Hi cherrycoke:
Have you considered getting an electronic thermometer? These units are more accurate than those placed in the outside surface of the tank. I do use cheap inside the tank, red dyed alcohol thermometers but their error of measurement is a concern, I have one that reads 2degrees over the actual temp.
As for a definite solution, have you considered getting a mini
chiller?
I live in the Caribbean basin (Santo Domingo) and I have two units that I keep in standby to cool down one particular tank (208L or 55gal) that is in the living room; tank temp there climbs easily slightly above 30C (86F) when the hot days of summer come by. These use up a fair amount of energy that is evident in my energy bill.
Thermoelectric chillers use less energy than conventional compressor chillers. Since you have a small tank you could use a thermoelectric chiller rated at 150W (e.g. Resun CL-150), these units are easily installed with a submersible water pump or power head.
Be aware that the info in the technical manuals can overstate their efficient capacity; so in the manual of a small unit like the Resun CL-80 you would see that the manufacturer claims it works for a 5 degrees Celcius pull down in tanks up to 16 gallons. That claim is based in experimental conditions which do not resemble our usual settings. I share this info with you since this is the reason I ended having two units instead of just one: I went by the technical data and purchased, installed and kept running (inefficiently in terms of energy use and long term lifetime of compressor) the Resun CL-280 which I later replaced with the CL-600.
Pepe
Santo Domingo