Bdbs Choices?

Mick Frost

Member
I use PFS, have for a while, and there are worse things than paying $0.80/lb.
I've been looking through alternative substrates available locally, and I'm a little lost. I have a properly sized (20-40) Coal Slag product available, but the MSDS lists a bunch of metals. The more expensive one is 35 grit and says Stable/Insoluble. Otherwise I could go with a PFS sized 10-20, or a Pure Silica Sand sized 20-30. All of these are 0.25-0.35/lb. Does anyone with experience with these have any suggestions?
 

Thunder_o_b

Member
I use BDBS in all but 1 aquarium. The 1 has pool filter sand. Both are good.

BDBS is $8.00 for 50 lb. pool filter sand is $12.00 for 50 lb.

Not sure how that translates to Canada.
 

finnipper59

Member
Mick Frost said:
I use PFS, have for a while, and there are worse things than paying $0.80/lb.
I've been looking through alternative substrates available locally, and I'm a little lost. I have a properly sized (20-40) Coal Slag product available, but the MSDS lists a bunch of metals. The more expensive one is 35 grit and says Stable/Insoluble. Otherwise I could go with a PFS sized 10-20, or a Pure Silica Sand sized 20-30. All of these are 0.25-0.35/lb. Does anyone with experience with these have any suggestions?
I wouldn't use the pure silica. Silicates tent to over produce diatoms...which most people refer to as brown algae.
 
  • Thread Starter

Mick Frost

Member
finnipper59 said:
I wouldn't use the pure silica. Silicates tent to over produce diatoms...which most people refer to as brown algae.
Silica sand doesn't "produce" anything, it's inert. It does need agitation (like any other fine substrate) to avoid problems, but diatoms are not high on that list. My question regarding the silica sands were about the sizing, as I have a lot of catfish.
 
  • Thread Starter

Mick Frost

Member
Thunder_o_b said:
I use BDBS in all but 1 aquarium. The 1 has pool filter sand. Both are good.

BDBS is $8.00 for 50 lb. pool filter sand is $12.00 for 50 lb.

Not sure how that translates to Canada.
Black Diamond brand isn't available here. I pay over $40 for 50lbs of 20-40 PFS.
 

Most photos, videos and links are disabled if you are not logged in.

Log in or register to view

Top Bottom