Best Water Filter For Bettas

What would you do?

  • Keep putting filter foam in the intake

    Votes: 1 25.0%
  • Get a different filter

    Votes: 1 25.0%
  • Forget filtering and water change more

    Votes: 2 50.0%

  • Total voters
    4

Golabh

New Member
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Points
1
Experience
2 years
I bought a beautiful butterfly tail Betta. He is having a really hard time with the water filter. I have the 3 gallon mini bow tank with the water filter it came with. I do think that it moves the water quite a lot for a small tank. Some of my other Bettas have not loved it either. In the past, I have put a little bit of foam filter in the intake pipe to reduce the flow rate, but it didn't do a great job filtering the water like that. Since this tank was created to use the filter system it came with, I'm not even sure how well another type of filter will fit in there if I change it. I have the filter off for the moment. I want to give my Betta the best home I can, and I don't want the filter to stress him out! What flow rate would be good in this small of a tank? Should I forget the filter and just change water more frequently?
 

_S_

New Member
Messages
25
Reaction score
1
Points
3
Experience
4 years
I bought a beautiful butterfly tail Betta. He is having a really hard time with the water filter. I have the 3 gallon mini bow tank with the water filter it came with. I do think that it moves the water quite a lot for a small tank. Some of my other Bettas have not loved it either. In the past, I have put a little bit of foam filter in the intake pipe to reduce the flow rate, but it didn't do a great job filtering the water like that. Since this tank was created to use the filter system it came with, I'm not even sure how well another type of filter will fit in there if I change it. I have the filter off for the moment. I want to give my Betta the best home I can, and I don't want the filter to stress him out! What flow rate would be good in this small of a tank? Should I forget the filter and just change water more frequently?
Definitely keep a filter. That's where all of the beneficial bacteria is made to turn nitrite to nitrates. If you don't keep a filter the nitrogen cycle will crash. If the current is strong I would replace the filter because strong current cause betta's stress and also rip their beautiful fins. Betta's do best in stagnant water so I would say get a sponge filter. It should do fine in that small of a tank and filter well. I think the foam trick is good but only for a while so that's why I would replace it. The foam trick might also effect the removing of the chemical compounds within the water. I would also look into upgrading to at least a five gallon because the recommended is a five gallon and it would also give the betta more ground space. Best of luck
 

PokeTileCraft101

Valued Member
Messages
298
Reaction score
107
Points
78
Experience
2 years
If you want to you could not have a water filter and just do more water changes because when I owned bettas i didn't have a filter and just did water changed and they lived for about 3-4 years.
 

bgclarke

Well Known Member
Messages
1,902
Reaction score
1,161
Points
198
Experience
1 year
Based on the image I saw of the filter, could you put some sponge or floss in the output area to slow or dampen the flow a bit?
 
  • Thread starter
  • Thread Starter
  • #5

Golabh

New Member
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Points
1
Experience
2 years
This is not my tank, but the same type of filter. I put the foam in the circled area to slow down the water flow.
 

Attachments

peppy210

Valued Member
Messages
238
Reaction score
141
Points
53
Experience
3 years
You must have a filter. It will be so much better for your fish and maintenance. If you want low flow, the best and cheapest filter you'll find is a sponge filter and they work well to hold biological filtration. You'll just have to clean the substrate with a gravel vacuum which I assume you do anyway, because no filter is going to be able to get everything out of the gravel.
I also recommend the Tetra Whisper 3 or 3i. I had one in a 3 gallon and it works really well and it even has space for you to put in more filter media. I have the original filter cartridge, a piece of a sponge and ceramic rings for more media for the bacteria to grow on!
Hope this helps

Edit: for the filter you have, you can put an intake sponge over it and it will still work. Filters aren't only for taking stuff out of the water, it's also to hold the beneficial bacteria that will break down waste and help get rid of ammonia and nitrites. A gravel vacuum would get everything out of the substrate and in my opinion, owning a gravel vacuum is a must for everyone no matter what type of filtration or what size tank you have. They're inexpensive too.
 
Toggle Sidebar

Aquarium Calculator

Follow FishLore!





Top Bottom