Tropical Fish Tank and Aquarium Information

Go Back   Fish Lore Tropical Fish and Aquarium Forum > Freshwater Aquarium Fish Forum > Freshwater Tank Equipment > Filters and Filtration

Filters and Filtration Forum for discussing freshwater aquarium filter options such as canister filters, hang on tank filters, filter GPH (Gallons Per Hour), etc. - Aquarium Filter and Filtration Articles

Join Fish Lore Aquarium Forum

Search Fish Lore Facebook 
Google+
Twitter


Aquarium Forum
General
Welcome To FishLore
Using the Forum
General Discussion
Members Fish Tanks
Photos and Videos
Member Photos
Member Videos
Freshwater Aquarium Forum
Freshwater Beginners
Freshwater Equipment
More Freshwater Topics
Freshwater Fish & Inverts
Ponds
Saltwater Aquarium Forum
Saltwater Beginners
Saltwater Equipment
More Saltwater Topics
Saltwater Fish & Inverts
Member Blogs
Member Blogs
Misc. Topics
Reviews
Aquarium Fish Clubs
Buy, Sell, Trade
Fish Profiles
Freshwater Fish
Saltwater Fish
Fish Forum Archives
Closed Thread
 
Fish Forum Thread Tools
Old October 13th, 2009  
Fish Lore Newbie
 
Need 'dead silent' filter

I am looking for a "DEAD SILENT" filter for a 10 gallon aquarium (so I wont disturb my roommate).

What do you guys recommend? I've read that canister filters were very quiet. And if they are indeed the quietest types of filter, which specific one would you recommend. I am a poor college student so I am looking for something under $50.

My second question is,
I currently just bought an aqua tech filter 30-60 gal and installed it. Would Wal-Mart allow me to refund this? It's too loud for my needs.


Thanks!
-Tim

Last edited by tinywang; October 13th, 2009 at 01:09 AM.
tinywang is offline  
Old October 13th, 2009  
Fish Master
 
I would think most canisters would be too big for your purposes but I'm sure you guys in the states get much more to choose from than us aussies. For a small tank like yours you could just use a little internal filter that makes no noise what-so-ever or if the roomie doesn't mind the sound of bubbles just use a pair of box filters run off an air pump & gang valve. Stick the air pump in a small foam esky to keep it quiet.

Don't know Walmarts refund policy but scrub the bejabbers out of the filter so it looks & smells like new then tell them it doesn't work properly. They probably won't even take it out of the box to check it anyway.
Nutter is offline  
Old October 13th, 2009  
Fish Bum
 
A duetto 50 or 100 is probably down your alley.As it is an internal filter that works quite well.

And I'm sure if you complain enough Walmart will let you refund it.
Peffico is offline  
Old October 13th, 2009  
Moderator
 
Good morning. Some good suggestions above. You may want to check out the Aqua Clear 20 (100gph) It's a hang on back type filter. I have 3 of them in different tanks. I actually have to check to make sure it's still running it's so quiet. A link for it is below.
http://www.drsfostersmith.com/produc...fm?pcatid=3610
Have fun shopping!
Ken
aquarist48 is offline  
Old October 13th, 2009  
Fish Lore Newbie
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by aquarist48 View Post
Good morning. Some good suggestions above. You may want to check out the Aqua Clear 20 (100gph) It's a hang on back type filter. I have 3 of them in different tanks. I actually have to check to make sure it's still running it's so quiet. A link for it is below.
http://www.drsfostersmith.com/produc...fm?pcatid=3610
Have fun shopping!
Ken
so no noise at all?? not even the sound of the water pouring down or the impeller spinning? that is my biggest criteria, can't have any sound at all.
tinywang is offline  
Old October 13th, 2009  
Fish Keeper
 
http://www.drsfostersmith.com/produc...id=16742&r=487

You may have to replace the hoses with these but the hoses do not cost much.
eiginh is offline  
Old October 13th, 2009  
Fish Master
 
For no sound at all an internal filter is best. Aquaclear's are very quiet and regular maintainence should keep them that way. However if the water in your tank gets low you do have the waterfall type sound.
Red1313 is offline  
Old October 13th, 2009  
Fish Keeper
 
I have several aquaclears and they are silent............
redlessi is offline  
Old October 13th, 2009  
Fish Master
 
For a 10 gallon, the wisper 10i (internal) or 20i get my vote. They are as silent as it gets, primarily bacuase the filter is inside.

The eclipse tanks are dead silent as well, IME.
Jaysee is offline  
Old October 14th, 2009  
Fish Keeper
 
I heard eclipse tanks are good but they are quite expensive!
eiginh is offline  
Old October 16th, 2009  
Fish Lore Newbie
 
hey guys,

after yalls inputs, i bought the aquaclear 30 and its not 'dead silent' unfortunately. the motor seems to be making a rumbling noise. it's not like SUPER LOUD but it is audible and it gets kinda irritating after awhile.

i am wondering if any of u guys also have this problem and if i should just take it back and exchange it for a new one?

thanks! cleaning wise, this thing does wonders!
tinywang is offline  
Old October 16th, 2009  
Fish Master
 
You could try returning it - it's uncommon, but not unheard of that an AC is bad out of the box.

When I made the switch to ACs, I noticed that at first too. So, either they went away or I got used to them cause I no longer hear it.

You'll get used to it
Jaysee is offline  
Old October 16th, 2009  
Fish Lore Newbie
 
i might but roommate wont. that's the problem =/
tinywang is offline  
Old October 16th, 2009  
Fish Master
 
Personally, not being the sort of person to take much rubbish from people, I would simply tell the roomie to get over it. Then turn up your stereo with music you know they hate & ask them which one they prefer, the music or the fish tank. You have tried to please them, they can't ask much more than that.
Nutter is offline  
Old October 16th, 2009  
Fish Master
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by tinywang View Post
i might but roommate wont. that's the problem =/
Yeah they will - If they hear it everyday. It's white noise.
Jaysee is offline  
Old October 16th, 2009  
Moderator
 
Hello Tiny. If you have your receipt I would exchange it. All of mine (3 of them) are completely silent. I actually have to check the current to make sure mine are even running.
Ken
aquarist48 is offline  
Old October 16th, 2009  
Fish Lore Newbie
 
ok guys, i exchanged it and i'm still getting the same problem. i bought this from petco and i feel bad if i go back and exchange it for YET another one. i'm pretty sure they wont let me either.

i looked up this problem on youtube and it seems i am not the only one..
this is pretty much what mine sounds like.


any idea how to fix this!?
tinywang is offline  
Old October 16th, 2009  
Fish Master
 
I don't have any lids on my ACs because of the rattle. So, my advice is to.....take off the lid.

As far as FIXING it, you could get some rubber material to make a gasket and silicone it to filter lid.

Last edited by Jaysee; October 16th, 2009 at 11:34 PM.
Jaysee is offline  
Old October 16th, 2009  
Fish Lore Newbie
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jaysee View Post
I don't have any lids on my ACs because of the rattle. So, my advice is to.....take off the lid.

As far as FIXING it, you could get some rubber material to make a gasket and silicone it to filter lid.
it is not the lid. even without the lid, i get that noise.
tinywang is offline  
Old October 16th, 2009  
Fish Master
 
I have 8 ACs running in my room and all I can hear is the 1 emperor - Take it back for another one. If they give you a hard time, get a refund and go to another store.

You've taken apart the motor assembly and put it back together?

In the video, the noise went away when the lid was removed.

AC's are silent when compared to other HOBs, but they are not completely silent. As was stated earlier, the quietest filter you can get is an internal one. Since the motor is inside the tank, the noise doesn't make it out. For your 10 gallon, I would suggest the whisper 20i. http://www.drsfostersmith.com/produc...5&pcatid=12085

My 10i is SILENT.
Jaysee is offline  
Old October 16th, 2009  
Fish Lore Newbie
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jaysee View Post
I have 8 ACs running in my room and all I can hear is the 1 emperor - Take it back for another one. If they give you a hard time, get a refund and go to another store.

You've taken apart the motor assembly and put it back together?

In the video, the noise went away when the lid was removed.

AC's are silent when compared to other HOBs, but they are not completely silent. As was stated earlier, the quietest filter you can get is an internal one. Since the motor is inside the tank, the noise doesn't make it out. For your 10 gallon, I would suggest the whisper 20i. http://www.drsfostersmith.com/produc...5&pcatid=12085

My 10i is SILENT.
thanks for ur help jaysee. yes i've taken it apart and assembled it again same problem. in the video, the noise was still there despite lid being removed. again, i am looking for a 'DEAD SILENT' zero noise filter!!

im thinking about getting a whisper 20i. but are those for sure ZERO noise i dont think i will be able to refund the ac 30 cause i already exchanged it and they asked if i wanted to try a different filter and i said no. so i guess i will just have to buy another filter. =(


what filters have ZERO NADA noise!??
tinywang is offline  
Old October 17th, 2009  
Fish Keeper
 
Petco will exchange no matter what, just make sure it's clean. I read a lot of reviews about whispers I even bought one my self before I bought an emperor 400. 4/10 says it gets loud. Look into the canister HOB filter I posted earlier, I think it was the rapids canister for up to 20-30 gallons. Oh when your exchanging your item don't go to the same person all the time. The staff will get p/o'ed and give you an attitude if they don't have the patience if you keep coming back to the same person but if they're really laid back they won't care. Trust me I exchanged at least 4-5 times when I first started keeping fish and decided at the end to buy an emperor 400 online. If you can try buying it online as well, Petco marks their prices 10 bucks over the msrp. You can keep using the filter you have while you wait for shipping b/c they have a 30 day money back guarantee.You can go to the sites listed on top of the links bar on the forum page or go to fish.com they're having a really good sale atm.

Last edited by eiginh; October 17th, 2009 at 12:17 AM.
eiginh is offline  
Old October 17th, 2009  
Fish Master
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by tinywang View Post
what filters have ZERO NADA noise!??
I have ACs, emperors, pengiuns, tetras, top fins, as well as a few others (HOBs). The ABSOLUTE quietest filter I have, that is COMPLETELY silent - no noise whatsoever - is my eclipse. The whisper 10i is silent, but the eclipse is DEAD SILENT. http://www.drsfostersmith.com/produc...67&pcatid=3867
Jaysee is offline  
Old October 17th, 2009  
Fish Lore Newbie
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jaysee View Post
I have ACs, emperors, pengiuns, tetras, top fins, as well as a few others (HOBs). The ABSOLUTE quietest filter I have, that is COMPLETELY silent - no noise whatsoever - is my eclipse. The whisper 10i is silent, but the eclipse is DEAD SILENT. http://www.drsfostersmith.com/produc...67&pcatid=3867
that thing is pricey! =/
tinywang is offline  
Old October 17th, 2009  
Fish Keeper
 
There hood is basically a penguin bio filter except it's built with the light and closes the whole tank. Are you not interested in the hob canister filter I posted earlier? I have read a lot of reviews that is great, you just need to replace the hose with an ehiem hose. It would be really quiet! Anyway if you want the eclipse hood, you can probably find a used on craigslist depending on your area. They even sell full tanks for $50.
eiginh is offline  
Old October 17th, 2009  
Fish Lore Newbie
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by eiginh View Post
There hood is basically a penguin bio filter except it's built with the light and closes the whole tank. Are you not interested in the hob canister filter I posted earlier? I have read a lot of reviews that is great, you just need to replace the hose with an ehiem hose. It would be really quiet! Anyway if you want the eclipse hood, you can probably find a used on craigslist depending on your area. They even sell full tanks for $50.
idkkk i am thinking about giving aquaclear ONE more try.

i am curious to know for those who say aquaclear is 'completely silent', do u guys not experience this mild humming noise caused by the motor? if not, I am wondering if these are just a defect.

Last edited by tinywang; October 17th, 2009 at 03:35 AM.
tinywang is offline  
Old October 17th, 2009  
Moderator
 
Hello Tinywang. My Aqua Clears have no hum period. I can look at my tanks and not hear a sound. I have to look closely to make sure it's still on and running!
Ken
aquarist48 is offline  
Old October 17th, 2009  
Fish Master
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by aquarist48 View Post
Hello Tinywang. My Aqua Clears have no hum period. I can look at my tanks and not hear a sound. I have to look closely to make sure it's still on and running!
Ken
Me too, but is it because we are used to it?


The hood is pricey, but you get a hood, light and filter all in one. And it's silent.

Give AC another shot - they're great filters and trust me, after a few weeks, you and your roommate won't hear a thing.
Jaysee is offline  
Closed Thread

Fish Forum Thread Tools

Fun Fish and Aquarium Games!
Fish Tycoon
Fish Tycoon
Insaniquarium - Insane Aquarium
Insaniquarium
Insane Aquarium
Jenny's Fish Shop
Jenny's
Fish Shop
FishCo
FishCo!


Similar Aquarium Fish Forum Threads
Thread Fish Forum
has anyone done a 'silent cycle'? Aquarium Nitrogen Cycle
Is An Aqua Clear Filter (Power Filter) Good for a 20 Gallon? Freshwater Beginners
Silent Air Battery Operated Air Pump by Penn Plax Misc. Reviews
filter + kuhli = dead? Kuhli Loach
!Gamers! Silent Hill General Discussion Archive



Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2012, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
LinkBacks Enabled by vBSEO 3.3.2 © 2009, Crawlability, Inc.
© Fish Lore.com - providing tropical fish tank and aquarium information for freshwater fish and saltwater fish keepers