If your current setup is working, i.e., good foam in the skimmer, and the skimmer isn't over-flowing, and your return, (
sump tank) isn't over-flowing or very low then i would use a pump of the same gph that you have now. If i am not mistaken some aquamedic's come with the pump as part of the set-up, if this is the case i would replace with the same model/type as the current pump. Otherwise, if the set-up you are using now works - i would keep everything the same - as of course when you change one thing in the pathway of the water flow, that usually means changes occur somewhere else along the pathway of the water return.