ricktavious

I'm having a tough time deciding what to get for a 10 gallon tank. I was planning on 6 cardinal tetras, then 3 male guppies. Some have suggested get both, but there seems to be a bit of a question on if that would be overstocking the tank.

I have never owned either types of these fish, but both are nice looking and seem like they'd be enjoyable. Let's hear what yall have to say

eiginh

Go both but make sure you maintain it well, w/c weekly and pristine water.

Here's a list from agabr123, it helped me out. Hopefully it'll help you out.

Work In Progress: Freshwater Community Stocking List

ricktavious

Thanks for the reply....according to agabr, I should just stick with the 3 guppies or the school of tetras. However, you (and a few others) seem to think 6 tetras + 3 guppies would be fine with frequent changes. I just don't want to over do anything and keep all the little guys alive, happy, and healthy

Shawnie

overstocking a 10 gal is going to be very hard to maintain...IMO you wont enjoy it as much as you will be spending more of your time doing water changes than watching the tank....I say go with the cardinals and some plants..maybe a few snails

iloveengl

You could also throw in a bunch of RCS and wood shrimps. They're really cool looking and kinda hilarious when they suddenly decide to zoom around.

ricktavious

Thanks for the info folks! And pardon the ignorance, but what exactly is RCS?

iloveengl

I'm sorry - it means red cherry shrimp. very pretty little guys.

Nick G

Red Cherry Shrimp. They'd be a good addittion with the cardinals, although I personally think 6 Cardinals and 3 Male Guppies would be fine.

aquarist48

Hello Rick. I like the idea of a species only tank. I would go for the 6 to 9 Cardinal Tetras and some snails also. Keep up with your water chemistry and water changes.
I hope you keep us posted on your progress.

Rick would you be so kind as to fill out your profile aquarium information for us please? It would be a big help.
Ken

peacemaker92

I like shawnie and ilovee's stocking opinions. I'd get that too if I had a 10g, too bad I only have an 8g. LOL

You could also go with a betta? And have some snails with him or corycats if he's not so aggressive. Keep us posted in what you decide Best of luck!