Algae eater with male Betta ?

HOWsMom

Are there any algae eaters I can put in a 5-gallon or 6-gallon tank with a male Betta ?
 

Furallicah

Hello! I have cory cats and a snail in each of my male betta 5gal tanks. Really it depends on that bettas personality if you can keep anything with them.
 

dacrax07

For algae eater, I recommend cherry shrimp or amano shrimp, depending on your bettas personality. Usually, they get along well, especially if there are plenty of hiding places.
 

e_watson09

If your tank were a little larger like a 10 gal there would be no problem with putting some type of pleco in there with it (if you go with the varieties that stay rather small) but since you have a smaller tank I would reccoment some type of shrimp. To be honest I work at a pet store and I know the only freshwater shrimp that we ALWAYS have are ghost shrimp and they keep the tank VERY clean and they are only like 89cents each.

Watch out if you're going with a snail many (maybe most I can't remember) can multiply on their own and you will end up with THOUSANDS of snails, your tank will be clean, but who really wants a thousand snails in their little 5 gal?
 

bassbonediva

Watch out if you're going with a snail many (maybe most I can't remember) can multiply on their own and you will end up with THOUSANDS of snails, your tank will be clean, but who really wants a thousand snails in their little 5 gal?

I believe you're thinking of pond snails, which are generally regarded as pests by everyone. They are asexual, so they don't need a mate to reproduce. Mystery snails, apple snails, and nerite snails require a mate to reproduce, so if you only have one, you won't have any unwanted babies.
 

rae64

A pleco in a 10 gallon is not a good idea, just to note (I know the OP does not have a 10 gallon) Some people get away with corys, but IMO snails are much better suited for bettas.
 

e_watson09

I believe you're thinking of pond snails, which are generally regarded as pests by everyone. They are asexual, so they don't need a mate to reproduce. Mystery snails, apple snails, and nerite snails require a mate to reproduce, so if you only have one, you won't have any unwanted babies.

Oh I bought a snail that was listed as "mystery snail" and I got it and then a few months later had THOUSANDS of babies. But maybe it was just a mistake.

A pleco in a 10 gallon is not a good idea, just to note (I know the OP does not have a 10 gallon) Some people get away with corys, but IMO snails are much better suited for bettas.

Some pleco breeds stay small and get a max of 3" and those variety are fine in a 10 gal.
 

rae64

I would still be cautious with the plecos though... what breeds stay that little?
 

bolivianbaby

Some pleco breeds stay small and get a max of 3" and those variety are fine in a 10 gal.

I respectfully disagree. IMO-the smaller plecos shouldn't be kept in anything smaller than a 20g. They produce a lot of waste.
 

HOWsMom

So far, I'm avoiding getting anything. I'll likely get a snail in the long run.
 

Etcetera

The whole need for a "helper fish" is really just hype. You don't need a helper fish to eat algae/detritus--since all they do is turn that algae/detritus into large amounts of unsightly poop.

The tank in question is not ideal for cories, since they should live in schools of 6 or more, not ideal for otos since it is not mature and they prefer to be in groups of 3 or more, and not ideal for any type of pleco because of the size and the amount of waste they produce.

Some people say shrimp are good with bettas--but I have had tons of shrimp and many bettas over the years, some of these bettas have tolerated other fish and ADFs and the like--but never has any kind of shrimp lasted more than a couple months with my bettas. They always get eaten eventually.

Snails are really your best bet if you want something that can effectively clean the algae off the glass and your plants. If you control the amount of light and the amount of food you put in your tank, the population will not explode. Each of my tanks has malaysian trumpet snails and each one has one large ramshorn snail which does most of the cleaning. I've tried adding more ramshorns to the tank, but when I do, one always out-competes the other for food and the other dies. Population control really isn't an issue.
 

Furallicah

I have to agree. Snails are usually the best option. I would just get one though for a 5gal mainly if it is a mystery snail....I have one the size of a half dollar. So they get pretty big and loveable lol.
 

Emily1234

try a bristle-nose catfish I have one in with my fighter at the moment and they are fine together. They are in a 5 gallen tank the moment and the catfish will eventually get to about 15cm but that will take over 5 years for him to get that big. I wouldnt recommend snails.
 

mishykinz

I was thinking about getting some snails for my divided betta tank. Should I just get 1 snail or a snail for each divided part?
 

e_watson09

I would still be cautious with the plecos though... what breeds stay that little?

Umm for sure a Rubber pleco, then some type a bristlenose or something that we have at work, then also a clown pleco (not a loach a actual pleco) But those are just the ones we keep in stock

I respectfully disagree. IMO-the smaller plecos shouldn't be kept in anything smaller than a 20g. They produce a lot of waste.

I agree that it would require a lot of cleaning due to the waste but I was just stating that it is an option. I didn't know exactly how much space they needed I just knew they stayed small.
 

HOWsMom

Snails are really sounding like a good plan here !
 

Furallicah

try a bristle-nose catfish I have one in with my fighter at the moment and they are fine together. They are in a 5 gallen tank the moment and the catfish will eventually get to about 15cm but that will take over 5 years for him to get that big. I wouldnt recommend snails.

True but not every betta would let something likethat in their tank. It still all boils down to personality. And I'm only suggest one snail. But if you get more you'll have to manage your food.
 

McAttack

I would still be cautious with the plecos though... what breeds stay that little?

I have a female bristlenose pleco and she's MAYBE 3". A year old. very shy.
 

HOWsMom

I took the chance - and Wan Bo Bo has been content living with a couple of ghost shrimp and a yellow snail for a while now.
 

Tigerfishy

Hope it continues to go well for you, congrats!
 

Similar Aquarium Threads

Replies
7
Views
102
BigManAquatics
  • Question
Replies
7
Views
144
MacZ
  • Question
Replies
1
Views
109
jkkgron2
Replies
8
Views
182
Skittlesttr75
Replies
19
Views
254
Fisch

Random Great Thread

New Betta Threads

Latest Aquarium Threads

Top Bottom