I am no expert on power filters, but here's a question - what kind of tank will you be using? For tanks with only fish, HOB filters like these work reasonably well; for planted tanks, the variable flow patterns inherent to HOB filters (just change the distance between the outflow and the water surface) can play havoc with CO2 levels and may be excessively good at offgassing, so something with an internal outflow (such as a canister filter, an internal power filter, or a refugium/sump) where the current can be kept more consistent would work better.
I know a lot of people run Aquaclear HOB filters and they are very happy with them. I had one years ago and it was great, never a hiccup from it. They have a decent media capacity as well which allows for some nice customization.
I've seen some complaints on the Tidal skimmer sucking up food that's still floating, causing the filter to clog up, but I keep my skimmer setting set to about half, it is adjustable, and I've never had any problems with clogging. I also keep the filter on the far left side of my tank and feed on the far left right side, so that may help. I just really like that the water flows from bottom to top. Their sponge sits on the bottom, I have poly-fill packed between the sponge and the bio-bag, and I'm totally happy with mine.