randrjax

I just got these two fish from the store. At the store they looked like a male and female pair. Now they look like 2 males. What do you think?

Attached Images

	Platy 1a.JPG (79.6 KB, 18 views)
	Platy 2a.JPG (80.6 KB, 17 views)

Cherrry123

The second picture is a female platy, I'm not so sure about the other one

randrjax

I posted this on the Freshwater topic but wanted to try and catch everyone's opinion (plus I took some better pics). What sex do you think these two are? I thought one was male and one was female but once I got them home I don't know. What do you think?

Attached Images

	plat1.JPG (101.9 KB, 17 views)
	plat2.JPG (136.9 KB, 19 views)

Cherrry123

They look like a female to me.

andy65

female

COBettaCouple

Welcome to Fishlore.

Beautiful coloring on the platys. They look identical and I think you have 2 females. Their anal fins are both fan-shaped?

randrjax

Thanks! We thought they had good color too. They have the fan shaped anal fin but you can see how it is a little pointed. We have one other that is definatly female but these two swim around with without the anal fin faned out and the way it is pointed proved to be misleading when I was at the store.

finmama

Looks like they are both females. Sometimes they hold the fin against their body and it looks like a gonopodium.

guppiemaster892

The second one looks like a female but i am not sure about the first one.

swords3711

I hate to say it but unlike what everyone else said, they are now males. Their anal fins are folding over so they are becoming male.One of my female swords' anal fin is folding over. She'll be male very soon.

Eagles Fan

male