Thanks everybody. William and Michael said "slurp!". They were my only ones big enough to enjoy the worms, and to be perfectly honest I just really wasn't into cutting them up. The creep factor was way to much for me, the slicing and dicing of wormies reminds me way to much of a bad horror flick I saw as a teen. William circled the first worm a few times then slurped him right up, didn't hesitate on the next 2. Michael attacked and destroyed 3 in seconds. I don't use chemical pesticides or fertilizers on any of my plants or my lawn so I felt safe giving them to the fish after Chief posted (I didn't want to give them anything that could potentially be harmful, or a non-food source). I've been watching them closely since...just to make sure they'd be ok. I think they're begging for more, but their little bellys are plenty full now

Once again, thanks everybody!