Advice Please

Status
Not open for further replies.

Gonoli

Valued Member
Messages
72
Reaction score
29
Points
43
Experience
3 years
It honestly depends on the temperament of your betta me and my friend used to have a betta in a 10 gallon with some mollies and they did just fine together no aggression and everything was fine
 

david1978

Fishlore Legend
Messages
13,081
Reaction score
9,340
Points
758
Location
pa usa
Experience
More than 10 years
Shrimp have a very low bio load so you can have many. Some bettas will eat them as did mine but some wont. Most suggest trying ghost shrimp to see if they will get eaten or not as they are cheap and if they are eaten is a good quality snack for the betta. With snails it would depend on which snail you are interested in but typically you can do 3-4
 

Jyl080208

Valued Member
Messages
168
Reaction score
34
Points
53
Location
Washington state
Experience
Just started
Be careful with shrimp too. There needs to be a lot of cover, and plenty for the shrimp to eat. I had a few shrimp with a betta, and they would grab at his tail. But once I upgraded to a bigger tank they were fine
 

seth rodgers

Valued Member
Messages
194
Reaction score
11
Points
53
Shrimp are also very sensitive and i would recommend doing the drip method when acclimating them.. i love snails, i have 3 in seperate tanks and they help alot and honestly are cool to look at. i would recommend snails but shrimp are very cool as well! i would t recommend putting other fish in with the betta though however you could do a different combination of fish!
 

Thunder_o_b

Fishlore VIP
Messages
9,484
Reaction score
5,849
Points
508
Location
North East Ohio…USA
Experience
More than 10 years
Where do you get this idea? Totally false.
Being new to fish keeping, how are you able to say this is Totally false?


Male bettas are a poor choice for a community aquarium. They can be fine for months and then kill everything around them. Then there are males that are fine for years.

I have had both. It is not worth the risk.
 

Mcasella

Fishlore VIP
Messages
8,305
Reaction score
4,296
Points
458
Location
Virginia
Experience
5 to 10 years
Where do you get this idea? Totally false.
The quoted post is the safest measure for the animals involved, more experience is needed before you try and set up a community with betta. Other fish with betta can ended badly for all involved. The betta can be shy and become stressed by the other fish without them ever touching him and due as a result. The betta can go months without damaging anything then one morning you wake up to everything dead except the betta who is now parading around like a champion fighter. Your other fish could think the betta's fins look tasty and pick on him because he can't get away. Your betta can murder the fish you have slowly or the fish will be terrified of him and hide all the time. Males and females are equally aggressive and can act out jealousy. Placing them with snails or shrimp provides the least likely amount of damage possible. Ghost shrimp are used to test how live food hungry/hunter the betta is. However some betta will snack on more colorful shrimp and leave ghosts alone. It depends on the betta's personality, some can handle it, some even decimate snails.
We here Gove the safest route of pairing things to avoid catstrophy and try to help make sure your fish are able to thrive, not just manage to stay alive.
 

Frozen One

Valued Member
Messages
333
Reaction score
87
Points
38
Location
Bay Area, California
Experience
Just started
Being new to fish keeping, how are you able to say this is Totally false?


Male bettas are a poor choice for a community aquarium. They can be fine for months and then kill everything around them. Then there are males that are fine for years.

I have had both. It is not worth the risk.
There is no fact when it comes to behavior. It’s not a fact that a betta will do anything many think they will. How vast is your knowledge of Betta fish? Are you aware there are wild types that are completely docile? There are wild types that won’t bother anybody in a tank. As for the splendens it really just depends on the fish. Fish are like humans in the respect that no one fish is exactly like another.
 

Thunder_o_b

Fishlore VIP
Messages
9,484
Reaction score
5,849
Points
508
Location
North East Ohio…USA
Experience
More than 10 years
There is no fact when it comes to behavior. It’s not a fact that a betta will do anything many think they will. How vast is your knowledge of Betta fish? Are you aware there are wild types that are completely docile? There are wild types that won’t bother anybody in a tank. As for the splendens it really just depends on the fish. Fish are like humans in the respect that no one fish is exactly like another.
Is over 50 years of fish keeping enough to satisfy you?

EDIT: It is a given that on non specialized betta forums when one asks about a betta with other fish it is a male splenden not a wild cousin.

Ask the OP if he was asking about a wild betta or a common one from a pet store.

Your argument is absurd.
 
Last edited:

Frozen One

Valued Member
Messages
333
Reaction score
87
Points
38
Location
Bay Area, California
Experience
Just started
Is over 50 years of fish keeping enough to satisfy you?

EDIT: It is a given that on non specialized betta forums when one asks about a betta with other fish is a male splenden not a wild cousin.

Ask the OP if he was asking about a wild betta or a common one from a pet store.

Your argument is absurd.
No you’re just very mad and it’s evident. I wonder what splendens derive from.. hmm there is no argument. This is a matter of opinion.
 

Thunder_o_b

Fishlore VIP
Messages
9,484
Reaction score
5,849
Points
508
Location
North East Ohio…USA
Experience
More than 10 years
No you’re just very mad and it’s evident. I wonder what splendens derive from.. hmm there is no argument. This is a matter of opinion.
You are right I am mad, this forum has been flooded with people completely lacking in hands on experience with fish talking like they are experts and the fish suffer.

Yes they come from wild stock. That statement just highlights your absurdity. That is like saying a collie comes from a wolf in the wild so they are the same.
 

Frozen One

Valued Member
Messages
333
Reaction score
87
Points
38
Location
Bay Area, California
Experience
Just started
Yeah you seem very passionate. I didn’t say they were the same. did they teach evolution when you were in school? (Not a subjective question). Every species can exhibit qualities and characteristics of the species they derive from. I’m not saying I’m an expert. By no means am I an expert, which I’ve stated on numerous responses. I said that the whole idea of Betta only being able to be with shrimp and snails in a 10 gallon is “absurd” because I’ve done it. Successfully. Of course you can tell me, “one day you might wake up and all of your fish are dead” but I don’t think that’s likely at all. Didn’t mean to hurt your feelings. Genuinely sorry if I did. It’s hard (almost impossible) to understand someone’s tone when you can’t actually hear them.
 

Thunder_o_b

Fishlore VIP
Messages
9,484
Reaction score
5,849
Points
508
Location
North East Ohio…USA
Experience
More than 10 years
Yeah you seem very passionate. I didn’t say they were the same. did they teach evolution when you were in school? (Not a subjective question). Every species can exhibit qualities and characteristics of the species they derive from. I’m not saying I’m an expert. By no means am I an expert, which I’ve stated on numerous responses. I said that the whole idea of Betta only being able to be with shrimp and snails in a 10 gallon is “absurd” because I’ve done it. Successfully. Of course you can tell me, “one day you might wake up and all of your fish are dead” but I don’t think that’s likely at all. Didn’t mean to hurt your feelings. Genuinely sorry if I did. It’s hard (almost impossible) to understand someone’s tone when you can’t actually hear them.
Condescending , nice switch of tact.

I'll end this right now. You are added to my ignore list. We shall not cross on this forum again. There too many good people to help and learn from here to waste more time on you.
 

Kristian Acevedo

Valued Member
Messages
224
Reaction score
102
Points
38
Experience
1 year
To Op, you could also go the route of nano fish (cpds, embers, chili rasboras) or C. Habrosus (salt and pepper cories) or C. Hastasus (dwarf cory). All of these would be fine in a 10g with a betta, but you have to be extremely careful to watch behavior, and it’s advisable to add the betta last, so he has a higher likelihood of excepting the fish as part of his habitat. Best of luck to you!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Toggle Sidebar

Water Change Frequency?

  • Daily

    Votes: 4 2.9%
  • Weekly

    Votes: 92 66.2%
  • Every Two Weeks

    Votes: 16 11.5%
  • Monthly

    Votes: 2 1.4%
  • As Needed (from test kit results or based on knowing your tank)

    Votes: 25 18.0%




Top Bottom