Anyone Used Tantora Mineral Stone?

Mistwalker

Active Member
Member
Messages
119
and if so does it do any good or is it snake oil? I've been looking at some at the link below.
 

CaptAnnDuchow

Well Known
Member
Messages
1,728
I ordered something off amazon that says it does the same stuff just a different name..they will be here tomorrow.. I can inform you in a few days of any changes..hence the reason I'm commenting so that I can find this thread again.
What I ordered is
SunGrow Mineral Rocks - Provide Magnesium that enhances Shrimp's Color - Calcium helps molting - Absorb Toxic Chemical in Water - For Shrimps, Crayfish & Snails
 
  • Thread starter
  • Thread Starter
  • #3
OP
Mistwalker

Mistwalker

Active Member
Member
Messages
119
Ann Daniel said:
I ordered something off amazon that says it does the same stuff just a different name..they will be here tomorrow.. I can inform you in a few days of any changes..hence the reason I'm commenting so that I can find this thread again.
What I ordered is
SunGrow Mineral Rocks - Provide Magnesium that enhances Shrimp's Color - Calcium helps molting - Absorb Toxic Chemical in Water - For Shrimps, Crayfish & Snails
That does look like it's the same thing, Ann. I'll be ointerested to see how you get on with it. Thanks for letting me know.
 

CaptAnnDuchow

Well Known
Member
Messages
1,728
Mistwalker said:
That does look like it's the same thing, Ann. I'll be ointerested to see how you get on with it. Thanks for letting me know.
My shrimp and snails go no where near these .. My PH has not changed and either has my TDS..don't waste your money..the wecI wonder shells did much more and are cheaper.
 
  • Thread starter
  • Thread Starter
  • #5
OP
Mistwalker

Mistwalker

Active Member
Member
Messages
119
Ann Daniel said:
My shrimp and snails go no where near these .. My PH has not changed and either has my TDS..don't waste your money..the wecI wonder shells did much more and are cheaper.
Thanks for letting me know, Ann. I'll give those Wonder shells a try instead.
 

aae0130

Well Known
Member
Messages
627
Wouldn’t it need to be in there a while? It’s a rock of sorts and would need time to leech out. Yes???

When you say they went nowhere near it.....are you thinking they are supposed to eat it or sit on it? I think it just slowly dissolves (slow being the keyword). The trace elements are released to the water. It wouldn’t be something perceivable in a day.....
 

CaptAnnDuchow

Well Known
Member
Messages
1,728
aae0130 said:
Wouldn’t it need to be in there a while? It’s a rock of sorts and would need time to leech out. Yes???

When you say they went nowhere near it.....are you thinking they are supposed to eat it or sit on it? I think it just slowly dissolves (slow being the keyword). The trace elements are released to the water. It wouldn’t be something perceivable in a day.....
5 days not just 1 ..my tds should have changed at least by .01 and they were exactly the same. My tds meter is very accurate. And my snails and shrimp all go to the weco wonder shells so that is where that comparison came in.
this is my meter.
 

aae0130

Well Known
Member
Messages
627
Guess that’s another product that can have its ad on the sea monkey page.

Btw....thanks for that link. They have some things I would be interested in.
 

CaptAnnDuchow

Well Known
Member
Messages
1,728
aae0130 said:
Guess that’s another product that can have its ad on the sea monkey page.

Btw....thanks for that link. They have some things I would be interested in.
Yw I love buying from them!! Amazing products.
 

New Threads

Follow FishLore!

FishLore on Social Media

Online statistics

Members online
75
Guests online
1,883
Total visitors
1,958

Aquarium Photo Contests

Aquarium Calculator

Top Bottom