even if you have a really good betta who decides to leave everyone live in peace around him. Most bettas however, will attack the guppies as if they were fellow bettas (or any other fish with long fins).

Rose
I am not by any means recommend that anyone else do this, but I too have a Betta in with Guppies (and Platys, and Swordtails), and they get along fine.

S.
 

chickadee

Fishlore VIP
Messages
6,627
Reaction score
22
Points
358
Experience
5 to 10 years
My point is that if someone makes an informed decision on their own to put two fairly incompatible fish in the same tank and it works out - Great! but I am trying to keep anyone from making recommendations for others and perhaps getting someone else into a bad situation. It is not meant to be personal to anyone. We have just had so many little ones with difficulty lately, that it is hard to see people slide down a slippery slope toward a problem if it can be prevented. BUT it is always a person's own choice what they decide to place in their tank. Personal observations are ALWAYS welcome .

Rose
 

inari

Well Known Member
Messages
816
Reaction score
3
Points
178
Experience
4 years
MaryPa said:
I would say don`t put the Betta in with Guppies. The reason for me saying tis is because I had a Betta Jump a tank divider and eat my guppy fry. She was bloated and stayed ill for a couple days.
i must comment here smart fish tho probly wasn't his/her brightest moment
 

inari

Well Known Member
Messages
816
Reaction score
3
Points
178
Experience
4 years
definately from what i have been reading i have seen that male bettas (which are the most beautiful in my opionion) aren't very friendly towards most fish (even females of their own species trust me on that one) anyway if u want a betta I would suggest that u keep him alone or with some snails something like that, bettas are wonderful compions but they get alone best with humans (kinda odd if u ask me) so keep him alone (or with a snail or two) and pay lots of attention to him and to answer ur hand feeding question yes they can be trained to do that mine eats out of my hand almost everday, unless its a pea day!!!
anyway the best of luck to you
Brent
 

ecnaj143

Well Known Member
Messages
529
Reaction score
1
Points
176
See, I don't agree with charts or everyone saying "I wouldn't do it, they don't get along." Its like a critic saying things about a movie, but 99% of the time, the critics are worng, the movie is a hit. (Fot example: Critics raved about the movie King Kong, that it was a great movie, blah, blah, blah. It was whack. I hated and so did everyone I know). So, I just give it a try on my own. Alot of time, they get along. So to be honest, no one really knows if they will get along or not, each fish has his own personality. Another example, my barbs get along with ALL my fish. I havn't seen them nip fins on any of my fish. Actually I see them school with my neons. SO really, again, I say give it a try, each fish is different. (Except if you KNOW that a fish will eat it, like; Angels and neons and stuff like that).
 

Boxermom

Valued Member
Messages
446
Reaction score
0
Points
176
That is very irresponsible advice, IMO. Its not at all like critics being wrong about a movie. Its more like 99% of experienced fishkeepers knowing what they are talking about and trying to prevent the torture of a living being by experimentation.
 

kerryve

Valued Member
Messages
332
Reaction score
0
Points
186
Speaking from experience, I learnt the hard way, I while ago I put a betta with 2 male guppies, they were fine with eachother at first, I dont know if they just got on eachothers nerves but a week later I saw that one of my guppies was missing some fins and my betta was dead. I know now that it was cos they faught. Its very stressful for fish that dont get along to be in the same tank together... But like we all know every betta has its own unique personality... Ive got two males that love eachother, but my situation us unique I would under no circumstances put two together in a tank. So no, I wouldnt put guppies with bettas
 

ecnaj143

Well Known Member
Messages
529
Reaction score
1
Points
176
Well, my experience is the opposite. So really, you can't say someone shouldn't do it, because you don't know if they will. Its about a 50 50 chance that they will and that they won't. Its worth a try. I mean, at liveaquria.com, they say that they do, obviously they did some research and they got along. So, I mean, everyone has their own opinion.
 

kerryve

Valued Member
Messages
332
Reaction score
0
Points
186
In that case, set up a separate tank to accomodate your betta if they dont get along. Its the only thing I can suggest, but I still advise against it.
 

ecnaj143

Well Known Member
Messages
529
Reaction score
1
Points
176
What I do is, I make sure that the pet store puts the betta is a bag(i hate the cups) and let the bag float in the tank, see if he flares at them. If he doesn't, they more than likely, they'll get a long.
 

inari

Well Known Member
Messages
816
Reaction score
3
Points
178
Experience
4 years
Not always, as most of us know by now male and female bettas don't get along very well....i put tenshi (female) in bag next to Inari and they both seemed to do ok, now once they were mixed that was a whole nother story so the separate tank of your betta is a must especially when ur mixing fish that there is a high chance that they are incompatible!!
 

chickadee

Fishlore VIP
Messages
6,627
Reaction score
22
Points
358
Experience
5 to 10 years
It is my experience that it is better to err in the side of caution. Fish cost money and most aquarium owner invest something of themselves into their fish. I do not want to advise someone to do something that may, or may not, work and "give it a try" is not an option I really want to have expressed here as we are advising someone else who may or may not have the experience to make an informed decision. We should not take the responsibility of advising someone to try something when it has been a problem for experienced fishkeepers. If they choose to do so after hearing the pros and cons it should be their choice.

Rose
 
Toggle Sidebar

Aquarium Calculator

Aquarium Photo Contests

Follow FishLore!





Top Bottom