Am I Overstocked?

Frani

Member
I have a 20gal with 4 guppies (male) and 2 Corydoras, used to have 3 Corys but one of them disappeared. Will I be ok adding 2 more Corys and then two platys? Will that be overstocked? Should I just stick with the
Corys?
 

Alex Pasquale

Member
You will be perfectly fine adding in 2 more Cory Cats don't worry about it. Cory's don't take up much stock to begin with, not to mention they are cleaning your substrate constantly. As for the Plattys, same thing, they don't take up much space so you'll be fine adding them in. Just keep up with your filtration and your water changes.
 
  • Thread Starter

Frani

Member
Can I still add two more platys after I add the corys without being overstocked?
 

AquaticJ

Member
I'd recommend getting at least 3 more Cories, they should be in groups 6+. Adding 2 Platies should be fine, but I wouldn't add after that. Is this a 20 gallon long or a 20 gallon high?
 

Alex Pasquale

Member
Frani said:
Can I still add two more platys after I add the corys without being overstocked?
Yeah of course, they don't take up that much space as I said. As long as your filtration is good, and you keep up with your water changes, you will be perfectly fine.

AquaticJ said:
I'd recommend getting at least 3 more Cories, they should be in groups 6+. Adding 2 Platies should be fine, but I wouldn't add after that. Is this a 20 gallon long or a 20 gallon high?
Having Cory's in 6+ groups is a complete myth. That's not necessarily true. I have had them in tanks by themselves, with 2 of them, with 3 of them, with 8 of them, etc. They don't need to be kept in groups of 6.
 
  • Thread Starter

Frani

Member
Thanks for the advice, my tank is 20gal long
 

Alex Pasquale

Member
Frani said:
Thanks for the advice, my tank is 20gal long
You are quite welcome, enjoy your day.
 

FriarThomasIII

Member
Depends. 20 high has a smaller foot print than a normal or long. Corydoras need to be in groups of at least 6. Guppies and Platies can interbreed, though they won't be fertile most times, so get males. That stock should be fine, but no more.
 

AquaticJ

Member
Alex Pasquale said:
Having Cory's in 6+ groups is a complete myth. That's not necessarily true. I have had them in tanks by themselves, with 2 of them, with 3 of them, with 8 of them, etc. They don't need to be kept in groups of 6.
How is it a myth? It's a schooling fish. Schooling fish do best in groups of 6 or more.
 

Smalltownfishfriend

Member
Alex Pasquale said:
Having Cory's in 6+ groups is a complete myth. That's not necessarily true. I have had them in tanks by themselves, with 2 of them, with 3 of them, with 8 of them, etc. They don't need to be kept in groups of 6.
Hmm.. I had only three cories... I hardly ever saw them.. they were very shy and skittish.. I now have around 8.. I see them all the time and they are very playful and fun to watch.. so I have to politely disagree with you on that!!!
 

FriarThomasIII

Member
Alex Pasquale said:
Having Cory's in 6+ groups is a complete myth. That's not necessarily true. I have had them in tanks by themselves, with 2 of them, with 3 of them, with 8 of them, etc. They don't need to be kept in groups of 6.
Wait a second man. You CAN keep one, but the corydoras will just be miserable. They are shoaling fish and are very social. Not a myth. When alone, they are stressed and scared, and more susceptible to disease.
 

JamieXPXP

Member
you don't have to keep schooling fish in groups but it is recommended because they will feel more secure and act more natural in a group then if they were by themselves. I used to keep corys in just a pair and they were miserable, stressed and inactive. sometimes they can do well in just small groups of 3 but is rare

but it sounds like your stocking plan will be just fine
 

Most photos, videos and links are disabled if you are not logged in.

Log in or register to view

Top Bottom